Alisae V Pine: Trees Apparently Make Good Treestumps

[Gamma Emerald]

Krazy, PP, Ico, Maria, Fire.

What you think

Can I chime in?

[Pink Ball]

Yeah sure, be my guest!

[Gamma Emerald]

Well I was gonna ask about Ico and PP but honestly I think Ico might be worth considering. So I'Lloyd just ask "why PP?" and leave the sentiment that we probably don't need a full solve just yet. The scumteam is still large enough that broad strokes thinking probably works. Now if anyone wishes to counter me there I'm down to hear it.

[MariaR]

What a dumb solve for a dumb game zzz

[Gamma Emerald]

What a dumb solve for a dumb game zzz

Who do you think

is

scum in that solve?

[MariaR]

Give me a minute to hop on my computer to give a more detailed answer. I suppose I should at least try to not let this game go to shit.

[Pink Ball]

Well I was gonna ask about Ico and PP but honestly I think Ico might be worth considering. So I'Lloyd just ask "why PP?" and leave the sentiment that we probably don't need a full solve just yet. The scumteam is still large enough that broad strokes thinking probably works. Now if anyone wishes to counter me there I'm down to hear it.

I was actually going to say the same thing, we should focus in one scum at a time, but it's were my head is right now.

[Gamma Emerald]

Give me a minute to hop on my computer to give a more detailed answer. I suppose I should at least try to not let this game go to shit.

Ok cool
I'll just spit out my own thoughts while I am at it. I am inclined to go with early conclusions I made rn because I feel like they're on the right track. So I am sussing Fire and Krazy, and I am also willing to consider Ico because I did have like a knee jerk suss of him early. You I'm on the fence about, and PP I don't recall having any early impression of.

[MariaR]

Krazy is town. The way he's playing this game is so blatantly obvious town along with the way he went at Mastina his tone is consistent it fits the narrative and I think scum are pushing him. There was 1 point I could see for Krazy scum and no one has brought it up and I feel like it's a pretty obvious point so scum clearly are just pushing it to push it.

All you people who were scumreading pops just brushed it under the rug and clearly aren't reconsidering your reads. Like dear god if your town these solves are awful that have like no thinking in them. Although, I can't blame it because we're all tired (at least most of us)
Firebringer
Gamma Emerald
the worst
Iconeum
Pink Ball
Dannflor
Menalque

4 scum in here. I took out PP cause he's open wolfing and obv the 5th
I won't vote the worst because of what Titus said even if his posting is...hahahaha
Dann is scum his interactions and intent today prove that enough. It leaves us with

Firebringer
Gamma Emerald
Iconeum
Pink Ball
Menalque

3 in here. But the fun part is you just need to look for 'who has been towny in this group' not the 'who has been obv scum' because I don't think you can really pinpoint that right now.
And right now I'd say Fire has been the least towny of this group. Still debating the others

[MariaR]

Also, I saw your point on 'scum Maria pushes mastina for the doc thing is scummy' and at the time I didn't care to respond but how is that scummy? I knew Ali was a doc and added that to my own read. Because yes, I didn't think we had a bodyguard and a doctor is that so wrong for me to understand. I didn't lie. I had mech reasons to believe mastina was scum.

[Pink Ball]

Huh

[Pink Ball]

Maria, how have you reevaluated the game since mastina's flip? I'm asking because of your pops argument.

[MariaR]

Of course I have. I would be power lynching the worst rn if I wasn't. One of the main reasons for my silence was wanting to watch how this played out because if I use Titus logic and the worst really is town then a lot of my reads are wrong so I'm like 'hm I should work on this'
It's why I have 2 and a half scum reads. I'm open to change.

[MariaR]

Man, why am I the one having to change my reads when I've been correct on every read besides 1 so far. Ah well that's life!

[Pink Ball]

Chill, I'm trying to follow your progression 'cause you're not in my top of mind.

Leaving you out of my PoE means I'm wrong in one between Dann/Mena.

[MariaR]

I don't think I could possibly explain to you how chill I am tbh. A lot of times people read my tone wrong (hence why I tell people to not tone read me) like. I am perfectly fine and have been for ages. I've just been more blunt than normal and perhaps that's being taken as anger.
(Also the one you're wrong on is Dann btw)

[Gamma Emerald]

Krazy is town. The way he's playing this game is so blatantly obvious town along with the way he went at Mastina his tone is consistent it fits the narrative and I think scum are pushing him. There was 1 point I could see for Krazy scum and no one has brought it up and I feel like it's a pretty obvious point so scum clearly are just pushing it to push it.

All you people who were scumreading pops just brushed it under the rug and clearly aren't reconsidering your reads. Like dear god if your town these solves are awful that have like no thinking in them. Although, I can't blame it because we're all tired (at least most of us)
Firebringer
Gamma Emerald
the worst
Iconeum
Pink Ball
Dannflor
Menalque

4 scum in here. I took out PP cause he's open wolfing and obv the 5th
I won't vote the worst because of what Titus said even if his posting is...hahahaha
Dann is scum his interactions and intent today prove that enough. It leaves us with

Firebringer
Gamma Emerald
Iconeum
Pink Ball
Menalque

3 in here. But the fun part is you just need to look for 'who has been towny in this group' not the 'who has been obv scum' because I don't think you can really pinpoint that right now.
And right now I'd say Fire has been the least towny of this group. Still debating the others

What "narrative" does Krazy's tone fit? And why does missing the obvious answer mean it is a scum push? I incidentally traipsed along a recently locked game that had a scum that slipped and was caught, but for reasons other than the slip.
How many people actually FoSed Pops? How many of those are still alive as well, since the most I recall him being FoSed was D1, towards the end.
Why are you certain Dann is scum but not me? I feel like if you are looking at things the way you claim you are you'd find my actions suspicious.

[Pink Ball]

Oh it was because of the "oh well that's life" comment, I don't think you're angry but I thought I could frustrate you with the question I made.

If I'm wrong on Dann I would be wrong on Krazy and that would fuck me over. Lets focus on what we agree for now, PP and Fire.

[MariaR]

Krazy is town. The way he's playing this game is so blatantly obvious town along with the way he went at Mastina his tone is consistent it fits the narrative and I think scum are pushing him. There was 1 point I could see for Krazy scum and no one has brought it up and I feel like it's a pretty obvious point so scum clearly are just pushing it to push it.

All you people who were scumreading pops just brushed it under the rug and clearly aren't reconsidering your reads. Like dear god if your town these solves are awful that have like no thinking in them. Although, I can't blame it because we're all tired (at least most of us)
Firebringer
Gamma Emerald
the worst
Iconeum
Pink Ball
Dannflor
Menalque

4 scum in here. I took out PP cause he's open wolfing and obv the 5th
I won't vote the worst because of what Titus said even if his posting is...hahahaha
Dann is scum his interactions and intent today prove that enough. It leaves us with

Firebringer
Gamma Emerald
Iconeum
Pink Ball
Menalque

3 in here. But the fun part is you just need to look for 'who has been towny in this group' not the 'who has been obv scum' because I don't think you can really pinpoint that right now.
And right now I'd say Fire has been the least towny of this group. Still debating the others

What "narrative" does Krazy's tone fit? And why does missing the obvious answer mean it is a scum push? I incidentally traipsed along a recently locked game that had a scum that slipped and was caught, but for reasons other than the slip.
How many people actually FoSed Pops? How many of those are still alive as well, since the most I recall him being FoSed was D1, towards the end.
Why are you certain Dann is scum but not me? I feel like if you are looking at things the way you claim you are you'd find my actions suspicious.

1a) He's upset town and pushing along the game with how pissed he is at these bs scumreads. Because yes, the scumreads are bs.
1b) It doesn't make it a scum push because no one has brought it up. It makes it NAI but it's still shocking that no one has brought up the point
2) I'd need to go back and check but I'mnot about togo check every player for 'pops is scum' but it was at least 1/3rd of the alive playerlist
3) Because I expect Dann to be better than this because he can have very good and well thought out opinions when he wants them/is town. You? You flip your logic randomly and do bad pushes all the time that I can see them from town you just as much from scum you. That's putting it nicely. So basically, I don't expect much from you. That's why you're null.
Pedit: I think everyone knows pp is scum at this point but that doesn't really help the game state. We'd be back at the same place again.

[Gamma Emerald]

Pedit: I think everyone knows pp is scum at this point but that doesn't really help the game state. We'd be back at the same place again.

REALLY? I don't. What makes you say that?
As for the rest maybe what Krazy is doing does push the game along incidentally but do you see real intent to push and/or solve the game from Krazy? And would you be willing to give any sort of direction about what that point against Krazy is? And if you think my flips in logic are completely random I don't know if you truly get me. Yes they're spontaneous but they have reason.

[Gamma Emerald]

Hello?

[Something_Smart]

I don't really see why the lynch should be anyone other than Firebringer

[Something_Smart]

And incidentally if Fire flips scum PB is next because PB is the reason I didn't lynch Fire days ago.

[Pink Ball]

That's fair

[Dannflor]

The way he's playing this game is so blatantly obvious town along with the way he went at Mastina his tone is consistent it fits the narrative and I think scum are pushing him. There was 1 point I could see for Krazy scum and no one has brought it up and I feel like it's a pretty obvious point so scum clearly are just pushing it to push it.

townie tone is not a good reason to town read Krazy!! Especially considering Mastina's push on him

Your logic is also backwards here. If there was an obvious point for Krazy scum and scum were looking for reasons to push him, it would have been brought up by now.