Mini Theme 2222: Open Draft Mafia [Game Over]

[Almost50]

If you're town and grab one of them all the better

Which one would you suggest?

[cyrus62]

cyrus, what specifically about Taly's reasoning is bad?

I think infinity is scum I get white knighting vibe from him twords infinity . Infnfnty hasn't been scum hunting but seems to be town hunting . Town don't know who is town or scum so I find it scummy to be calling each other town. Look at my last town game your see scum pulled the same crap. So either he's a bad player or he is scum with infinity or he is pocketing infinity .

[Taly]

Try to get through D1 without drinking, Taly...

[cyrus62]

If you want me to see you as town at least work with me a little show me why you find them town. Or maybe go with my idea as for me I have 1 scum role. Rest town.

[Dwlee99]

A50, is this another reaction test? Because I zero percent believe you think being eliminated day one is the "correct" play here if you're town.

And what do you think the correct play is? Should I be picking strongman enabler tonight? Or should I pass on both shots and let scum use them at will??

How about I take the RB? That should -at least- deny them that. But whom am I going to use it against? Or should I holster??

Are you suggesting I should pick Neighbor which may or may not put me in a Neighborhood with "unknown alignment", where it'd be easier for them to manipulate me?

My final option is to pick VT.

Please guide me with your infinite wisdom

If I had that pack I'd pick neighbor because I love neighborhoods because I find them very useful for sorting and planning. If that's not your vibe you could justify picking basically anything except vanilla imo. What I don't understand is why you think that if you're town that it would be best to just kill you to remove that pack. If you hadn't claimed it you would have been able to see how the next person reacts to it/what they do with it, and your current move seems to pull a "look at how town I am offering myself as sacrifice" instead of really trying to solve the game or use what you've been dealt to your benefit.

[T3]

cyrus, what specifically about Taly's reasoning is bad?

I think infinity is scum I get white knighting vibe from him twords infinity . Infnfnty hasn't been scum hunting but seems to be town hunting . Town don't know who is town or scum so I find it scummy to be calling each other town. Look at my last town game your see scum pulled the same crap. So either he's a bad player or he is scum with infinity or he is pocketing infinity .

About Infinity townhunting, that's more of a playstyle thing. I haven't been particularly scumhunting this game.

[cyrus62]

cyrus, what specifically about Taly's reasoning is bad?

I think infinity is scum I get white knighting vibe from him twords infinity . Infnfnty hasn't been scum hunting but seems to be town hunting . Town don't know who is town or scum so I find it scummy to be calling each other town. Look at my last town game your see scum pulled the same crap. So either he's a bad player or he is scum with infinity or he is pocketing infinity .

About Infinity townhunting, that's more of a playstyle thing. I haven't been particularly scumhunting this game.

And you wonder why I don't trust your reads this game either. As far as I see it right now it's 9v1v3 till proving other wise.

[Dwlee99]

I completely failed reading Norwee last time I played with him but I think this game he seems to be doing solving things™. At least the interactions I had with him he seemed to be trying to peer into my brain and the frustration/pushback I'm seeing from him seems genuine in a way that makes me townread him.

[cyrus62]

If you want me to see you as town at least work with me a little show me why you find them town. Or maybe go with my idea as for me I have 1 scum role. Rest town.

Here do this to earn my trust.

[cyrus62]

Poe. Dw,taly nor, t3 and infinity. Show me why It I have should change a50 has shown me more faith so has house and bingel and dun. Heck even mistina has shown more.

[Dwlee99]

I have lots of town roles I should be night killed cause I have such town roles all town roles it's crazy lots of them.

[T3]

A50, is this another reaction test? Because I zero percent believe you think being eliminated day one is the "correct" play here if you're town.

And what do you think the correct play is? Should I be picking strongman enabler tonight? Or should I pass on both shots and let scum use them at will??

How about I take the RB? That should -at least- deny them that. But whom am I going to use it against? Or should I holster??

Are you suggesting I should pick Neighbor which may or may not put me in a Neighborhood with "unknown alignment", where it'd be easier for them to manipulate me?

My final option is to pick VT.

Please guide me with your infinite wisdom

If I had that pack I'd pick neighbor because I love neighborhoods because I find them very useful for sorting and planning. If that's not your vibe you could justify picking basically anything except vanilla imo. What I don't understand is why you think that if you're town that it would be best to just kill you to remove that pack. If you hadn't claimed it you would have been able to see how the next person reacts to it/what they do with it, and your current move seems to pull a "look at how town I am offering myself as sacrifice" instead of really trying to solve the game or use what you've been dealt to your benefit.

L M A O
FIA WRC

[Dwlee99]

You could say it helped me sort you... LOL

[Taly]

If you want me to see you as town at least work with me a little show me why you find them town. Or maybe go with my idea as for me I have 1 scum role. Rest town.

Here do this to earn my trust.

All right. Mental note to do this next time I'm in the thread. Really tired and am logging off, but I'll work with you on this and your thoughts on A50.

[Infinity 324]

Infnfnty hasn't been scum hunting but seems to be town hunting

Yeah I think this is a much better strategy

[cyrus62]

If you want me to see you as town at least work with me a little show me why you find them town. Or maybe go with my idea as for me I have 1 scum role. Rest town.

Here do this to earn my trust.

All right. Mental note to do this next time I'm in the thread. Really tired and am logging off, but I'll work with you on this and your thoughts on A50.

He has gone out of his way to state why he thinks he should be d1 elemation so I have more faith in a50 then the rest.

[cyrus62]

I have lots of town roles I should be night killed cause I have such town roles all town roles it's crazy lots of them.

I said say all town both or all scum.

[Almost50]

FIA WRC

I googled those and I got

Fédération Internationale de l'Automobile
World Rally Championship

[cyrus62]

Infnfnty hasn't been scum hunting but seems to be town hunting

Yeah I think this is a much better strategy

you know what team also does this?

[T3]

cyrus, why am I scum?

[Infinity 324]

Poe. Dw,taly nor, t3 and infinity. Show me why It I have should change a50 has shown me more faith so has house and bingel and dun. Heck even mistina has shown more.

I'm not really sure what you're asking me to do, and honestly it's not that big of deal if you scumread me right now. I'd hope that you'd get to a townread on me eventually, but atm I don't think there's too much I can do to "show" you I'm town.

PEdit: I don't think scum townhunts more often that town does, in fact I'd say in general they townhunt less.

[Almost50]

So far I am roughly at (groups in no particular order. I used the mod's player list):

Honouable Judge:

Almost50

The Jury:

House mastina Taly T3 NDMath

Pool of Suspects:

Dunn Flea Bingle Infinity Dwlee cyrus Momrangal/NorwEE

[cyrus62]

cyrus, why am I scum?

Let me ask you this who do you scum read and why. T3 I can't trust no one unless they look for scum.

[Infinity 324]

Though tbh I don't think it's fair to say I haven't looked for scum, I've pushed t3, a50, and house

[cyrus62]

So far I am roughly at (groups in no particular order. I used the mod's player list):

Honouable Judge:

Almost50

The Jury:

House mastina Taly T3 NDMath

Pool of Suspects:

Dunn Flea Bingle Infinity Dwlee cyrus Momrangal/NorwEE

see this makes me feel good about a50. Scum can say so and so is town after reading the thread . Town don't know who is scum so haveing scum reads shows more faith.