Krazy's Post-Apocalypse uPick (Game Over)

[popsofctown]

Spoiler: my pt members

They are being cute this evening.
This probably makes me immune to Dann vote, when he says I get pocketed by cat pics it's mostly projecting.

[alimdia]

I forgot to say this earlier:
I never see FL replacing out as scum, popsofctown is locktown in my book.

day 2 chochoo

VOTE: Dr Easy Bake

It was obviously a silly thing for DEB to say but I don’t understand why it makes him scum?

~Fu

He said he'd do content on day 2

[TrueSoulEnergy]

VOTE: Hectic

I think this is a decent place to go. Still townreading DEB so I don't feel comfortable on that wagon.

Opinion on Eclipse?

[PenguinPower]

PenguinPower(3) - I agree with PB's analysis of the unvote earlier so he's townier than null. Both scum PP's I've faced have impressed me in the ways they've postured themselves so I give him a hard handicap but most of his other posting tends to meet the tough handicap.

Last time you complimented me, you were scum...why does my posting meet your given hard handicap?

[Dr Easy Bake]

I forgot to say this earlier:
I never see FL replacing out as scum, popsofctown is locktown in my book.

day 2 chochoo

VOTE: Dr Easy Bake

Why does this post make you want to vote me?
Like, seriously people, I've never been more confident about a read like this in my entire MS career. There is just absolutely no world where FL reps out as scum.

[Hectic]

What if Leafy was just busy since he was afking as mod too during the time he repped out? Is he still locktown?

EH???

[PenguinPower]

I hate the repping out argument btw. It's against site rules for someone to discuss their reasons, and it's because it's an outside influence. Maybe move on and just read the player currently in the slot.

[Pink Ball]

Amen, hail the pingüino.

Talk about something useful DEB, or eat rope. Your choice.

[mastina]

Get the fuck away from him you hussy

-collector general

heyyy yo we can all be friends

You can be our third!

To seriously answer your question: I agreed that mastina probably doesn't have a 90% tell and may not actually believe she even has one. I disagree with the conclusion that there's no townie motivation for that. Whether you're right or wrong, I'd expect you to see me putting her as a town lean (Ank has her as town too I think), multiple other people like PP putting her as hard town, and maybe questioning that conclusion. Because obviously multiple people can see the townie motivation behind her posts.

Mostly I'm just curious why you're so definitely reading this as "scum or jester," because that seems like quite a leap to make off a single push.

-Diana

Ank having a townlean on me, for the record, is part of where the legit scumread comes from.

Yes, I know.
I hate playing scum, my most recent scumgame was nothing like my play this game, I'm in my town meta, etc. There's numerous, very valid, reasons why I would be townread.

…None of the reasons to townread me, I'd expect Ank to actually townread me for on D1.

Ank usually doesn't townread me on D1, and nothing in my play this game makes me think that she would this game above all prior ones. What in my play this game is different enough to demand that she townread me so early whereas in prior games this play from me didn't warrant one?

[mastina]

BTW while catching up and phoneposting, I decided that it'd be productive to give a pseudo Creaturesque poe resdslist removing townreads
TSE removed. Hectic removed. PB removed
Clover Ebi removed. PP removed. Elsa removed.

Not mentioned yet in my catch up, but PPF removed; Datisi Mist removed.

Let's check in on who that leaves left for further commentary.

[mastina]

This feels like the perfect time for a readslist tho!

Eclipse
alimdia
Pink Ball
chkflip
emperor flippynips
Dats Mist

Clover Ebi
or
Dr. Easy Bake
PenguinPower
Superb Subtlety
Titus + Auro + Nancy Drew 39 Hydra [Past Present Future]

TrueSoulEnergy
Elsa Jay

The Collectors
Alchemist21

Flavor Leaf

(FB excluded for now, will place him within like 24 hours. Mind you, not place him WELL, but I haven't gotten the chance to take a stab at his alignment in spite of him having posted, so. Will get back to you on that read.)

alimidia, DEB, Superb Subtlety, Alchemist21, popsofctown, Dannflor, and Firebringer.

That's who I have yet to give a definitive townread on.

4/7 of those names are the groupscum.
I'm scumreading Alch, pops, and Dann, but the other four are dead nulls, pending further analysis.

At least one of them is scum; for every scumread I'm wrong on, add one of the four in. (The obvious one, my most likely to be wrong scumread is the Dannflor one as it boils down to what amounts to possibly paranoia. So if Dann is town, then 2/4 of FB, DEB, jjh/Ali, and alimidia are scum. Alch/pops are scum regardless tho.)

[Dr Easy Bake]

I hate the repping out argument btw. It's against site rules for someone to discuss their reasons, and it's because it's an outside influence. Maybe move on and just read the player currently in the slot.

Just because you hate it, doesn't mean it isn't valid. I know FL very well. There is no situation irl that would take him away from a scum game imo. He loves thinking he is the best scum player ever, he wouldn't pass up the opportunity for another win. You don't have to listen to my locktown read on the slot though, you do you.

Not like I've known FL for nearly seven years or anything smdh.

[Past Present Future]

Mastina town

-Present (Auro)

[Past Present Future]

DEB town

Wow this game is easy!

-Present(Auro)

[Pink Ball]

Mastina, the post you quoted Eclipse saying it was Ank was actually Dann, for the record

[Pink Ball]

I'm at the beach again so V/LA.

Auro stop posting like I do, you're already town via Nancy

[mastina]

This feels like the perfect time for a readslist tho!

Eclipse
alimdia
Pink Ball
chkflip
emperor flippynips
Dats Mist

Clover Ebi
or
Dr. Easy Bake
PenguinPower
Superb Subtlety
Titus + Auro + Nancy Drew 39 Hydra [Past Present Future]

TrueSoulEnergy
Elsa Jay

The Collectors
Alchemist21

Flavor Leaf

(FB excluded for now, will place him within like 24 hours. Mind you, not place him WELL, but I haven't gotten the chance to take a stab at his alignment in spite of him having posted, so. Will get back to you on that read.)

alimidia, DEB, Superb Subtlety, Alchemist21, popsofctown, Dannflor, and Firebringer.

That's who I have yet to give a definitive townread on.

4/7 of those names are the groupscum.
I'm scumreading Alch, pops, and Dann, but the other four are dead nulls, pending further analysis.

At least one of them is scum; for every scumread I'm wrong on, add one of the four in. (The obvious one, my most likely to be wrong scumread is the Dannflor one as it boils down to what amounts to possibly paranoia. So if Dann is town, then 2/4 of FB, DEB, jjh/Ali, and alimidia are scum. Alch/pops are scum regardless tho.)

With this, will do a proper readslist when not at work, but for now:

Of the seven, most town to least…


almidia
{DEB,
Firebringer}

Superb Subtlety (they're probably just scum regardless of the alignment of others here)

Dannflor (IMPORTANT: Dann is not to be lynched or vigged until either two scum are dead AND it's still probable that he's scum, OR, until four of the seven names in my poe are dead AND it's still probable that he's scum.)





(Big fucking casm of a gap)





Alchemist 21
popsofctown.
(Both of whom are probably scum regardless of the alignment of anyone else.)

[Dr Easy Bake]

I'm at the beach again so V/LA.

Spoiler:

[Superb Subtlety]

You still about Mastina?

-jj

[Superb Subtlety]

Also. PB made a good point, based on Ali’s main contribution to the game up to that point was basically telling me to shut up and just let FL try to mislynch me.

you two were argueing about nothing
like literally nothing
it was stupid
you got into a fight with FL and it was stupid and your read is stupid.

[Superb Subtlety]

that arguement
means nothing in the grand scheme of things

FL's read on you is stupid
you're read on him is stupid

its just more fun to tell you to shut up

[Superb Subtlety]

ama ig

[Superb Subtlety]

While Alisae is also posting I'm gonna make a special effort to sign my posts

-jj

[Past Present Future]

Spoiler:

VOTE: Hectic

I think this is a decent place to go. Still townreading DEB so I don't feel comfortable on that wagon.

Opinion on Eclipse?

This feels like the perfect time for a readslist tho!

Eclipse
alimdia
Pink Ball
chkflip
emperor flippynips
Dats Mist

Clover Ebi
or
Dr. Easy Bake
PenguinPower
Superb Subtlety
Titus + Auro + Nancy Drew 39 Hydra [Past Present Future]

TrueSoulEnergy
Elsa Jay

The Collectors
Alchemist21

Flavor Leaf

(FB excluded for now, will place him within like 24 hours. Mind you, not place him WELL, but I haven't gotten the chance to take a stab at his alignment in spite of him having posted, so. Will get back to you on that read.)

alimidia, DEB, Superb Subtlety, Alchemist21, popsofctown, Dannflor, and Firebringer.

That's who I have yet to give a definitive townread on.

4/7 of those names are the groupscum.
I'm scumreading Alch, pops, and Dann, but the other four are dead nulls, pending further analysis.

At least one of them is scum; for every scumread I'm wrong on, add one of the four in. (The obvious one, my most likely to be wrong scumread is the Dannflor one as it boils down to what amounts to possibly paranoia. So if Dann is town, then 2/4 of FB, DEB, jjh/Ali, and alimidia are scum. Alch/pops are scum regardless tho.)

With this, will do a proper readslist when not at work, but for now:

Of the seven, most town to least…


almidia
{DEB,
Firebringer}

Superb Subtlety (they're probably just scum regardless of the alignment of others here)

Dannflor (IMPORTANT: Dann is not to be lynched or vigged until either two scum are dead AND it's still probable that he's scum, OR, until four of the seven names in my poe are dead AND it's still probable that he's scum.)





(Big fucking casm of a gap)





Alchemist 21
popsofctown.
(Both of whom are probably scum regardless of the alignment of anyone else.)

Based on Mastina’s reads: Alch is resolvable, Pops’ lynch hurts Elsa, Dann=bleeding obvtown, I think DEB is also town, Alimdia, probably town, I hope Fire is town. That leaves SS.

VOTE: SS

~Fu

[Krazy]

Dab