Mini Normal 2175 | The End |

[shellyc]

i do not Scumread iv and that slot is my high priority reread later ftr

is BM georgebailey replacement? entrance didn't ping either way hard but was a little lamist

[Ydrasse]

...but in those two quotes, you say you're eh but clearly you think that iv is still worthy of a townlean with that early game outweighing the "white noise" that was iv/dats, so the later parts of the game clearly aren't trumping the earlier.

[Iconeum]

hi bm

im feeling like shit today and skimmed but re: datisi I'm still townlean-ish on iv due to earlygame similarities to town!him but this war between iv and dats seems like white noise.

i do not understand you having a townread on iv AND datisi at this point (taking into account you just said you still town-lean datisi)

[shellyc]

...but in those two quotes, you say you're eh but clearly you think that iv is still worthy of a townlean with that early game outweighing the "white noise" that was iv/dats, so the later parts of the game clearly aren't trumping the earlier.

I'm free to change my mind when I will + I thought more about dats with ico.

[Iconeum]

ydrasse thoughts on iv vs ydrasse now asap

i think you're actually the most obvtown in this gamestate aorn, ico has kind of fallen off their town-ness

explain to me what made me drop in your reads please"

[Ydrasse]

you're free to change your mind but you're either failing to concisely explain your progression on iv (at a time that seems opportunistic) or you're misrepresenting it all, imo.

[Iconeum]

563 seemed like dats going hey iv give me explanations its concerning, while not directly sring iv, which is discrediting

so

you scumread datisi

because he asked iv to explain reads

and wasn't scumreading iv yet?


datisi's been asking iv for reads so they can form a read, as clearly stated multiple times 'i can't get a read on this slot'
so datisi keeps asking for reads

and you go all 'omg dats isn't scumreading iv despite

asking for reads?

'

VOTE: shellyc

[Iconeum]

you're free to change your mind but you're either failing to concisely explain your progression on iv (at a time that seems opportunistic) or you're misrepresenting it all, imo.

basicly, i have townreads on datisi/staarling/you

with a keeping eye on gypyx/bm

scumreading iv/shellyc, tho not necesarilly as a team

IV's interactions towards datisi don't seem like they come from a towny mindset, and obstruct more then they help. Granted, i've done the same as town once or twice so it's not set in stone.
Shellyc's read progression these last 5 or so pages is so absolutely terrible that i'm gonna dedicate an entire post to it soon

[Iconeum]

also extremely curious what I did that made me drop on shellyc's reads

[Ydrasse]

oh that post was at shelly because she is confusing me right now regarding how she's like, portraying her read on iv.

[Ydrasse]

good 2 know though... i feel a bit better about having you townier than not after seeing this stuff but you post a lot and it makes my brain hurt a bit

[shellyc]

also extremely curious what I did that made me drop on shellyc's reads

ico i feel like your read on datisi is weirdly confident and not re-evaluated at all since rvs.

[shellyc]

Shellyc's read progression these last 5 or so pages is so absolutely terrible that i'm gonna dedicate an entire post to it soon

i realise my scumread on datisi before terrible therefore I'm now townlean on datisi

[shellyc]

you scumread datisi

because he asked iv to explain reads

and wasn't scumreading iv yet?


datisi's been asking iv for reads so they can form a read, as clearly stated multiple times 'i can't get a read on this slot'
so datisi keeps asking for reads

and you go all 'omg dats isn't scumreading iv despite asking for reads?'

iv not giving reads is alignment indicative of its own, since it can be interpreted as obtuseness/lack of compliance with datisi

[Iconeum]

also extremely curious what I did that made me drop on shellyc's reads

ico i feel like your read on datisi is weirdly confident and not re-evaluated at all since rvs.

my read on datisi is stronger now that he's being pushed by shellyc and iv
i've got *extensive* experience with them
i am also very much paranoid about the slot, but with what i see here there is no reason to scumread them at all

[Iconeum]

Shellyc's read progression these last 5 or so pages is so absolutely terrible that i'm gonna dedicate an entire post to it soon

i realise my scumread on datisi before terrible therefore I'm now townlean on datisi

was that 1 post you quoted literally all you had on the 'pedantic' item?

[Iconeum]

so shellyc, you say you read people by engaging with them and then coming to a conclusion

so why did you scumread datisi for trying to engage with iv and trying to come to a conclusion?

[Iconeum]

If ya'll can hop aboard the shellyc train

we are departing soon for Execution-land

[shellyc]

my read on datisi is stronger now that he's being pushed by shellyc and iv
i've got *extensive* experience with them
i am also very much paranoid about the slot, but with what i see here there is no reason to scumread them at all

uhhh ok?

what exactly townpings though? since "no reason to SR" is indicative of nullread

[Iconeum]

shelly what made me drop down in your reads?

[shellyc]

so shellyc, you say you read people by engaging with them and then coming to a conclusion

so why did you scumread datisi for trying to engage with iv and trying to come to a conclusion?

datisi did not push iv in the early stages, datisi tried to poke at iv for explaining their reads (and did the same to you at a point as well)

a lot of datisi play was a bit like
person x: this person is town for [reason]
datisi: ok but why

[shellyc]

ico i feel like your read on datisi is weirdly confident and not re-evaluated at all since rvs.

this

[shellyc]

was that 1 post you quoted literally all you had on the 'pedantic' item?

idk how to explain it but I think the person x: this person is town for [reason]
datisi: ok but why

was a little pedantic/overfocused on others explanations on their reads as well

[Iconeum]

datisi i'm townreading because they are sorting players out
is being stubborn about engaging with iv, which is less likely to happen when they are scum because of the (negative) attention it draws
scumtisi is more laid back, especially day 1
has bumped heads with me over my reads, which is very much in towntisi's range and very much not in scumtisi's range

is this completely out of scumtisi's range? probably not, but i am liking the slot

[Iconeum]

ico i feel like your read on datisi is weirdly confident and not re-evaluated at all since rvs.

this

why aren't you pushing/scumreading ydrasse for their townread on staarling then?