Open 786 | Dream Mafia | Cult Win!

[iamausername]

also, is it just not reading the game on replacing that you're saying is a null tell for Titus, or are you saying she always jumps on the biggest wagon with a justification as terrible as "this is rather overconfident"?

[Aristophanes]

Username, meet Titus.
Queen of moonlogic and never going to change.
She doesn't read games on replacement, so we must work with that.

I think the BM slot was very towny and don't have much to go om from its other two occupants. Psyche replaced for non-game reasons and reading any more inti that is wrong.

Titus is Titus and until I see otherwise I retain my BM townread.

That said,
UNVOTE:
You're town and I was dumb keeping a scumread up.

TW might be scum here.
Legitimately.
VOTE: The Worst
Sorry friend

[Hiraki]

Why?

[Aristophanes]

I was coming onti a spicer scumread the other day and they unfortunately were yeeted from the thread so I let it be. I did do an Iso of Fackskn and spicer and felt like they had an agenda but I didn't do a writeup.

Unfortunately I left it too late and have to work until deadline so I can't do a deep dive and provide my evidence. I understand that's not enough but *shrugs*
If you leave them alive I'll do one D3

[the worst]

also, is it just not reading the game on replacing that you're saying is a null tell for Titus, or are you saying she always jumps on the biggest wagon with a justification as terrible as "this is rather overconfident"?

1) yes dead null she never backreads on rep in
2) sure, that's not uncommon - she makes whacky votes and waits to see what happens

I'm half down to wagon half down to see how she handles the slot, I'll decide tmrw

[the worst]

VOTE: The Worst

Spectacularly bad vote
Let's murder the scums together dear ari

[Aristophanes]

VOTE: The Worst

Spectacularly bad vote
Let's murder the scums together dear ari

I mean, I have no qualms with an Ythan elim at this point so I am content to see that ride out.

I think we should revisit this D3, Worstie

[the worst]

I'm down bro

[the worst]

I had the audacity of replacing town in a fucking cult micro so here's the quarter of an ass I can convince myself to dedicate aorn:

- Titus shouldn't be D1 scum but may be scum now;
- Aristophanes shouldn't be D1 scum but may be scum now;
- the comp on Ythan should hit a wolf (Hiraki rings pure; Jesus sheep was kinda nice and spicy; I think Titus replaces in and votes partially for the effect but it also reads as hard unassociated)

I also like from a cursory flick through ythan's iso agree he's not really townreadable

[the worst]

If I had to drop a meme scumteam it's Ythan/username !!
if Ythan is town sure, murder aristophanes

[the worst]

idk if I really follow why username thinks his case is outing a scumbag but I think he wants me to believe that his case is good. maybe I'm just bad at mafia. whatever dude I Don't Know

Hiraki's rxn on the page where username did a big snazzy analysis wallpost sounds earnest and hiraki's issues with Ythan sound earnest : ) I quite like hiraki

[the worst]

VC

Hiraki(1): Ythan [644]
Ythan(2): Hiraki[634], Jesus Christ [652]
iamausername(1): Aristophanes [559]
Titus(1): iamausername [558]
Aristophanes (1): the worst [675]
Not Voting: innocentvillager and Titus

Hiraki is town
Jesus is town
the worst is town

Titus should probably be left alive because she is Readable and Good at Mafia unless people are really overwhelmee by username's post and just think her slot needs to be nuked but she's also not s/s with Ythan currently

I can read innocentvillager depending on how much he engages/plays!! exciting.

of Ythan / user / Ari I think I'd kill Ythan most enthusiastically especially given the slots I like best are also voting him and he doesn't seem associated with Titus who I want alive

user's kinda unexciting push on the Titus slot works pretty well as an Ythan partner

Ari is just not correct on me I'll sort him Later

[the worst]

maybe I should have put myself above hiraki there
I think it'd be quite strange to say I'm more towny than Jesus tho

[the worst]

oh hey yeah I don't want Titus dead
VOTE: Ythan E-1

[the worst]

innocentvillager is currently aligned with the town

[the worst]

original cult {Ythan,user,Titus} + throw in Ari as a possible recruit

I'll be taking my quarter of an ass back now, someone hammer Ythan, GL tomorrow

[the worst]

UNVOTE: can someone else e-1 I wanna give intent

[innocentvillager]

TW why is Ari scum, I feel like Korinas shitposting looked really town?

[innocentvillager]

innocentvillager is currently aligned with the town

the worst is also currently aligned with the town!

[Jesus Christ]

@5above thanks for finally explaining why Titus is scummy, after many posts where I asked you to.

also, Hiraki did some shit at the end of D1 that made it really obvious that he was doing whatever he could to keep that slot alive while trying to pretend otherwise, which i helpfully summarised in 619.

It was already explained why Hiraki would do that as town.

Battle Mage (the original bearer of Titus' slot) responded to this nonsense by declaring that Korina was scum, noting that drawing attention to himself as much as he did and also voting himself to L-1 made Korina likely cultist and not cult leader, then immediately walked back this entirely reasonable conclusion and declared that actually, Korina might be cult leader after all.

following this, Battle Mage continued to tunnel on Korina to the point of not just failing to comment on literally anything else himself, but also attempting to shut down any conversation from anyone else that wasn't all about Korina.

then he flaked out as soon as he came under any suspicion.

What would be the cult motivation for that? Wouldn't a cult be fine with hanging any town?
While reading that part of the game myself I found this:

132 and 138 demonstrate a sequential organization of reads that I don't remember seeing from you in our past game:

viewtopic.php?t=83080&f=11&st=0&sk=t&sd=a&user_select%5B%5D=5673&user_select%5B%5D=0&user_select%5B%5D=0&user_sort=Go

My impression is that the more formal way you are approaching reads is very cautious for the profile that I imagine you have, which also gives the *feeling* of a scum agenda.

which is more reason to believe Titus is scum. UNVOTE: Ythan
VOTE: Titus

also, is it just not reading the game on replacing that you're saying is a null tell for Titus, or are you saying she always jumps on the biggest wagon with a justification as terrible as "this is rather overconfident"?

This is also a good point and means that Ythan and Titus are not both cult.

Psyche replaced for non-game reasons and reading any more inti that is wrong.

Well, the point of this was that it was not towny.

[innocentvillager]

I had the audacity of replacing town in a fucking cult micro so here's the quarter of an ass I can convince myself to dedicate aorn:

- Titus shouldn't be D1 scum but may be scum now;
- Aristophanes shouldn't be D1 scum but may be scum now;
- the comp on Ythan should hit a wolf (Hiraki rings pure; Jesus sheep was kinda nice and spicy; I think Titus replaces in and votes partially for the effect but it also reads as hard unassociated)

I also like from a cursory flick through ythan's iso agree he's not really townreadable

oops nvm I get it now

VOTE: Ythan

[Titus]

Oh cool JC is probably scum.

[innocentvillager]

yeah I don't hate scum!JC, where's your head at on that?

[Titus]

There's a limited amount of time to deadline. Ythan gets to Ex -1 and JC bails on it. He never outright calls Ythan town either and deflects his rationale for voting me onto someone else (not sure who 5above is but still).

[innocentvillager]

I see, I feel like this kind of seems more like a cult!JC and CL!Ythan dynamic rather than a CL!JC and cultist!Ythan, so I'd rather get Ythan today and if he flips CL look to JC as the cultist tmr

I think the only reason CL!JC avoids bussing cultist!Ythan is if their cult failed last night so they're worried about preserving their members