[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/ext/alfredoramos/seometadata/event/listener.php on line 114: Undefined array key 10507519 [phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/ext/alfredoramos/seometadata/event/listener.php on line 114: Trying to access array offset on value of type null Micro 830: DoY II: Plato's Symposium! Lyncher/Inquisitor Win - Mafiascum.net
Post
Post #127 (isolation #7) » Thu Oct 25, 2018 5:38 pm
Postby BrightEyedFish »
In post 122, Krazy wrote:I do have an alt, but I guess it doesn't matter if you didn't already make that connection which somewhat disrupts my read of you.
OK well BEF -- would you like to join me on FA_Q?
I did the research, found your alt..
I'm not completely sold on your FA_Q read yet. I'll take a deeper look.
In post 168, BrightEyedFish wrote:I took it off because it was a pure RVS vote. Maybe it was placed correctly out of luck, but I can always throw it back if the situation arises.
so you looked at FA_Q's game there and noticed he had good reads, but didn't comment on the lack of an unvote and the lack of caution
the lack of caution is what is what I focus on. He is an aggressive, highly reactionary player as town
and he doesn't seem to be that way here
maybe it's because he's a double voter
or maybe it's because he's scum or third party
but what do you actually think of his reads in this game, and what do you think of his tonality in this game?
If FA's claim of being Socrates is to be believed, that could put him as a Lover/tragic lover in regards to Platos Symposium.
In post 176, BrightEyedFish wrote:If FA's claim of being Socrates is to be believed, that could put him as a Lover/tragic lover in regards to Platos Symposium.
so you're townreading someone because you like his flavor name and are into setup spec about roles that you don't even know are in the game?
AND UH WTF IF HES A TRAGIC LOVER THEN SHOULDNT YOU WANT TO LYNCH HIM?
I could be wrong. Just something I have sitting on the back burner. We are not in a rush right now, still plenty of time.
Post
Post #181 (isolation #19) » Thu Oct 25, 2018 6:49 pm
Postby BrightEyedFish »
In post 180, Krazy wrote:that's a terrible mentality. we have exactly as much time as we have until we decide on a lynch. the dayphase lasts as long as we decide, the timer is only there to keep it from turning into absurdity
Let's see what some of the others think about FA.
@InfernoBrafin
@Carcalilly
In post 172, BrightEyedFish wrote:Generally yes, but since this game is bastard it takes a little longer for my intuition to take hold
but why
all bastard means is that there are no limits on roles and the mod can change the rules
but players *right now* have been told they have certain roles. so until the mod *does something bastard* this is just a normal closed setup game
This is why I am not rushing to judgement with the little info that we have. I don't want to lock down in on my theories when we can potentially get a bastard surprise from mod.
Like I said, let's see how the next few pages go and then we will have more to work with.
I'm not disregarding your FOS on FAQ, personally I'm just not content with a vote on him (or anyone else) at this stage.
Post
Post #208 (isolation #22) » Fri Oct 26, 2018 5:49 pm
Postby BrightEyedFish »
I'm liking InfernoBrafin's read of the Carmen/FA posts.
I am eager to see Carmen's response to this. I am not fully against a Carmen lynch, seems like the best option we have right now, but let's give her a chance to respond.
Post
Post #222 (isolation #25) » Sun Oct 28, 2018 6:07 am
Postby BrightEyedFish »
In post 220, Carcalilly wrote:Ok, but we can still talk for future reference. What are your current opinions, Fishy?
I'm this its justified for Carmen being at L-1. I am still iffy on FA, but the sudden disappearance as me leaning also towards the scum spectrum.
Other than those two, I still am a little cautious with Krazy.
Post
Post #223 (isolation #26) » Sun Oct 28, 2018 6:08 am
Postby BrightEyedFish »
EPWOB
*I think it's justified for Carmen being at L-1. I am still iffy on FA, but the sudden disappearance as me leaning also towards the scum spectrum.
Other than those two, I still am a little cautious with Krazy.
Post
Post #273 (isolation #29) » Tue Oct 30, 2018 3:24 am
Postby BrightEyedFish »
Unless the mod just hasn't had time yet. I'm thinkin since FA claimed Socrates and possibly has the Loved modifier, so that would put him after my vote at L-1. If this is the case, I believe him to be town, so I will unvote.
If the mod just hasn't been able to update than he can ignore this and my hammer will stand.
From the wiki:
Opposite of the Hated modifier, the Loved modifier makes it so that a player requires one more vote than normal to lynch. For example, if there are seven players alive, most players will require four votes to be lynched but a Loved player will require five.
I was asking what from the flavor claim would lead to the seemingly picked out of thin air idea that he'd be loved and subsequently the decision to simply hammer him like that.
I only thought he could have the loved modifier after I hammered him and the mod didn't end the day. Maybe I am wrong and mod will end the day anytime now, but until then I will hang on to the loved hypothesis.
Socrates preached all about love and the different kinds of love in Platos symposium. I don't remember much about it since its been over a decade since I had to study it, but that's why I think Socrates has a lover/loved type of role or role modifier.
Think my lynch order from yesterday was still pretty close to correct
VOTE: BEF
there's something else I think I'm supposed to crumb atm but I can't think of a good way to do it. idk can you think of anything worth crumbing jameshydra?
because if your crumbs lead people to me then they have no merit.
Post
Post #343 (isolation #41) » Sat Nov 03, 2018 1:53 am
Postby BrightEyedFish »
In post 342, InfernoBrafin wrote:James:
Nope nope nope
If my hunch is correct shot was at Krazy or us last night.
Eager scum is now confused and trying to get the lynch they lost in shot last night.
Post
Post #347 (isolation #42) » Sat Nov 03, 2018 2:18 am
Postby BrightEyedFish »
In post 345, InfernoBrafin wrote:I think Carmen is town. Scum might be between BEF and Carcalily?
If Krazy does end up being scum he has to be the last lynch, but there’s no way that’s the case
Post
Post #366 (isolation #45) » Sun Nov 04, 2018 3:12 am
Postby BrightEyedFish »
In post 355, Krazy wrote:BEF is actually easiest to read in the context of a claim.
When he is scum it's always "oh shit I'm confirmed town because of this shitty claim for reasons that don't really make sense but fuck doesn't my role sound townie?" when it never does and it's never clear why he would think it would
and then when he's town it's "listen everyone this one person is scum so I'm making sure we're locked into a 1v1"
like his role doesn't even make sense here, there's no reason to think it would influence his alignment, but that weird, nonsensical overconfidence--that is exactly what he does as scum
Unfortunately I can't link the perfect example of this because the best game I'm thinking about is still finishing up but trust me, I know how to read BEF, and he is scum here
Basically, if the role sounds like pure nonsense, and his treatment of the role sounds like pure nonsense, that = scum
if the role sounds like nonsense *but it aggressively pushes town toward his top scumread* then that is when he is town
and if he was actually macho, he would just say he's macho, he wouldn't try to make it seem like that should clear him or something
Post
Post #376 (isolation #50) » Mon Nov 05, 2018 8:22 am
Postby BrightEyedFish »
All I know is my role. There could be a protective or maybe not. I just crumbed that comment out just in case there was one and they wouldn't waste their protective ability on me.