Open 93 - Near Vanilla: Game Over, Mafia Win!

[Korts]

Locking thread, recounting votes.

EDIT: retrowiz didn't unvote. Carry on.

[Korts]

kuribo replaces Apothecary, effective immediately. Thanks!

[kuribo]

I'm tempted to throw a policy vote onto MafiaSSK, but I'll do us all a favor and read first.

Just in case my predecessor was voting:

Unvote

[retrowiz]

he wasn't voting...not even on the vote count. I will hold back the mishammer until you get some input out in.

as for my question then vote, I dont believe a question dies from day to day.

in the meantime

unvote

afat and darix are now in the running for me after gecko.

[Riceballtail]

I will hold back the mishammer

Oops?

[Korts]

hascow replaces ChaosOmega, effective immediately. Thanks to you too!

[hasdgfas]

hi. I have a busy day today, so don't expect anything from me until tomorrow.

[ZazieR]

I will hold back the mishammer

Oops?

Indeed, Retro what did you just say?

[kuribo]

he wasn't voting...not even on the vote count. I will hold back the mishammer until you get some input out in.

already pointed out, but how do you know if it's a mishammer?


(still reading before I begin loudly condemning anyone in the most caustic way possible)

[retrowiz]

I had attempted a hammer vote, and forgot to unvote. hence..mishammer...ooohhh....now I see the wording is poor...I was editing my post in word...2 parts, condensed, and spit out.

Mishammer meaning I forgot to unvote, NOT hamering a Townie.

[Doktor Per]

That's a rather big slip up, buddy. Tsk, tsk, tsk.

And Kuribo, any insight into MafiaSSK?

[kuribo]

That's a rather big slip up, buddy. Tsk, tsk, tsk.

And Kuribo, any insight into MafiaSSK?

not yet, still reading

[MafiaSSK]

I'm tempted to throw a policy vote onto MafiaSSK, but I'll do us all a favor and read first.

Just in case my predecessor was voting:

Unvote

Do you still hate me for 539?

[Darox]

Kuribo, and hascow?

This game got a bunch more fun.

[Darox]

afat and darix are now in the running for me after gecko.

Uh, I assume thats meant to be me.

What?

[armlx]

People are trying to misrepresent your misreading as a misrepresentation Darox.

[afatchic]

he wasn't voting...not even on the vote count. I will hold back the mishammer until you get some input out in.

as for my question then vote, I dont believe a question dies from day to day.

in the meantime

unvote

afat and darix are now in the running for me after gecko.

so why do you find me suspicious? because i defended someone i believe to be a townie? isn't that what a townie should do, defend other townies? you should know from the other mini we were in before i got brutally night killed by protecting the wrong person that i seldom go with the crowd, unless it is a good case. and if i feel strongly enough about it, i will defend them.

[armlx]

afatchic is tripping up. He never said he thought gecko was town earlier, you know, when he was actually defending him.

[afatchic]

afatchic is tripping up. He never said he thought gecko was town earlier, you know, when he was actually defending him.

yep you caught me, im scum. dang why would i make such a careless mistake. darn.
but seriously, i guess ill give you that, i never felt he was scum, but he did have a few scummy posts, which made me uncertain about him. however i just felt there were more scum on the wagon itself, and later on me. some of his defenses made me wonder, but all in all i never thought he was scum, which is why i defended the wagon so much.

[retrowiz]

People are trying to misrepresent your misreading as a misrepresentation Darox.

Darox has never claimed it to be any of the above...quite the assumption!

[armlx]

Darox has never claimed it to be any of the above...quite the assumption!

Its pretty obvious it was....

yep you caught me, im scum. dang why would i make such a careless mistake. darn.

I can only imagine. It does happen a lot.

[hasdgfas]

Hascow's "I just replaced in" analysis(AKA, I'll read a few pages and then post my thoughts on certain things in those pages):

Pages 1-3

Post 7 - k7: Not random already? With a daystart and him not even posting yet?
Post 9 - Darox: I really dislike policy lynches.
Post 11 - Sineish: I don't see this as a valid reason
Post 15 - Darox: I still dislike policy lynches.
Post 20 - Darox: Lurking, while anti-town, doesn't mean someone is scum.
Post 27 - Sineish: I quite like this post. Per seemed a little too keen on a wagon that started with him making a "random vote"
Post 28 - SSK: Right, because the thread link was IN YOUR PM. Seriously now....
Post 35 - Darox: No, not necessarily scum. Town lurks too. Policy lynches are bad.
Post 39 - Darox: Get off it. Seriously. This is getting scummy.
Post 40 - zazier: This just seems a bit noncommital. You're responding to things, but not commenting on them. It looks like you're trying to moderate a debate.
Post 41 - Per: You've got to be kidding. You should really have better reasons at this point.
Post 42 - Gamma: Why the unvote?
Post 43 - gecko: Ah, so you're pretty much following the crowd. Why?
Post 44 - SSK: A good question, actually.
Post 47 - Per: Link?
Post 48 - Darox: GET OFF IT!
Post 50 - Per: Can't you at least let him do something scummy?
Post 53 - armlx: Is there a reason you're asking this?
Post 55 - retrowiz: You should really have a reason for getting someone to L-2 so early.
Post 58 - retro: Please don't fish like this
Post 59 - armlx: Good post.
Post 61 - armlx: Another good post
Post 62 - Per: Well, I'm not a huge fan of this post. It seems like a lot of joking around without really saying anything.
Post 67 - Apoth: Oh, hi. How are you? Anything else to say?
Post 68 - Per: Including yourself?
Post 69 - Per: What non-game related stuff? Why are you getting on them for voting SSK with about the same reasoning as you?
Post 70 - Darox: I'd love reasoning for the votes and FoSes. Plus, the last sentence is extremely scummy.
Post 72 - Darox: But maybe they weren't in some way random. Why are you assuming that?
Post 74 - zazier: good explanation, IMO. Excellent questioning of the wagon

Current thoughts of some players:
Darox - scummy for this tunnel visioned policy lynch. How does this help?
retro - scummy for almost everything up to this point
zazier - seeming town to me. Good explanations for things so far
Per - scummy. Staying on the SSK wagon for what seems to be no reason.
SSK - neutral. Still unhelpful, but not scummy.
armlx - neutral. Where are you? You seem quiet.
Sineish - seems town to me right now. Good insights on Per.

I will not be voting until I am fully caught up, but my current vote would be on Doktor Per or retrowiz.
Expect at least one more analysis post today. Hopefully more than one.

[armlx]

armlx - neutral. Where are you? You seem quiet.

Is this a joke? I've made 118 posts in this thread.

[hasdgfas]

armlx - neutral. Where are you? You seem quiet.

Is this a joke? I've made 118 posts in this thread.

Note how this analysis was only through page 3. You seemed quieter than normal in those 3 pages for some reason.

[armlx]

I missed the page 1-3 part.