Mini Theme 2172: Great Idea Mafia - Game Over

[MURDERCAT]

I think echo seems pretty towny to me but I don't know his scum game well

[MURDERCAT]

I dont see the point in bringing a lot of attention a conftown slot(at least rn they are conftown)?

absolutely not

[Noraa]

I think echo seems pretty towny to me but I don't know his scum game well

I second this

[MURDERCAT]

Honestly feeling after page 20 that Herta and Ranny are easy pushes and we might want to lim elsewhere

[Noraa]

Honestly feeling after page 20 that Herta and Ranny are easy pushes and we might want to lim elsewhere

oooooooooooooooooooooo this is very much how I feel

[MURDERCAT]

It probably has something to do with redcardinal’s policy of deciding which slots to scumread and then picking reasons later as he explained to me in 463

she

I just want to point this out Ranny as it has happened a couple of times, please pay attention to people's pronouns under their avatars. If you aren't sure, please check in another tab before you post, thanks.

[MURDERCAT]

I don’t decide who I’m going to accuse first and then come up with reasons later.-

I can iso dive and build a more thorough case.

lol

VOTE: Rannygazoo

This sticks out to me as a weak vote

[MURDERCAT]

please use a bit of occam's razor here, if they sound fake it's probably because they are. even if you don't buy that, at least voting ranny will remove a big question mark. I don't want to end up with ranny at the end, do you?

hmm

[MURDERCAT]

kinda think herta/ranny are s/s wagons. I'll join yours because I buy the points + my TRs red and username are there

This just seems incredibly unlikely to me

[Noraa]

shelly thinks the solve is ranny/herta/noraa lmaoooooooooooo

[Noraa]

she TRed me at the beginning and I immediately accused her of pocketing and then I became a "tbd"
then I became a TR again for ???? reason
then I was tbd again
then I was a SR
and now somehow a solve of ranny/herta/noraa spawned out of nowhere

[MURDERCAT]

I do have a history of pushing and tunneling town hard but I dont think I've ever felt this strongly about a read at the beginning of a game. Either way, I'm willing to go on ranny or herta to avoid no-lim but my preferred wagon throughout this entire game has solidly been shelly.

Noraa can you give me like 1 post with a couple of quotes in a spoiler about why you think shelly is scum and why specifically you think those posts don't come from town? Just pick like the top 3 that stick out to you.

[Noraa]

basically ranny/herta/noraa = big wagon number 1/big wagon number 2/only person that's been sussing shelly big time

LMFAO

[MURDERCAT]

@Noraa, My scum read is gut based off posts like this one.

Can I also get SRs from titus? Ranked if you don't mind? Everything south of null would be great, just a line of reasoning if you want

[Noraa]

Spoiler:

ok username effort to sort ranny is prob!town

noraa is gut-town

I don't think I've ever seen u TR me straight off the bat before

so now im more clear about your play across various games, I have a good ~vibe~ from them, they claimed town and I think it's real lol
answer to titus redas geniune

*reads

also noraa is often explicitly *confused* and if they were in a scum PT I think they would have more direction on how to approach this rather than being confused about the factions

shelly didn't I play the ~confused~ card hard in doggos tho? :3

the key is tone. this is proooobably your first ever theme or something

see the reactions towards me giving you a gut-TR, it's trying to doubt me / point out logical flaws. scum upon TR'd doesnt do that

I do not fucking accept free town passes. this is the way scum shelly pockets. I'll bet you post game the scum pt will say something like "I can pocket Noraa"

[MURDERCAT]

Ranny is still a good wagon.

NPOM could be a good yeet today

[MURDERCAT]

MURDERCAT replaces Assemble!

Caught up

[Noraa]

Ranny is still a good wagon.

NPOM could be a good yeet today

what what wtf why?

[MURDERCAT]

huh no I'm not

this is the noraa case against me:
"player X is scum because they're playing in a protown way"
"player X is scum because they're sussing me"
"Noraa votes redcardinal"
"ah but I'm sussing player Y because they sus player X"

I am sussing shelly a bit based on how she is OMGUSing Noraa, but I want to read them together

[MURDERCAT]

I mean you should know from Roses that town Noraa can produce bad tunneled reads, what makes you think this is different?

Still a good point

[MURDERCAT]

yeah titus is lock town thank u and good night

I feel like Titus could be scum who is doing a good job hunting other scum right now

[MURDERCAT]

I do not fucking accept free town passes. this is the way scum shelly pockets. I'll bet you post game the scum pt will say something like "I can pocket Noraa"

Thank you I will definitely be isoing shelly

[MURDERCAT]

Ranny is still a good wagon.

NPOM could be a good yeet today

what what wtf why?

I'm amazed that NPOM is getting a free pass, especially from you. Remember what happened with Pooky in that marathon game? NPOM as werewolf gravedigger or whatever it is probably immediately looks for a town version and claims it post 1. Despite being largely treated as town for the claim he has done nothing to actually lead town

[MURDERCAT]

Now that I'm actually in the game I'll be doing some actual scum hunting over the next few days.

[Noraa]

I personally think there's no point in looking into him too much unless something proves he isnt what he claims he is.