Krazy's Post-Apocalypse uPick (Game Over)

[Dannflor]

I also can't scavenge

[Dannflor]

PB, I feel like you're scum casing me but calling it a PoE read.

[Past Present Future]

Dann, where's the wall post? Or are you waiting for claims? I'd rather you post it ASAP. Tell me the the scumteam pls!

-Present (Auro)

[Dannflor]

I'm tired and was hoping to use waiting for the claims as an excuse to do it tomorrow morning

[Past Present Future]

Issok, but give me your tl;dr / conclusions then?

-Present (Auro)

[Past Present Future]

Nancy and I have revisited and discussed things, and we have one very confident scumread. I hope you arrive to that conclusion too, Dann.
Firebringer, please fullclaim.

-Present (Auro)

[Past Present Future]

The following items were also found on Elsa Jay:
A solar powered walkie talkie (channel 4815)
A sewing kit (restore 1 charge to an x-shot protective item as an action at night, 1-use) ~Krazy[/quote]

@Pops, as the current reigning mech goddess, what is your take on this?

~Fu

[Past Present Future]

The following items were also found on Elsa Jay:
A solar powered walkie talkie (channel 4815)
A sewing kit (restore 1 charge to an x-shot protective item as an action at night, 1-use) ~Krazy

@Pops, as the current reigning mech goddess, what is your take on this?

~Fu

[Dats Mist]

Hello I’m prodging at this point

I think Alch is SK and we probably still have 4 groupscum, which is

Not good news

-Mist

[Dr Easy Bake]

Oh, that’s weird, I must’ve missed that. I thought everyone could scavenge. I might have given it a go if I new that.
Oh and I don’t think I mentioned that I don’t have any items.

[Dr Easy Bake]

So there’s me mentioning it

[popsofctown]

The following items were also found on Elsa Jay:
A solar powered walkie talkie (channel 4815)
A sewing kit (restore 1 charge to an x-shot protective item as an action at night, 1-use) ~Krazy

@Pops, as the current reigning mech goddess, what is your take on this?

~Fu

Since non many slots are fully unclaimed at this point, I'm guessing your slot gifted Elsa the sewing kit. I guess you did that because he was conftown, but you should have gifted it to someone you guessed might have the redgreen herb, which couldn't be Elsa who had fully claimed otherwise. That's probably the only powerful X-shot protective item in the setup (DEB's freezer counts, but if DEB is town he doesn't ever accrue much nightkill equity so it's not a powerful freezer right now).
No flipped townies have ever been multiacting, so there would be so many steps of using redgreen herb, scavenging sewing kit, using sewing kit, using redgreen herb again, that that's so many nights its very likely the game is over or the slot has died by the time the sewing kit becomes relevant.

If the main goal was to keep it away from scum because you worry the scum have x-shot protective items, I guess you know Elsa's not scum..

I don't think sewing kit interacts with ark, since it's conditionally gated but unlimited shot, but PB's claim has some fuzzy details in general. @PB, is the ark an item? How can you use repair materials to repair the ark if you can't scavenge?

pedit: DEB is saying the freezer isn't an item now.. I thought he implied otherwise.. oh well

[Pink Ball]

No, the ark is not an item, it's my ability, but scum must have an item that interacts with that kind of actions/abilities (like a roleblock) and make them act differently. If the sewing kit was a gift ítem, I think it was meant for me. My condition hasn't been achieved tho so it's not relevant.

[Pink Ball]

If the ark was an item it would be ridiculously broken. The ability being conditional makes it a swingy role. I'm less than a regular VT here 'cause I can't even scavenge, and it also can be neutralized by scum somehow. My role is not that useful now, it will be if we lynch scum today 'cause nobody dies tonight

[popsofctown]

Sewing kit only works on items so if the ark isn't an item the sewing kit definitely isn't meant for you

[Pink Ball]

It's a reactive condition, like SS' role. It is reparable at that point, the sewing kit would work.

[Dannflor]

Issok, but give me your tl;dr / conclusions then?

-Present (Auro)

sure, I'm in the middle of writing it up but I still might wait for mass claim to finish in case there are any major revelations

I'm working with a town core of you, Mist, and Pops

My picks for scum are [PB, PP, Alchemist, DEB] If there's a fourth group scum and Alch is indeed an SK, I would look in the [Hectic, FB] category, but I'd like to sort that later. I doubt Hectic/FB are aligned.

Right now I think PB is the scummiest slot in the game (maybe besides Alchemist) and I'd like to be voting there today and have Alch shoot within the [PP, DEB] group.

It's in some ways a 180 from my previous reads list, but last nights/day flips in particular gave me some clarity which I'll explain when I'm done with the post

[Dannflor]

My order of confidence for scum is like PB > DEB > PP [Alchemist]

I think I have the strongest case for PB, and a somewhat strong one for DEB. PP is mostly there out of PoE and being nowhere near as towny as I remembered on reread. It's possible I'm wrong on him if I'm wrong on one of you/pops/datisi, or on Hectic/FB not being aligned, but I kinda doubt I am.

[Pink Ball]

Lol

[Dannflor]

Town!PB doesn't respond to that with "Lol"

but yknow

[Dannflor]

you would get possibly mad and indignant but not dismissive

[Past Present Future]

I think all of PB's recent reactions are NAI, for ~reasons~

-Present (Auro)

[Pink Ball]

Nice to know I won't have to explain myself on that matter

[Past Present Future]

I doubt Hectic/FB are aligned

FB has an inno on Hectic. If FB's town, Hectic's town: so the only possibility here is that FB is scum, so why not just say that directly?
I don't see how you have townreads on Popsofctown and Dats Mist. We can talk about it after the claims though, I guess.
Dats Mist "prodging" with this gamestate is ick.

-Present (Auro)

[Hectic]

Hmm