Open 93 - Near Vanilla: Game Over, Mafia Win!

[armlx]

you are voting him right now for opportunism, yet i would call half the votes on the wagon right now the same thing.

Really, which half? The half voting him for his wagon vote of SSK despite the fact that SSK did nothing?

Voting people for scum tells is not opportunistic in itself.

[afatchic]

i have two more of the people that i posted that i could do the same thing with, but i am anxious to know why they are voting before i post it. but what i am getting at is that they haven't contributed much to the wagon.

and darox like i just posted no i am not trying to start another wagon or end this one, im just saying that more than just gecko are acting suspicious and it seems like people are playing with tunnel vision and not questioning the other people doing suspicious stuff. all i am saying is take a closer look at the other people voting and why they are voting. gecko wasn't the only one with an opportunistic vote, which is why i don't feel it is good enough at this point to merit a lynch. however if you give him time and let him screw up again then i might can be convinced he is the best lynch for today.

[armlx]

You asked how you are trying to derail his wagon earlier? See your last 2 posts.

[armlx]

Also, if you going to say "Other people here might be scummier, so don't lynch him", put out a case on one of said other people.

[Darox]

So I had heard that an entire page was filled up discussing whether it is too early for a claim/lynch or not.

Keep up the *quote*discussion*unquote* and it will become a moot point.

[afatchic]

So I had heard that an entire page was filled up discussing whether it is too early for a claim/lynch or not.

Keep up the *quote*discussion*unquote* and it will become a moot point.

huh?

[afatchic]

You asked how you are trying to derail his wagon earlier? See your last 2 posts.

im not stopping his wagon by any means. as far as i can tell he is still at L-2. if your case is good enough then it shouldn't matter if i talk about something other than gecko for a little while. and in my last two posts i am saying pay attention to other people, it feels as if you are not paying attention to them. just in case you didn't know, you probably caught one scum, but there are still two more.

[afatchic]

Darox why are you voting gecko?

[Darox]

MafiaSSK voters
1: Darox - Devilishly handsome. Votes MafiaSSK for being lurker scum.

4:

thegeckoj - States meta and that lurking is antitown at best. Also mentions that not having the game in watched topics is somehow suspicious.

Unvote, Vote Sineish, FoS ZazieR & thegeckoj

Gecko is the #2 suspect in my rundown of the SSK wagon. I can dig this wagon.

Unvote, Vote thegeckoj

Sineish is the person I found most suspicious out of the SSK wagon, but you are giving an interesting response to the votes upon you, and you were the person I found most suspicious after Sineish. Of course I want a bandwagon to start on you.

Looking at my posts could have told you pretty easily.

[afatchic]

i did look at your posts, but what wasn't so common sense from looking at them was why you would want to bandwagon your #2 instead of #1, so can you explain

[Darox]

Because none of the tells from then were particularly strong and I was willing to follow up on any of them. Gecko's later responses have pushed him higher than Sineish or anyone else, thus I continue to support his wagon.

[afatchic]

i do agree that i don't like his play once the pressure was on him, but i don't think we should rush a lynch on him.

[Doktor Per]

My hat goes off to you fatty, I excuse for my relative inactivity. I'm sure my frustratingly sarcastic and unhelpful activity will return sooner than we can all dream of. Or, like, tomorrow. I will be kicking some arses soon, might derail the bandwagon, but will hopefully spring some life back into this. (No excess fat in my Mafia, please)

[afatchic]

doktor what are you thoughts on all of this?

[armlx]

im not stopping his wagon by any means. as far as i can tell he is still at L-2. if your case is good enough then it shouldn't matter if i talk about something other than gecko for a little while.

But you aren't talking about anything other then gecko...

and in my last two posts i am saying pay attention to other people, it feels as if you are not paying attention to them. just in case you didn't know, you probably caught one scum, but there are still two more.

I don't see your point.

[ZazieR]

afatchic, Darox has just an interesting playstyle. You're asking him why he votes his number two suspect. Then I suggest that you look at the posts of his number one and two. At this moment Geckoj is more suspicious to me than Sineish.

Also, you're saying that there are players suspicious as well. Can you name them all including the reasons why? Besides, if you see others suspicious make a case against them.

Also can you explain what you mean with 'however if you give him time and let him screw up again' post 226?

[armlx]

however if you give him time and let him screw up again

I missed this.

You know what really helps with this him screwing up again thing? A claim.

[afatchic]

however if you give him time and let him screw up again

I missed this.

You know what really helps with this him screwing up again thing? A claim.

yes i agree, but never too early. think about it this way: pretend he has power role, and he is at L-2 and a few people on there aren't real comfortable with there votes and they decide to unvote, and yet you have already gotten a claim from him. so even though he wasn't in danger of getting lynched, he still gave his role away and will get NK'ed for it

and what i meant by that statement is that if he is scum, he is honestly going to make another mistake or two. its not like if we just keep gong with D1 that he is going to look completely pro-town and that we missed out chance to lynch him, unless he is pro-town.

[ZazieR]

As SpamWise said at my post: 'there are too many hypotheticals involved. There really shouldn't be any reason for afatchic to defend Geckoj. Unless it was out of the goodness of afatchic's heart. But no-one is truly virtuous enough to defend Geckoj.' This was one of his few posts except the playernames were different.
However, if you're story is correct, he could prevent us from a mislynch. Short said, claim!

Also, where are your cases I asked about at my previous post?

[afatchic]

maybe you should look back through the last few pages, and while your at it answer my question

[ZazieR]

It's never bad to repeat them, right?
Which question?

[afatchic]

why you voting for him?

Longer days are better for the town!!

[ZazieR]

Easy to say, see posts 135 and 142

[Korts]

Sixth Vote Count

(5) thegeckoj -armlx, Darox, SpamWise, MafiaSSK, ZazieR

(3) MafiaSSK -Doktor Per, ChaosOmega, thegeckoj
(2) armlx -killa seven, afatchic
(1) retrowiz -Apothecary
(1) Gamma -retrowiz

not voting:

Sineish

Activity check coming up.

EDIT: Damn, forgot I wanted the top of the page...

[Korts]

Prodding Apothecary (second), MafiaSSK (first), Sineish (first), SpamWise (second), thegeckoj (

this is your last shot

) and killa seven (

this is your last shot

)

Scratch that, I'm giving them one more day's time to post without a prod, I just realized the weekend's just ended.