In post 34, humaneatingmonkey wrote:But you were curious, were you George?
Would it be in your town wincon to confirm a mason lolclaim? Let's talk about that.
In post 101, humaneatingmonkey wrote:in our last blitz, george was a distant town, so I don't know why scum!george is especially "cautious" because i've seen him do it before as town.
In post 316, Umlaut wrote:I know why I'm voting him, why are you voting him?
im sheeping you and i want this game to develop. i have no reads on anyone other than the masons, HG, and shiki.
In post 485, humaneatingmonkey wrote:You said GeorgeBailey is your secondary scumread. Do you find me scummier than GeorgeBailey because of #46?
In post 511, humaneatingmonkey wrote:Can anyone pushing for a Bailey lynch tell me why Bailey is a better lynch?
And where the hell is Bailey?
Seemed to originally be presenting a scumread of George, but let shiki talk him off it, and then said someone (Hoctac, I presume) "TMI defended" him. #101 isn't really a read
per se
but seems to discount the reasons given for townreading him. Then he sheeped me back onto GeorgeBailey (even though he didn't believe the mason claim and had declared the only alternative to that was that I was scum), but eventually fell back off onto Hiraki without ever talking in the interim about GeorgeBailey
per se
. I find last post here the most interesting, because if I imagine a scum!HEM making it the most plausible motivation is that he genuinely wanted someone to make a case for scum!GeorgeBailey, so he could have something to point to.
I have no trouble believing, under the hypothesis that Hiraki is town, that HEM could be the scum looking for a safe way onto the GeorgeBailey wagon.
“There are two kinds of people in this world: those who say, ‘There are two kinds of people in this world: those who say there are two kinds of people in this world,
In post 702, Umlaut wrote:I have no trouble believing, under the hypothesis that Hiraki is town, that HEM could be the scum looking for a safe way onto the GeorgeBailey wagon.
I 100% would have joined GeorgeBailey's wagon. You're not wrong there. Hiraki's wagon was going nowhere.
Hoc is not the easiest person to read. From Umlaut's perspective he got mafia to kill a difficult slot that had a good chance of being scum mechanically.