Titus v Nancy Drew (Game Over)

[Nancy Drew 39]

Seems like Sherlock was using Noraa's hard SR on clidd as a partial excuse to vote him. Noraa was quite persistent about that scumread if i remember right.

I don't think Sherlock was thinking about Noraa's *entire* PoE when he said that. i doubt it, would be open to being convinced on that I guess but i dont think Noraa's D2 PoE is something scum would play around. Like why?

Is there scum in Noraa's PoE, though? probably. I like REK for scum currently, hinging on WnP!scum obviously. If that's wrong I'd guess Toog. Don't think Starcrossed/Pyro are scum -- Clidd I doubt as well also there's probably more reasoning for clidd i havent seen or forgot

So if we flipped W & P and they flipped town, you’d also think REK!town. What if we flipped REK and they flipped town, would you then also think W & P town? Iow, do you think W & P and REK are the same alignment?

[Nancy Drew 39]

Still following me? Probably not.

I don't want to touch Dominant players today.

I would compromise with a social player.
My preference: Morty and Rick > Sherlock and Watson > Saudade > Akarin.

I would very much lim anyone who is coasting.
My preference: Battle Mage > Starcrossed > Toogeloo > War and Peace.

Unknown is crapshoot. Scum doesn't care about them or it's scum who doesn't care.

From those pools I'd do:

Sherlock and Watson > Saudade > Akarin > Morty and Rick

I think Akarin looks kind of towny, Morty and Rick also look kind of towny, Sherlock and Watson do not

and then

Battle Mage > Starcrossed > Toogeloo > War and Peace

Not doing W & P because Nancy is against it. If not a mason then they can potentially be mafia

I don't like Battle Mage's contribution here, Starcrossed was null but the recent posts feel kind of scummy, Toogeloo is also kind of coasting/scummy.

@Toog can we get a readslist from you, thanks?

[DkKoba]

if REK made it to endgame they should be flipped in lylo - just my 2C

[Nancy Drew 39]

if REK made it to endgame they should be flipped in lylo - just my 2C

Agreed.

[Toogeloo]

@Toog can we get a readslist from you, thanks?

I will put a disclaimer ahead of time that my reads in each section are in no particular order. Apparently you guys think that in a category something at the top means strongest, which for me is never the case. The strongest is the category itself. If I want someone to know who my #1 town read is, I'll emphasize it.

Town for sure:

Fey
Pink Ball

Town-leans as of right now

Clidd**
Olaf
Dkkoba

PoE

Morning Tweet
War and Peace
Starcrossed
KidAmn*
SaraharaS*
Red Eyed Knights*
Dunnstral


*means I actually have like, zero, read on this slot at all. I don't pay attention to them, and I have literally no idea what contributions they have to the game. I pay attention to Nancy, and a bit of the conversation that is happening when I am actively there, and I have skipped everything else.

**has a good chance of actually being near town for sure based on interactions with scum, but I haven't paid that much attention and to the slot and it's more of a guess.

[Pink Ball]

Hey like... in two lines or less... why is a scum strongman/roleblocker suggested? Two lines or less please I don't need a big explanation I'm a fast learner I swear

[Toogeloo]

Hey like... in two lines or less... why is a scum strongman/roleblocker suggested? Two lines or less please I don't need a big explanation I'm a fast learner I swear

Nancy said a Protective on Morty and Rick was required, but they died anyways. So Nancy assumes Strongman/roleblocker.

[Pink Ball]

Oh ok is because of a protective, not because of someone roleblocking Gamma, right?

[Dunnstral]

Hey like... in two lines or less... why is a scum strongman/roleblocker suggested? Two lines or less please I don't need a big explanation I'm a fast learner I swear

dkkoba claims to have targeted morty and rick with a rolestop, but morty and rick died anyway

[Dunnstral]

5uffering
Gamma
Dunnstral
W+P

These seem like very safe scum reads :\.

@Toog can we get a readslist from you, thanks?

I will put a disclaimer ahead of time that my reads in each section are in no particular order. Apparently you guys think that in a category something at the top means strongest, which for me is never the case. The strongest is the category itself. If I want someone to know who my #1 town read is, I'll emphasize it.

Town for sure:

Fey
Pink Ball

Town-leans as of right now

Clidd**
Olaf

Dkkoba

PoE

Morning Tweet

War and Peace

Starcrossed

KidAmn

*
SaraharaS*
Red Eyed Knights*

Dunnstral

*means I actually have like, zero, read on this slot at all. I don't pay attention to them, and I have literally no idea what contributions they have to the game. I pay attention to Nancy, and a bit of the conversation that is happening when I am actively there, and I have skipped everything else.

**has a good chance of actually being near town for sure based on interactions with scum, but I haven't paid that much attention and to the slot and it's more of a guess.

4030 feels disingenuous looking back and comparing to his current reads

[Pink Ball]

Isn't dkkoba a vanilla cop

[Dunnstral]

Isn't dkkoba a vanilla cop

other one. Kidamn claimed that

[Dunnstral]

Morty and Rick has died. They were a

Vanilla Townie

Sherlock and Watson has died. They were a

1-shot Dayvig

Morty and Rick were supposed to be protected. :(

Scum has a dayvig??? Dafuq? Whomever shot Krazy, you have my utmost gratitude.

I'm deeply confused because I submitted a rolestop on M&R, but Gamma had claimed down to even-night so who fuckin knows

I'm also hella busy with RL this morning and 193 pages is not an easy catchup so bear with me y'all

[Pink Ball]

For fucks sake let me check who replaced who then 'cause I'm lost

[Dunnstral]

For fucks sake let me check who replaced who then 'cause I'm lost

No you're right, I mixed them up

[Pink Ball]

Ok back to what I was thinking: KidAmn replaced Gamma who claimed to be an even night rolestopper, and that's why it's implied that there's a mafia roleblocker/strongman. IF and ONLY IF there is a roleblocker, then why roleblock KidAmn and not the gunsmith? Doesn't feel right. But this is assuming that the rolestopper is town in the first place. If we live in a world where both WnP and REK are town, my eyes goes to KidAmn lying and that's the fake claim you're looking for.

P-edit no worries Dunn I should've checked in the first place instead of being lazy

[DkKoba]

Ok back to what I was thinking: KidAmn replaced Gamma who claimed to be an even night rolestopper, and that's why it's implied that there's a mafia roleblocker/strongman. IF and ONLY IF there is a roleblocker, then why roleblock KidAmn and not the gunsmith? Doesn't feel right. But this is assuming that the rolestopper is town in the first place. If we live in a world where both WnP and REK are town, my eyes goes to KidAmn lying and that's the fake claim you're looking for.

P-edit no worries Dunn I should've checked in the first place instead of being lazy

my thoughts exactly.

but like why use the strongman on ur nightkill and then leave GS alive ?

[DkKoba]

Hey like... in two lines or less... why is a scum strongman/roleblocker suggested? Two lines or less please I don't need a big explanation I'm a fast learner I swear

dkkoba claims to have targeted morty and rick with a rolestop, but morty and rick died anyway

no i targeted our dear GS and got Not Vanilla.

[Pink Ball]

Yeah yeah he mixed you up with KidAmn. I was having that problem too 'cause two replacements on two claimed PRs during the night is confusing

[Pink Ball]

Ok back to what I was thinking: KidAmn replaced Gamma who claimed to be an even night rolestopper, and that's why it's implied that there's a mafia roleblocker/strongman. IF and ONLY IF there is a roleblocker, then why roleblock KidAmn and not the gunsmith? Doesn't feel right. But this is assuming that the rolestopper is town in the first place. If we live in a world where both WnP and REK are town, my eyes goes to KidAmn lying and that's the fake claim you're looking for.

P-edit no worries Dunn I should've checked in the first place instead of being lazy

my thoughts exactly.

but like why use the strongman on ur nightkill and then leave GS alive ?

If Gamma/KidAmn is scum, then there's no proof that there's a strongman

[DkKoba]

Ok back to what I was thinking: KidAmn replaced Gamma who claimed to be an even night rolestopper, and that's why it's implied that there's a mafia roleblocker/strongman. IF and ONLY IF there is a roleblocker, then why roleblock KidAmn and not the gunsmith? Doesn't feel right. But this is assuming that the rolestopper is town in the first place. If we live in a world where both WnP and REK are town, my eyes goes to KidAmn lying and that's the fake claim you're looking for.

P-edit no worries Dunn I should've checked in the first place instead of being lazy

my thoughts exactly.

but like why use the strongman on ur nightkill and then leave GS alive ?

If Gamma/KidAmn is scum, then there's no proof that there's a strongman

obviously.

either KidAmn OR WnP is scum. no other choice.

[Dunnstral]

I don't really think kidamn slot fake-claimed their role

And if they're not faking their role, they're more likely to be town just because mafia died at night

[Titus]

Y'all are forgetting I picked the roles. You expect me to be boring? All this talk is pointless. You should see tomorrow.

[DkKoba]

Y'all are forgetting I picked the roles. You expect me to be boring? All this talk is pointless. You should see tomorrow.

yes i do

[Titus]

Y'all are forgetting I picked the roles. You expect me to be boring? All this talk is pointless. You should see tomorrow.

yes i do

*sees join date*

Yeah, you're too young.