Guns & Roses IV [Game Over]

[DonCorleone]

So I’d include it within that park

[DonCorleone]

I’m legitimately unsure I’ve ever seen you try to sort people on D1 before firebringer and idk what to make of it

[Firebringer]

I prefer interacting with people in real time to figure out behavior/mindset is better because the longer between posts the harder it is to determine what is influencing what in a persons mind.

one post doesn't a scum make, a group of posts or a repeating process.

[DonCorleone]

one post doesn't a scum make, a group of posts or a repeating process.

Not sure if I agree on this, if someone makes a really egregiously bad post then I think it can mean they’re just scum — although I think this is more applicable in reverse, like if someone is mostly scummy and makes one post that’s really unlikely to be from scum that person is prob town

[Firebringer]

uve made me less certain of a scum maria rn. But I still think both ur analysis and mine is a bit superficial.

or maybe I over think maria given my terrible track record.

[Firebringer]

Like scum maria can def be rude as fuck. She just is usually more cordial. I don't feel like she has posted enough for me to accurately sy "ohh yeah she is doing her scum play of soft but strong pushes" or town because "she is willing to and is fighting anyone without any fucks given".

[farside22]

Don can go back into my town pile. I don't agree with him, but at least I understand why he thinks what he does. I see more of a lot of how fire see's maria's scum play her. Lots of aggressive pushes, easy to look like she is pushing something unrealistic and looking the better for it. I may not know maria as a player (and I don't want to meta someone right now to find out) but her reasoning doesn't mesh up.
I'm fine with the ABR vote if push comes to shove either ABR or Maria vote at the end of the day is fine with me.

[DonCorleone]

Agree that Maria should not be locked as town but I think based on her posting so far she’s an inferior lynch to any of (ABR, eyestott, knightmare, Vecna, cakez?, S_S?)

[DonCorleone]

I am fucking awful at reading Maria in the past tho but I think that’s partly because we don’t get along on my main and that messes with things. Also it’s only relatively recently that people have pointed out that scum her tends to be sweeter

[Firebringer]

yeah I guess I was thinking don is town too.

Rip strongest scumread.

I miss when I had scumreads that were so strong and pervasive in my mind and then I lynch them and they were scum. That euphoria. Rip confidences.

[DonCorleone]

Sorry firebringer, I’ll try to roll scum next game and then you can scumresd me again and then you’ll be right and have that sweet satisfaction

[Firebringer]

its okay im scum this game and im gonna beat u and get that satisfaction anyways.

[farside22]

Agree that Maria should not be locked as town but I think based on her posting so far she’s an inferior lynch to any of (ABR, eyestott, knightmare, Vecna, cakez?, S_S?)

Knightmare has seemed to decide not to post in this game any more after the whole lets break the game strategy. I would like to hear more from him.
eyestott....someone said he is not posting anywhere and may need to be replaced.
I like S_S, I think he is town. Call it gut, but after checking his meta I can't see him as scum this game. If he is bravo.
I go back and forth with cakez. Love him, hate him. Giving him time for now since he is voting ABR.

[Firebringer]

idek what cakez is doing this game. Is he forcing himself to post when he does? it feels like theres a bit of that in his postings.

[DonCorleone]

Agree that Maria should not be locked as town but I think based on her posting so far she’s an inferior lynch to any of (ABR, eyestott, knightmare, Vecna, cakez?, S_S?)

This is basically PoE btw

I think all of

Fire, Lilith, Maria, chkflip, votato have done things that make them unlikely scum

I feel less confident on Icon and farside but I think they’re still more on the townside of things, they’re in my re-ISO again list

S_S seemed town early on but I want to check him too

Cakez has been pretty forgettable so I’d like to re-ISO him later too

All of the remaining 4 (ABR, eyestott, Knightmare, Vecna) haven’t really been doing much, Vecna more than the others

So narrowing it down narrowing it down I’d probably say that the ideal atm is (ABR, eyestott, Knightmare) but idk if I trust there to be two scum who are completely lurking it out which means that if it’s ABR +1 of the two lurkers then in my more towards null pile is probs the final scum

[Firebringer]

Fire, Lilith, Maria, chkflip, votato have done things that make them unlikely scum

im def scum, don't be rude.

[DonCorleone]

its okay im scum this game and im gonna beat u and get that satisfaction anyways.

I’m gonna be very disappointed if your scumtell is actually as easy as “seems excited about the game and actually plays = warmpupper!scum”

[Firebringer]

its okay im scum this game and im gonna beat u and get that satisfaction anyways.

I’m gonna be very disappointed if your scumtell is actually as easy as “seems excited about the game and actually plays = warmpupper!scum”

I am actually super bored of this game. I just have no other exciting games to occupy my time rn.

[DonCorleone]

Have you guys considered both voting for ABR? That would be fun

[farside22]

Have you guys considered both voting for ABR? That would be fun

VOTE: Abr

[Firebringer]

im just gonna say it because ive been thinking it for awhile.
I think ABR hs been quiet is because he doesn't want to be shot tonight and he has one of the town guns.

So id kind of rather ignore him today

[DonCorleone]

Or

Consider this

Maybe he’s a scum gun staying quiet because he doesn’t want to not get his shot off

[Firebringer]

seems less likely to me

[DonCorleone]

Also if you’re a town gun then surely it also doesn’t make sense to stay so quiet that you risk being lynched and being forced to claim/just lynched and not being able to shoot

[Firebringer]

Also if you’re a town gun then surely it also doesn’t make sense to stay so quiet that you risk being lynched and being forced to claim/just lynched and not being able to shoot

I don't think ABR fears getting lynched Day 1. at all