Titus v Nancy Drew (Game Over)

[Morning Tweet]

hi pooks

[KidAmn]

Morty and Rick has died. They were a

Vanilla Townie

Sherlock and Watson has died. They were a

1-shot Dayvig

Morty and Rick were supposed to be protected.

Scum has a dayvig??? Dafuq? Whomever shot Krazy, you have my utmost gratitude.

I'm deeply confused because I submitted a rolestop on M&R,

but Gamma had claimed down to even-night so who fuckin knows

I'm also hella busy with RL this morning and 193 pages is not an easy catchup so bear with me y'all

What did you mean by this part,

KidAmn

?

I meant that Gamma had claimed all of our role, including the restriction, so it was public knowledge and scum could play around it with their own roleblocker/strongman/whatever.

[Pyro]

Why would the fact they know you're even night and can act that same night affect anything? I thought your confusion was regarding how your action didn't work

[Pyro]

*flops ears*

Hi Tweetie :3

I like a Sarah/Kidam scumteam for the final 2 baddies.

I should talk to Kanna some more about this game :>

~.~

[KidAmn]

If you need me to spell out why "I rolestopped this person last night and they still ended up dead" was confusing I don't know what more I can say pal

[Pyro]

Never mind, probably semantics

[Dunnstral]

Hm hm hm.

I reread Sarah trying to not be tunneled and I feel like... she has a few points. I’m not as sold there as I was before.

Can you go over it for me and also what are you thinking today

[Dunnstral]

how did Gamma know to claim even-night to mesh with Dunn's role?

Basically, this

[Fey]

Starcrossed should really claim at this point, I think, for my own sanity (and Pyro's, too).

If I can stop sussing them by virtue of their claim, I'd love that. Seriously.

[Pink Ball]

it's like one of your three posts on the previous day, and the longest and most substancial one

Caught up.

Sarah's "you think I'm scum instead of town with good reads? Are you actually serious right now?" feels like she doesn't understand how her play has been very underwhelming. Having good(ish) reads is not enough and it's even bad if your thread presence is not what it should be. I also think and have thought since I repped in that the whole "Nancy we're V I B I N G" thing was a pocket attempt and Sarah probably thought that following consensus and pocketing Nancy was enough.

That being said, I think it's weird that the first thing we do today is check who was bussing WP instead of looking who was outside the wagon. WP's wagon stagnated. Since D1 it has been stagnating. Scum didn't want to get rid of that slot, and there was still a chance to derail the wagon.

I don't know where I want to go. I have far too many ideas right now, none of them convinces me. I still have this feeling that Battle Mage's wagon was formed because of his scumread on Pyro. Anyway, I'm not concerned. Even if the consensus scumreads concern me, the consensus townreads are better. People realizing that Dunn is town is good.

I dont think i meant consistently throughout the game, i meant more recently on the previous day -- both you and clidd suspected her there. while you still have kid and her both in consideration, clidd seems more certain on just sara

1st paragraph: Sarah's suspicions
2nd paragraph: "why are we suspecting Sarah for bussing when it's more likely that scum stayed out of the wagon"
3rd paragraph: "Pyro's still pinging me".

You said "seems interesting that both clidd and Pink Ball are suspecting Sara pretty hard". So for one, I'm not suspecting Sara pretty hard, and I if I did, I don't think it would be 'interesting'.

[Titus]

5 bucks says Nancy stops Starcrossed from claiming.

[Starcrossed]

We are

The World Tree

If we die, both stumps are silenced for the following day.

[Starcrossed]

fixed picture link :#

[Titus]

Lol. Ok, changed bet. 5 bucks Nancy stops Starcrossed from real claiming.

[Nancy Drew 39]

Well it looks like no green scum died last night.

Like you seriously didn’t know they were a cop?

Like you seriously don't know the definition of green scum?

So you tell me, SPECIFICALLY what you meant by this.

[Nancy Drew 39]

I still think Sara fits well as a deepwolf and nothing she posted made me change my perspective.

Well, I still believe at least one of the vt claims are fake and I have less reasons to tr them than any other and she is definitely someone I could see Titus drafting. Krazy said pretty much nothing about them than Titus wouldn’t pick them because of name but both stumps obviously know exactly who she is. He was also fine with her being RS’d but I definitely don’t want to rush the day like last time. We need time and I didn’t get to give any instructions.

Speaking of @KidAmn, @Tweetie, claim your targets (Tweetie - yours from the past

2

nights) please. Starcrossed also needs to claim.

[Nancy Drew 39]

By PoE, my solve would be Sara + Kid.

If I had to select someone that I might be wrong, however, by occam's razor, it would probably be Star comparatively. By overthink, it would be between Olaf/Pyro and Fey, who are probably playing a competent game and completely off the radar.

My voting priority is Sara, but I'm open to other opinions/reconsiderations. A 360 can occur if I feel that someone is scumposting. Not that my reads are so relevant, of course.

Fey is 99.99999% locktown here. No way is that slot ever scum.

[Nancy Drew 39]

Hm hm hm.

I reread Sarah trying to not be tunneled and I feel like... she has a few points. I’m not as sold there as I was before.

So which vt(s) do you think are lying then? At least one of the claims has to be false. I don’t think Toog bus drive was a complete coincidence.

[Titus]

Well it looks like no green scum died last night.

Like you seriously didn’t know they were a cop?

Like you seriously don't know the definition of green scum?

So you tell me, SPECIFICALLY what you meant by this.

Yeah. I'm going to keep messing with you.

I'll tell you one thing though. The definition of green scum hasn't changed since the start of the game.

[Morning Tweet]

Targetted olaf yesterday, message succeeded. Today is a work in progress, more info on that later

[Nancy Drew 39]

Going to reread Starcrossed soon, KidAmn as well (a good vote today, I think).

Also going to reread Clidd who I am not sold on as town from associatives alone so we’ll see.

@Nancy, massclaim time?

Yeah good idea. If KidAmn/Gamma is scum then that would leave us with (negative utility/compulsive vanillaize) Italiano, (vanilla cop) Koba, (1 shot nightskipper) you, (odd night doc) Dunn and probably whatever tf Starcrossed is? Pooky is hard to read but I think this is > rand town!Kanna we’re seeing here.

[Morning Tweet]

You said "seems interesting that both clidd and Pink Ball are suspecting Sara pretty hard". So for one, I'm not suspecting Sara pretty hard, and I if I did, I don't think it would be 'interesting'.

Sorry for bad wording or understanding then. i'm getting at how both you and clidd were gearing to vote Sara after Toog (although yes you have mentioned olaf and kid). I think it's interesting if I consider kid/dunn/star/olaf town and have a remaining pool of around pink/clidd/sara with mayybe more suspicion on sara

[Nancy Drew 39]

Fey had a position in relation to Sherlock and W/P mostly towny. Dunn presented an interestingly towny reasoning regarding the Toog push. Star saw me as town very early but it would be silly for scum!Pooky and scum!Kanna to do that, since they both know how my reasoning process works when I think someone should see me as town or scum given the way I imagine that my play must be interpreted by each player. Olaf presented a meta-dive to try to read me that reflected a lot as coming from an uninformed perspective, that is, town. Nora had a stubborn behavior that I classify as town!Nora, although Morning is not playing in such a towny way in the sense of interpreting the game, which I am used to seeing from town!Morning, but regardless, the impression remains.

Kanna's super confident townread on you early makes you 100% town if they're scum

If Starcrossed is town, I think you might possibly have a really pissed Kanna after you. lolololol

[Nancy Drew 39]

Since no one's done draft speculation yet, these are the players I think Titus is most likely to pick:

War and Peace (Ircher + samantha97)
Sherlock and Watson (Krazy + PenguinPower)
Starcrossed (Kanna + PookyTheMagicalBear)

???
Gamma Emerald

Morty and Rick (mastina + Auro)

Dunnstral

Battle Mage

[Morning Tweet]

Vanilla Cop (Kinda bad)
Messenger (basically useless)
1-shot nightskipper (only exists to counteract 1-shot dayvig scum)
vanillaizer compulsive (literally helping scum at worst, doesnt do too much at best)

Even-Night Rolestopper (gated protective)
Odd-Night Doctor (gated protective)

vs.

Full Rolecop scum
Busdriver of sorts
1-shot fucking dayvig

If we are missing one of those protectives aren't we mostly working with unhelpful/negative utilty versus one of the strongest PR lineups on a scumteam ive ever seen?

Additionally if Kid is scum, doesn't it seem like they would have to be a scum rolestopper considering they claimed it on the first day and rolestopper is something we can verify?