Mini Theme 2172: Great Idea Mafia - Game Over

[Herta]

ok so I'm bad. Noraa that was the sickest soul read I've ever seen.

Lol at the IC living. 2 scum teams? Or maybe 1 SK? Or maybe a vig?

My off the cuff guess would be that the two scumteams aren't shooting the obvious target to avoid crosskills.

I'm kind of wrapping myself in knots debating what means anything in this game wrt to the way the ialiano wagon went yesterday.

That would take a little coordination the way you put it, and that isn't possible. Titus was obv town. I don't think Noraa was though. So I don't know how you conclude they're not hooting the obvious targets.

[Herta]

My off the cuff guess would be that the two scumteams aren't shooting the obvious target to avoid crosskills.

Agree that is the most likely, but scum wouldn't know how many teams there are. So it could still be 1 scum team avoiding a crosskill and a vig shot.

Possible but more likely multiple non-town.

[Herta]

ranny, username, murdercat, myself, and npom are all clear from my pov

I agree about ranny. And probably NPOM.

[Herta]

Of course, there can't be 1 or 2 because we caught one on day 1, and there were 2 night kills.

That's why I think town has lost majority or is close to it today. We have a good chance of eliminating scum today by sheer odds.

What I want to know is, is town better off hunting mafia buddies, or other factions?

How do you propose we differentiate? And does it matter?

Thinking about it, it may be slightly easier to poe mafia because of interactions with Italiano. But probably only slightly.

[Herta]

VOTE: PlusJoyed?

sheeping murdercat VOTE: Plusjoyed

VOTE: plusJOYED
Ok, let’s lolhammer an inactive slot

Eh, why not.

I admit I was wrong yesterday.

VOTE: plusJOYED

VOTE: +joy

how you like them apples

What is the case here? This is astoundingly ugly.

[MURDERCAT]

The case is my post about replacements

[Herta]

Spoiler: some scum quotes about plus slot

ok wiyvern kinda just tripped my super-amazing newbscum entrance scumtell

ok wiyvern to make this more efficient and for me to get a grip on your alignment tell me:

what do you think about herta
what do you think about echovision

if you had a complusive dayvig shot who would you use it on (complusively must kill a player now)

For herta, my read is the same as most of the thread, I think he's prob scum. The post where he listed "suspicions" or whatever was talking about profile pics more than anything else and then after the supposed scumslip, I don't think they ever explained the post until some time after they basically accused the people voting them. which is omgus I think and it kinda seemed like cornered scum to me.

Echo could go either way for me aorn, them not voting herta is weird, and focusing on inactive slots could be a way to take some pressure off of their possible scummate herta. I'm saying it could go either way because I liked some of their earlier posts, although this is a gut read, so it may not be that great.

I would just shoot herta here if I could because it would clear up a lot of stuff

ehhhh this is decent but also pretty consensus-y

this was less effective than I thought

yall are gonna get a low effort joyed this game, sorry
I looked through the list and I saw that there wasn't a mafia/antitown king, all i saw was a 1shot kingmaker. So I'm gonna be upfront so if we have a king they don't kill themselves: this game I rolled hero.
Probably gonna be more like a vt but whatever.

This seems like a town claim to me considering there is no pressure on plus

I’m thinking so. I wonder what Noraa and Echo think? They said they know him.

Still feeling good

more concerned with Joy's need and desire to end the day when they just joined the game

which was also a noraa read so i feel extremely confident in it

that's fair

What are you "not feeling" about? Do you only get excited about power roles?

i don't wanna whine but
i don't like vt very much and me being wrong 3 times yesterday has kinda quashed my confidence

This sequence doesn't make me feel real good about plus tbh. I'm not as taken with 1450 as mc seems to be though.

[Herta]

The case is my post about replacements

You mean 1450?

[MURDERCAT]

Guessing plus is last mafia and is finding it hard to care due to the way the replace outs happened.

As Wiyvern did not post yesterday they will be replaced.
shellyc has requested replacement.

like, if that's true it means shelly had no partner all game :/

[Herta]

i'm playing safe this game what the fuck is wrong with me
i haven't random voted enough people
VOTE: npom

it's been a few hours time to switch
VOTE: iconeum

dude makes my head spin but probably nai

[Herta]

Guessing plus is last mafia and is finding it hard to care due to the way the replace outs happened.

As Wiyvern did not post yesterday they will be replaced.
shellyc has requested replacement.

like, if that's true it means shelly had no partner all game :/

I guess I can see that.

[redcardinal]

herta you did see ranny's inno child right?

[Herta]

Yes.

[Herta]

plus seems easy here
i don't like easy and i believe the hero claim

that being said i got nothin with this game

nah not really sorry i was taking forever to write that message cause we're smelling different colognes

What does it being easy tell you?

[Herta]

herta you did see ranny's inno child right?

Yes.

???

[redcardinal]

herta still very scummy

[redcardinal]

echo if you want to go that direction today we can go herta instead of plus, I'm inclined to believe the hero claim as well

[PlusJOYED]

VOTE: herta
im town
technically since they'll be vla for a week they'll be more inactive than me

[NoPowerOverMe]

Plus is not presenting a very good case against him.

[Iconeum]

hi noraa

are you scumreading me yet?

hey titus

we meet again

lol scum teams said fuck your greetings i guess
interesting

you got me

it's a thing i do as scum

i greet the players (yeah, multitude) that i'm gonna kill during the night

[Iconeum]

just been solely pushing + and + seems very lhf and a very low effort elim
not a fan

i'm not gonna pretend that i'm pouring a ton of effort into this game, but +joy is still probably scum so...

[NoPowerOverMe]

Could Italian/PlusJoy/Echo/Shelly be the solve?

[Rannygazoo]

What is that supposed to mean? There is no shelly.

[Rannygazoo]

I'm also really sus of plus

unless he joins the italiano wagon then maybe he can be forgiven

It gives me the creeps how red keeps trying to manipulate town like this

ranny if you vote italiano I'll townread you too

A couple of posts from end of Day 1 I wanted to get back to. I'm not sure how they fit in yet.

This is one. I hated this post. At first I thought it was redcardinal being cute, but ranny's follow-up made me think it was sincere.

I think it was sincere in that since red couldn’t mis-elim me, she could only discredit me instead so town doesn’t pay attention to my reads. This was her saying that she’ll stop trying to do that if I sheep her.

[Rannygazoo]

What is the case here? This is astoundingly ugly.

There are people out there killing innocents at night. I think that’s what’s really ugly.