Silent Star 1: Lunacy

[Dunnstral]

Clover are you saying that you thought you were a wolf and there's no way your play would come from mafia for some reason?

[midwaybear]

Nahdia I don't believe that you're an alignment cop that got rolecopped and pushed by real mafia.

you mean kanna?

[Dunnstral]

then why did you say I think my partner is a werewolf
can people just claim their partners?
ok so drusilla and clover are together...

He is theorizing that wolf/wolf isn't necessarily masons, but believes his partner is a true wolf

[Dunnstral]

Nahdia I don't believe that you're an alignment cop that got rolecopped and pushed by real mafia.

you mean kanna?

No I mean nahdia, who also claimed that role

[Dunnstral]

you're both claiming factional cop?

OK here's the thing: with an even-night watcher and a bodyguard I'm very skeptical of this claim based on mechanics. Even if the alignment cop is roleblocked, they're still seen by watcher. What's the counterplay?

This is relevant though

[beeboy]

If no one admits to being Nahdia's partner we mass claim.
If someone admits to being Nahdia's partner and they did or did not claim alignment cop we proceed as normal./

World 1 is the we are just a bunch of masonries world so we should figure out nahdia's partner by force before we lose the chance.
World 2 we can either clear the cop claims much faster or move forward with the game knowing pairs likely aren't just scum/scum.

[Clover Ebi]

Clover are you saying that you thought you were a wolf and there's no way your play would come from mafia for some reason?

Unlike other people who were claiming to have faked there play or something like that I wasn't. I was still playing like town me would because in my mind I was hunting for another scum team. So all my thoughts and interactions came from a good place. It would've started to be a scum game for me if that other team died and I had to protect my partner but it never came to that. If I was the real scum in this case I wouldn't have been hunting people because I would be informed.

[beeboy]

I want partner claims, Dunnstral has a solid point about the game balance
The standard thing to do as scum is claim your role.

Both Kanna and Nahdia should have someone to back up their claim.
Or they should have someone to basically confirm they are aren't werewolf overlords like us.

[Dunnstral]

Clover are you saying that you thought you were a wolf and there's no way your play would come from mafia for some reason?

Unlike other people who were claiming to have faked there play or something like that I wasn't. I was still playing like town me would because in my mind I was hunting for another scum team. So all my thoughts and interactions came from a good place. It would've started to be a scum game for me if that other team died and I had to protect my partner but it never came to that. If I was the real scum in this case I wouldn't have been hunting people because I would be informed.

But then you can't say you wouldn't play like that as scum, because you would clearly

[Clover Ebi]

Clover are you saying that you thought you were a wolf and there's no way your play would come from mafia for some reason?

Unlike other people who were claiming to have faked there play or something like that I wasn't. I was still playing like town me would because in my mind I was hunting for another scum team. So all my thoughts and interactions came from a good place. It would've started to be a scum game for me if that other team died and I had to protect my partner but it never came to that. If I was the real scum in this case I wouldn't have been hunting people because I would be informed.

But then you can't say you wouldn't play like that as scum, because you would clearly

No I wouldn't because if I was scum my day 1 wouldn't be like that.

[Clover Ebi]

I can't tell if I'm not making sense or Dunnstral is being purposely obtuse.

[Morning Tweet]

I want to hear Nahdia claim or not claim their partner before the other partners claim

[Morning Tweet]

I understand what Clover is saying i think you guys are sort of arguing semantics

[Dunnstral]

I can't tell if I'm not making sense or Dunnstral is being purposely obtuse.

You're not making sense in my eyes and I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt.

[Dunnstral]

I understand what Clover is saying i think you guys are sort of arguing semantics

We're not though

They're saying they couldn't fake their play as scum because they were playing as if they were town

Except they thought they were scum all along so... they can fake that play as scum, admittedly

[beeboy]

I want both Kanna and Nahdia's partner to claim.
Kanna shouldn't be left off the hook if you think about it in more depth.

[Nahdia]

my partner is tuxedo man.

[Dunnstral]

Clover are you saying that you thought you were a wolf and there's no way your play would come from mafia for some reason?

Unlike other people who were claiming to have faked there play or something like that I wasn't. I was still playing like town me would because in my mind I was hunting for another scum team. So all my thoughts and interactions came from a good place. It would've started to be a scum game for me if that other team died and I had to protect my partner but it never came to that. If I was the real scum in this case I wouldn't have been hunting people because I would be informed.

But then you can't say you wouldn't play like that as scum, because you would clearly

No I wouldn't because if I was scum my day 1 wouldn't be like that.

Instead of saying scum can you use the word WOLF to refer to when you thought you were a werewolf antitown, and MAFIA to refer to real antitown

[Morning Tweet]

My partner is Kanna. She's telling the truth

[beeboy]

To save us the effort of waiting for Tux, did you claim cop to Tuxedo man?

[beeboy]

I am taking MT's post as "they claimed cop page 1"

[Nahdia]

my werewolf hood also heavily implies we're of the same alignment, fwiw.

[Tuxedo Mask]

This claim is the first I'm hearing about Nahdia being cop. They never mentioned it in our PT.

[Morning Tweet]

I am taking MT's post as "they claimed cop page 1"

Yup

[drusilla]

VOTE: nahdia