Big Four Mafia! Game Over!

[gobbledygook]

Titus, you cannot in good conscience say that Looker is town here. I understand you trusting pisskops reads, but look at their posts today..... especially in regards to Creature.

I can assure you that going after me is a wasted cause. You are the only conf town here, I am sure you can figure out why.

Also, I need to dig up Hectics quote regarding reading me from a previous game lol.

Let's push Drew. Pisskop suspected him and had Looker as town.

You can push me, but you aren't lynching me.

Did Pisskop expand on why he thought Looker was town?

Basically these posts saying 'I can't be lynched' and going after me is a 'wasted cause'.

Which after some thinking of why I was vanilla-ized, I believe they caught on to me softing BP.

Which is why they vanilla-ized me, and why Creature put Alch in a hood with Titud. How does Titus fit into all this? She has been scum reading me since basically she replaced in.

Alch lies about me having a PT to the confirmed town who would be very open to my mislynch. Seems like a good plan......but me being vannialized is tough to just ignore, scum would hope the 'guilty' would make people look past that. They unfortunately, miscalculated.

Alch is scum, no doubt about that. Slight chance that Creature is a victim of circumstance.....but a way way larger chance he is also scum.

Also, PT cop is the most dangerous power role to mafia that would be left.......what possible reason would there be to not vanillaize it if it is town based?

Simple answer, it isn't.

My issue is that a BP claim in no way makes you unlynchablw or not a lynch worthy target. I’m curious why you thought that it would? Like what about BP makes it not worth going after you?

[Titus]

Yurkin I would say town, BS and Chenn I lean town on, gun to my head Chenn is more likely to be town then BS.

Yoda is third scum in my eyes(with Alch and creature). I could see jjh as the last scum.....but is townier than Yoda that's for sure.

BS Yurkin are town bc vanillaizer claims. Chenn would be against Creature, thus more likely to be town in a scum Creature world.

Gobble would be scum aligned due to his incredibly inconsistent positions on the guilty. Alch is scum due to the coincidences above.

An argument exists for scum Chenn going for a scum mislynch because Creature had to act last night.

In that case, the town pool is

Titus
Drew
BS
Yurkin
JJH (lean)
Chenn or Creature

Against

Yoda (lean)
Alch
Chenn or Creature
Gobble

[Titus]

Was Yurkin proven to be a double voter before being vanilllized?

Also, I am pretty sure Chennisden is confirmed town because of TSE.

yurkin was conf doublevoter by VC and vanilized by VC

I'm having a hard time choosing from Alch, Drew, Creature, and Blatant.

Between Alch and Drew, I'm sure one of them is lying. Though I tend to believe investigatives.

I still don't know if I fully believe Blatant. Again, a prime scum kill N1 since he claimed Doc and nothing happened to him. The last time I played with someone who I thought was a prime scum target at night that didn't get killed that night turned out to be scum, so that's what keeps Blatant on my list. I know that this is a different game and all but it still sits on the back of my mind.

I just didn't like the brashness of Creatures claim push. Seems a perfect way to get targets on the most powerful remaining PRs.

But I just don't know who is the safest choice.

These two posts don't seem to be of the same mindset. It's like he forgot BS was the n2 vanilla target.

[Titus]

I am willing to lynch Alch, Yoda or Gobble atm.

[Titus]

Creature's role as town makes sense if Alch is a scum traffic analyst.

[gobbledygook]

I think I might actually want to lynch Drew now, lol. I’m sorry Titus. I am feeling insecure right now and the fact that we have no good information to go off is annoying.

But Drew’s crap crumbs reminds me of the Metalocalypse game where he was cult. Do you remember that game?

[Titus]

I think I might actually want to lynch Drew now, lol. I’m sorry Titus. I am feeling insecure right now and the fact that we have no good information to go off is annoying.

But Drew’s crap crumbs reminds me of the Metalocalypse game where he was cult. Do you remember that game?

Bulletproof doesn't crumb.

I get it. You're scum sooo

[gobbledygook]

I think I might actually want to lynch Drew now, lol. I’m sorry Titus. I am feeling insecure right now and the fact that we have no good information to go off is annoying.

But Drew’s crap crumbs reminds me of the Metalocalypse game where he was cult. Do you remember that game?

Bulletproof doesn't crumb.

I get it. You're scum sooo

You thought I was scum in Masquerade and we’re dead wrong. You don’t exactly have a good track record of reading me... so

[Doctor Drew]

Titus, you cannot in good conscience say that Looker is town here. I understand you trusting pisskops reads, but look at their posts today..... especially in regards to Creature.

I can assure you that going after me is a wasted cause. You are the only conf town here, I am sure you can figure out why.

Also, I need to dig up Hectics quote regarding reading me from a previous game lol.

Let's push Drew. Pisskop suspected him and had Looker as town.

You can push me, but you aren't lynching me.

Did Pisskop expand on why he thought Looker was town?

Basically these posts saying 'I can't be lynched' and going after me is a 'wasted cause'.

Which after some thinking of why I was vanilla-ized, I believe they caught on to me softing BP.

Which is why they vanilla-ized me, and why Creature put Alch in a hood with Titud. How does Titus fit into all this? She has been scum reading me since basically she replaced in.

Alch lies about me having a PT to the confirmed town who would be very open to my mislynch. Seems like a good plan......but me being vannialized is tough to just ignore, scum would hope the 'guilty' would make people look past that. They unfortunately, miscalculated.

Alch is scum, no doubt about that. Slight chance that Creature is a victim of circumstance.....but a way way larger chance he is also scum.

Also, PT cop is the most dangerous power role to mafia that would be left.......what possible reason would there be to not vanillaize it if it is town based?

Simple answer, it isn't.

My issue is that a BP claim in no way makes you unlynchablw or not a lynch worthy target. I’m curious why you thought that it would? Like what about BP makes it not worth going after you?

What are you talking about? I was 1 shot bulletproof, it would have been a waste to try to lynch me(I was going off the assumption there weren't any attempts on my life at night).

And I was vanilla-ized so the mislynch could go through. And Alch was placed in the hood with Titus because she is conf town who scum read me most of the game. The 'guilty' on me was meant to grease the wheels to my mislynch.

[Titus]

Holy cluck this is scum.

VOTE: Alchemist21

This is not a reaction test. I think you are scum for your interactions with Pisskop and Titus. Also the fact that you have not been vanillized is suspicious.

I think that actually makes Yurkin more likely scum in my mind.

Alchemist I think is scum for his bad reactions to Pisskop result. As PT cop, when you get a guilty, very specific things return false positives and he did not look for those at all. Not to mention revealing he had a result so quickly in the day. Seems very short sighted to go as hard on the PT result as he did.
Chennisden I think is town because I townread TSE. The claim there was unprovoked and seems very townie.
BS I think is town. He was vanillalized after revealing his power and has generally been trying to scumhunt.
Drew I think is town because he was also vanillalized and is trying to scumhunt. Plus he gave a lot of reads.

Did BS, Drew, or JJH ever flavor claim by the way?

jjh927
yurkin
Creature
YodaVader
Alchemist21

====

I think the 4 scum are in these 5 names.

Or he is the person in Titus’s hood that has the guilty.

Ding Ding Ding.

I'm still withholding who it's on yet.

Yeah I am 100% not lynching that person.

I am uncertain now if the guilty is on someone I’m already independently PoE scumreading. It would make it more likely that Alchemist is telling the truth.

So you'd judge Alchemist based on your PoE and no TV the reactions of people to the guilty?

My PoE is based on a combination of play and mechanical observations. Alchemist is in that group largely for his Day 2 play.

And yes I would because I do not know who the guilty is on so I cannot reliably judge their actions based on information I do not know.

Did he say why he claimed PT cop if he is a traffic analyst

Because I didn’t really think about the difference between the 2 roles at first and it’s easier to type out PT Cop.

*suspicion intensifies*

VOTE: Creature

Alchemist and Drew, what are your flavors?

VOTE: Doctor Drew

UNVOTE:

This is hard I town read both of them.

This transition doesn't feel town.

[gobbledygook]

What are you talking about? I was 1 shot bulletproof, it would have been a waste to try to lynch me(I was going off the assumption there weren't any attempts on my life at night)

You see claiming BP does not make you unlynchable. It just makes you not likable. It is quite often lynched because that is a role scum like to claim because it cannot be confirmed.

The other stuff is super WIFOM.

[Doctor Drew]

What are you talking about? I was 1 shot bulletproof, it would have been a waste to try to lynch me(I was going off the assumption there weren't any attempts on my life at night)

You see claiming BP does not make you unlynchable. It just makes you not likable. It is quite often lynched because that is a role scum like to claim because it cannot be confirmed.

The other stuff is super WIFOM.

But being BP makes me 1 time unlynchable, is my point.

[gobbledygook]

What are you talking about? I was 1 shot bulletproof, it would have been a waste to try to lynch me(I was going off the assumption there weren't any attempts on my life at night)

You see claiming BP does not make you unlynchable. It just makes you not likable. It is quite often lynched because that is a role scum like to claim because it cannot be confirmed.

The other stuff is super WIFOM.

But being BP makes me 1 time unlynchable, is my point.

Wut

Bulletproof does not make you unlynchable, by default. Does your role say you survive a lynch or a kill?

[Doctor Drew]

I specified with the mod, I was bulletproof one time to any kill..... including lynch.

[gobbledygook]

That’s absurd.

[gobbledygook]

That’s not what bulletproof means. That’s not what any of this means.

[gobbledygook]

That would mean you’re 1-shot lynchproof or bulletproof.

[Doctor Drew]

Talk to the mod post game I guess, but that's my role.

[Creature]

Bulletproof has nothing to do with lynch

This isn't China

[gobbledygook]

There’s no way that role is scum.

VOTE: Alchemist

[gobbledygook]

Drew, we meshed really well in Korina’s game but you aren’t doing much meshing.

[Doctor Drew]

Drew, we meshed really well in Korina’s game but you aren’t doing much meshing.

What do you mean?

[Doctor Drew]

Also that game angered me because I couldn't understand why no one else saw that formerfish was obv scum.

But I digress.

[gobbledygook]

You seem standoffish in this game.

[Doctor Drew]

You seem standoffish in this game.

Elaborate please.