In post 823, northsidegal wrote:I think there hasn't been a lot of elaboration, but the votes have followed something of a pattern of mostly staying within one PoE.
I think that I'm a lazy scumplayer, and that sig's play doesn't resemble that or any other lazy scumplayer. I think sig is a high effort scumplayer and sort of a lazy town player.
I think sig has done some outrageous stuff, but is probably a townie. I also think that enough has been said about that outrageous stuff, and the rest is best left to postgame.
I’m not seeing it yet, but I’ll take another look. I do have another 10 pages of catch up left too.
I think there’s a mistake you’re making which is WIM vs effort. I think Sigmund is probably a high WIM player regardless of alignment. I think you can make a lot of posts as scum and give the impression of activity while still being lazy in making a consistent effort with your thought processes etc, trusting that the WIM you exhibit will be misread as towniness.
I apologise if I’m making the game unpleasant; I find having to interact with Sigmund altogether unpleasant, but find it somewhat unavoidable. I will try to back off a little if you feel it’s going too far from my side, but I think I’ve been measured even if I haven’t minced my words at all.
I’m generally opposed to extensions on principle, I think they’re unfair on the scumteam in the vast majority of cases and don’t like to support them regardless of alignment.
Replacements are generally a disadvantage to scum imo, and so also giving town extra time to solve in addition to getting a maybe mislimmable or at the very least non-contributing slot swapped with someone who will contribute and who has a fresh perspective seems like pouring salt in the wounds.
In post 827, sang froid wrote:I’m generally opposed to extensions on principle, I think they’re unfair on the scumteam in the vast majority of cases and don’t like to support them regardless of alignment.
nsg, if I can’t sell you on Sigmund by EoD would you be willing to compromise on uneven?
And moongrass, could you elaborate further on uneven and why you think he’s town? Also, could you answer the question on what changed your mind on Sigmund to move him from the top of your reads (at the point of page 10) to the bottom (by the end of page 20)?
In post 826, sang froid wrote:I’m not seeing it yet, but I’ll take another look. I do have another 10 pages of catch up left too.
I think there’s a mistake you’re making which is WIM vs effort. I think Sigmund is probably a high WIM player regardless of alignment. I think you can make a lot of posts as scum and give the impression of activity while still being lazy in making a consistent effort with your thought processes etc, trusting that the WIM you exhibit will be misread as towniness.
I was going to quote some posts, but I think I will actually do it tomorrow.
For now, I actually don't consider sig a high WIM player this game - I think he's been listless and probably bored. Based on that, I think that - even absent any meta - it makes sense based on the play sig has displayed so far to think that, were sig to be scum this game he would probably be making more of his own fun. Do you get what I mean?
nsg, if I can’t sell you on Sigmund by EoD would you be willing to compromise on uneven?
And moongrass, could you elaborate further on uneven and why you think he’s town? Also, could you answer the question on what changed your mind on Sigmund to move him from the top of your reads (at the point of page 10) to the bottom (by the end of page 20)?
Uneven and I have a special connection. I can soul read them, so it looks absurd when I try to put it into words.
In post 843, northsidegal wrote:Moon, question on your progression here - did you townread me when you explained to me why you thought uneven was the towniest in the game?
I was hoping to determine if you were town. I had you in a possible team with ta vera after you responded.
In post 844, northsidegal wrote:Okay, moon. Say we're both town, and sig is town, Andres is maybe town, and uneven is town. Let's just say that's the case. Who's scum?
In post 837, sang froid wrote:nsg, if I can’t sell you on Sigmund by EoD would you be willing to compromise on uneven?
Hm. So you are after me because... you dislike that I said ta vera was solving in italics and with a ~ preceding it on page one? To indicate that I was saying it aware of the objection you are now making?
In post 837, sang froid wrote:And moongrass, could you elaborate further on uneven and why you think he’s town?
