So I'm thinking that the doc should not out who they protected just in case the mafia just didn't target anyone to bait the doc to out. We have the cop so we can get some info that way, does anyone else agree that cop should out if they have a read and doc should stay quiet?
If mafia figure out who the doc is we can think of this situation as ELO.
That said it does sound more likely that mafia just try and find the cop last night. If we assume that then the doc knows a confirmed town and if its not the cop then that is actually the best position for town, I still think cop should out especially if they caught scum.
Where is everybody? We can't have another day like D1 where the clock forces something. I won't be around most of today, but may be back on in like 9 hours.
Dongempire (4): Billy Pilgrim, PenguinPower, Lost, Nona
PenguinPower (1): Almost50
Lost (1): Dongempire
That was a disgusting wagon that lead to a bad elimination and everyone on it should be ashamed of themselves if they're town.
That said, I agree with Nona and I do believe both scum were on it. I am adamant it's most probably PP+BP, and I want to pock up from where I left yesterday.
You know what? FUCK IT. I am the Cop and PP is a Mafioso. ALL my play of yesterday was designed to evade the NK (including the "VT" slip). I -in fact- crumbed it in my very first post. My very first 3 words, even.
A replacement has been found. Almost50 replaces Kool Aid Man. Loading all PMs and settings.
C
ome
o
n,
p
eople! Not a single welcome???
Yesterday I made a case and deduced PP is the likely RB. We eliminate him today and take our chances. If he is the RB then I can get at least one more check. If he's the goon.. GOOD LUCK to us all.
I initially thought I should push PP w/o outing and see who does what, but that elimination on Dong made me think scum could very well force another miselimination today.
ALSO, I agree the Doc should NOT out today. Not just because I'd need them to protect me tonight. but also because dsjstr!'s logic has some merit to it. PP could have very well holstered, but NOT to out the Doc. It was to make ot harder for us to eliminate him today (we need all 4 town votes on him rather than "all" 3 town votes if he had killed someone_. I am not saying I 100% believe he did that, but I'm saying it's not too out of his character.
P.S. If that is true (PP holstered) I'd consider that to be a guilty on BP already. These were the two I was pushing (in addition to Nona) and if BP was Town PP could have very well tried to push him.
P.P.S. I don't think scum!Nona would open the day stating both scum were on the wagon. I am leaning Town on her now.
In post 321, Almost50 wrote:Dongempire (4): Billy Pilgrim, PenguinPower, Lost, Nona
PenguinPower (1): Almost50
Lost (1): Dongempire
That was a disgusting wagon that lead to a bad elimination and everyone on it should be ashamed of themselves if they're town.
That said, I agree with Nona and I do believe both scum were on it. I am adamant it's most probably PP+BP, and I want to pock up from where I left yesterday.
VOTE: Penguin
Wtf are you doing? This is MELO. Why are you voting out the gate?