Newbie 656 Game Over!

[RandomGem]

Both of those things are true. :/
I'm just going to go with thinktank. Like has been said already, he's unwilling to display his suspicions. I really want an end to this day. And he's lurking, so if he is town, we aren't really losing much in terms of towniness.

Vote: thinktank

[lifeofpie]

*sigh*
That word again.
I guess you could say it's boring.
Well, I don't exactly know if putting a second day up would help much...

[Artem]

Alright, in the interests of moving the game along, let's go with a lurker lynch:

Unvote; Vote: thinktank

[lifeofpie]

How about C5 instead?
I feel C5 has conributed less.

[Petunho]

MOD: I would love to have prods to C5 and thinktank.

How about C5 instead?
I feel C5 has conributed less.

I agree. Why are you (ShadowLurker, RandomGem, Artem) after thinktank and not C5? Just to point out, that if we lynch thinktank we would get a new replacement on the next day for C5 'cause his last post was 16 of September. One month ago! So if you are looking for moving game on, by lynching thinktank and not C5 you are only hampering this game.

And note to everybody: I don't like a bit that thinktank is lurking and would love to see his explanation. I'm just wondering why thinktank and not C5?

[NabakovNabakov]

Vote Count as of Post 404

Petunho (1):

thegeckoj

ShadowLurker (1):

Chapter 5

thegeckoj (2):

Fenchurch, Petunho

thinktank (3):

Shadowlurker, Artem, RandomGem

Not voting (2)

thinktank, lifeofpie

thinktank prodded. Seeking replacement for chapter5

I am considering a deadline and will announce one absent overwhelming opposition from players (please bold any addresses containing opposition).

[lifeofpie]

Well, with that, I will vote

Vote: Chapter5

No offense to the mod, as it isn't his fault, but this game is going rather slowly.
I think another replacement will simply slow things down.
If C5 comes back, I will reconsider.

[RandomGem]

I just went with thinktank because I think he is more suspicious than chapter 5 was. But this is probably because chapter 5 has barely posted.

I know this is a double standard, but I got suspicious of lifeofpie when he tried to divert the lurker bandwagon away from thinktank to chapter 5. (This because I don't find Petunho suspicious for the same thing...) Meh, just inuition and all that.

I guess I'm ok with either lynch.

[Fenchurch]

Unvote; vote: thinktank

And note to everybody: I don't like a bit that thinktank is lurking and would love to see his explanation. I'm just wondering why thinktank and not C5?

I'm voting thinktank not to get rid of a lurker, but because the way he is playing makes me think he's quite likely to be scum.

I realise my vote now puts him at L-1, and if anyone actually is thinking of hammering, I would also like for thinktank to have an opportunity to explain himself first; but going by his previous "explanations", my hopes are not high.

[Fenchurch]

I know this is a double standard, but I got suspicious of lifeofpie when he tried to divert the lurker bandwagon away from thinktank to chapter 5. (This because I don't find Petunho suspicious for the same thing...) Meh, just inuition and all that.

It's because Petunho has provided reasons for finding chapter 5 more suspicious (post 332) whereas lifeofpie just doesn't want to lynch thinktank. And I disagree that replacing chapter 5 would slow things down more. If we can get a replacement who contributes to the game, that will be very helpful. On the other hand, thinktank is still posting, so he won't be replaced, but his posts have been very deliberate in lacking any sort of useful content by which to judge him. I think this slows the game down more.

For instance, his last post was a promise to post his thoughts "soon". Two weeks have gone by, and we are still waiting.

[Fenchurch]

And I disagree that replacing chapter 5 would slow things down more.

Clarification edit: I disagree

with lifeofpie

that replacing chapter 5 would slow things down more.

I also disagree with lifeofpie that thinktank has contributed halfway decently. chapter 5 at least went out on a limb and gave some thoughts, tried to pick out evidence against people. I can imagine playing like chapter 5 myself. On the other hand, thinktank hasn't voted once since the random stage. He has barely posted anything to say what he thinks of other players, and when he has, doesn't provide any evidence or reasons.
All of this to me reeks of scum keeping their hands clean, trying to get through day 1 without hassle, and not committing to anything that could provide a read on them or evidence in the future; keeping his options open for later on.

I'd also like to know two things:
Artem: not that I mind, but why you are voting thinktank rather than chapter 5, in light of your post 325
thegeckoj: given that your main concern seems to be a quicklynch, are you now thinking about voting for thinktank or chapter 5? If so, which one? Note, it would be prudent not to hammer thinktank without giving him a chance to respond to his prod. However, I would still like for you to post your thoughts.

[thegeckoj]

thegeckoj: given that your main concern seems to be a quicklynch, are you now thinking about voting for thinktank or chapter 5? If so, which one? Note, it would be prudent not to hammer thinktank without giving him a chance to respond to his prod. However, I would still like for you to post your thoughts.

honestly yes, i am thinking of voting thinktank just to end the days even though i am still convinced of petunho's scumminess. i will not hammer before he has a chance to speak up though, it is only respectful to do so.

[RandomGem]

Can we have a 72 hour time limit on this prod... I don't feel like waiting indefinitely.

[lifeofpie]

This is getting way too slow, and my main worry is that a replacement will not help to speed things up much.
Think, I want to hear SOMETHING that shows you give a damn (or maybe C5 posting something scummy). by tomorrow or I think I will be in the mood to hammer.

[RandomGem]

This is getting way too slow, and my main worry is that a replacement will not help to speed things up much.
Think, I want to hear SOMETHING that shows you give a damn

(or maybe C5 posting something scummy).

by tomorrow or I think I will be in the mood to hammer.

Yes, that would be quite nice.

[lifeofpie]

What?

[Fenchurch]

What?

I think RandomGem was referring to the bit that he emboldened.

But what both of you say confuses me. You want chapter 5 to post something scummy, so that you can vote him. If he hasn't already posted something scummy, then why do you want to vote him?

[RandomGem]

I just mean that mentioning that you want Chapter 5 to post something scummy is... funny? Like a ha-ha joke.

[lifeofpie]

No, I meant if C5 posted something scummy I wouldn't vote for think.
*crosses fingers*

Unvote, Vote: thinktank

[RandomGem]

Thus marks the end of a 3 month experience... of Day 1. >.>
Oh, I get what you mean now...
*also crossing fingers*

[lifeofpie]

Wait, did I miscount?
I'm not sure that's a hammer.

[RandomGem]

Judging from Post 405's votecount, then Fenchurch's, then yours...
Yup, I'm pretty sure it's a lynch.
Sorry for being like thegeckoj, but HOORAY OH MY GOD THIS DAY IS FINALLY (almost) OVER!

[Fenchurch]

Wow. Well it's not out of the blue, but I wasn't expecting the lynch quite so soon. So it goes.

Now it's just a matter of waiting for NabNab to post the cardflip!

[Petunho]

Now it's just a matter of waiting for NabNab to post the cardflip!

Coin flip I would say... No real reasons behind those votes, only hopes of getting into next day and the info what we get from this lynch is quite minimal. Yep, let's hope thinktank was a scum.

[Petunho]

I don't see how you could possibly be bored.

All you have to do is take a glance at the proceedings and type one or two sentences. If it was a non-virtual game, I could understand. In this case, my only problem is a shortage of topics.
Peace, all.

You are right, the case isn't strong. However, it's about the best we have. I don't have my vote on petunho solely

because I'm not in a rush. If a deadline comes up, I think I will place my vote on him (=Petunho).

Repeat after me.
Quicklynch bad.

*sigh*
That word again.
I guess you could say it's boring.
Well,

I don't exactly know if putting a second day up would help much...

How about C5 instead?
I feel C5 has conributed less.

**

Seeking replacement for chapter5

**

Well, with that, I will vote
Vote: Chapter5
No offense to the mod, as it isn't his fault, but

this game is going rather slowly.

I think another replacement will simply slow things down.

If C5 comes back, I will reconsider.

This is getting way too slow, and my main worry is that a

replacement will not help to speed things up much.

Think, I want to hear SOMETHING that shows you give a damn (or maybe C5 posting something scummy). by tomorrow or I think

I will be in the mood to hammer.

No, I meant if C5 posted something scummy I wouldn't vote for think.

*crosses fingers*

Unvote, Vote: thinktank

You can all make your own conclusions on lifeofpie's posts in the last 10 days. I have made my own and the focus is on the bolded.