Mini Theme 2172: Great Idea Mafia - Game Over

[redcardinal]

username is a tr for me right now. lots of changing votes, I agree with him on stuff, little jncomfortable that he seems to be jumping on wagons as they form but it seems fine

[redcardinal]

natural versus unnatural analysis depends on context and tone, it's kind of bard for me to explain much further than that but based on the context of ranny getting pressured, for him to start swinging at random seems scummy to me

[Noraa]

sup homies now can someone tell me what the Ranny wagon is on about.
Noraa saying "fine with ranny" but defending them is weirdly fence-sitty.

pedit: nahhhh I'm town.

No no it's not. It means I will do anything to not get no lim but the lead wagon I dont agree with. Neither contradicts the other in any way so its not fence sitty at all. Dont throw shade at me for no reason.

Shelley might be scum...

expand. this is where I would like to go but I haven't pushed it much cuz I only have meta reasons and I dont feel like town is willing to buy meta reasons since they are rather ... weak.

[Noraa]

My favorite lim for today is shelly. I have heard all the cases on the major wagons(herta and ranny) but I dont feel that strongly on either of those two whereas I feel extremely strongly on shelly. I agree meta reasons are trash but if everyone else is starting to get the same scum vibes, I will push that wagon hard.

[Noraa]

I do have a history of pushing and tunneling town hard but I dont think I've ever felt this strongly about a read at the beginning of a game. Either way, I'm willing to go on ranny or herta to avoid no-lim but my preferred wagon throughout this entire game has solidly been shelly.

[Noraa]

I feel like her reaction to my SR also hasn't been right. She has constantly threw shade at me saying that I tunnel town and all kinds of other shade. If she was town the reactions would be WHY. TELL ME WHY. WHY AM I SCUM? BC OF UR CRAPPY META REASONS? etc etc. she would question my SR much more if she were town but as scum, she knows I'm right so instead she just throws shade at me to discredit my opinions.

[Titus]

@Noraa, My scum read is gut based off posts like this one.

I didn’t even vote you because I thought you were scum. It was a pressure vote to get you to straighten up. If I have to say that, it didn’t work, so: UNVOTE:

But you kept at it, and that’s what I don’t get.

uh what

imagine your reaction test didn't succeed in generating AI content
why do you back off
don't you want to solve titus

If shelley thinks, Rannygazoo is scum, where is her vote? If she doesn't think he's scum, then why post like this implying he's scum not sorting?

The posting is particularly bad if Rannygazoo flips town because Rannygazoo could have seen his reaction test failed.

[Noraa]

good point. shelly says I'm being fence sitty yet susses and doesnt vote.
BTW its shelly not shelley

[Titus]

Convince me Rannygazoo is town and I will join you on shellyc.

[Herta]

ohhh my god herta it's hard to believe lmfao that's so specific

Yeah, I don't know. It was in my mind I guess? Kinda frightening actually. I don't remember using that one before.

[Noraa]

Im not even convinced ranny is town myself.
ranny is a null for me rn

[Titus]

Im not even convinced ranny is town myself.
ranny is a null for me rn

Can you talk about why?

P.S. Welcome to my townblock.

[Titus]

Also, if Ranny is a null, why are you against his wagon?

[Noraa]

I dont wanna lim a null. one sec. wait a bit. I'm in class rn.

[Titus]

Ok. I'll likely be out till this evening anyway.

UNVOTE:

I'm starting to have doubts.

[Noraa]

Alright I'm back on a break. Basically I think Ranny could be scum or town atm and I'm not at all sure which he is. I may be slightly leaning town but definitely not enough to stop me from hammering in case the deadline creeps up. (basically if I believe in a TR enough its actually possible that I'll choose no-lim over that TR but generally if I believe in it that strongly, the person doesn't ever make it to E-1 :/) Ranny's anger/frustration reminded me lots of myself when I am in hot water as town. Easy to fake as scum, I agree. But I'm not convinced he's town or scum atm and due to the frustration he expressed, I slightly lean town there.

[Noraa]

His reaction to the pressure has been bad, I agree. But generally town doesnt react good to day 1 pressure either so idk. I could be swayed by good reasoning but currently, no one has successfully persuaded me into believing in a scum!ranny.

[NoPowerOverMe]

Ranny is still a good wagon.

[redcardinal]

I don't really know what is going to convince you noraa other than rereading the game

[Titus]

Red, what are your shellyc thoughts?

[Noraa]

Rather than rereading 24 pages, would an ISO suffice?
Im willing to ISO ranny

[redcardinal]

I'm leaning a bit town for shelly right now, but not committed to that

[Titus]

I'm leaning a bit town for shelly right now, but not committed to that

Can you explain what I am seeing in 581 if shelly is town?

[Primate]

Titus who should I be voting for.

[redcardinal]

I'm leaning a bit town for shelly right now, but not committed to that

Can you explain what I am seeing in 581 if shelly is town?

nope, I have no idea why town shelly wouldn't vote ranny here