Open 860 | Elected Decisions | Postgame

[Fun Times]

Spoiler:

Andante is pissing me off. I can't tell if she's maf or jut conf biasing. I don't have a read on Nancy. Hence I'm stuck.

I don't think I have any town reads. Maybe enchant.

Good time to reasses. Do you think I gained a thing with my "white knight"?

galron/kitty/Enchant are townreads

Okay, but why is

Galron

a townread?

No groundbreaking season tbh. I'm just familiar with them. I don't think they'd be so easily stung by

Andante

or very cautious of my defense if they were scum. Bad position for scum to go. Equally bad look to have no townreads and openly state that.

So I think he is sincere, and likely just town.

galron/kitty/Enchant are townreads

Okay, but why is

Galron

a townread?

I’d also like to know why Kitty is?

Because they voted for you?

@Taly

~N

Honestly yeah I'm a little pocketed.

But when

Frogs

asked for

Kitty

to explain and she just gave a tonal reason... like... I think that's less usual for scum to fake?

You'd think scum would have a better worded reason.

And certainly odd for scum to heal me, a town that is "power-hungry."

Enough to make me turn my beak.

I have no idea what Kitty is but if yoi recall from OMG, Gamma jumped onto Kyouku leader wagon, so I wouldn’t auto assume that.

[Fun Times]

Hmm, add kitty to my would divulge list. I don’t think frog is a partner of kitty flips red.

I don’t see what they’ve done that screams obvtown so far? Why is a town tonal read, town indicative? Like it’s totally nai.

~N

[Fun Times]

Spoiler:

No groundbreaking season tbh. I'm just familiar with them. I don't think they'd be so easily stung by Andante or very cautious of my defense if they were scum. Bad position for scum to go. Equally bad look to have no townreads and openly state that.

So I think he is sincere, and likely just town.

I have been reading this thread back and forth and I must say that I'm very surprised at this assessment. I have played several times with

Galron

before and I have never seen him so restless. Almost like he's had someone make him a much stronger coffee than usual. I am surprised, to say the least, that no one is even mentioning it.

I mean, would the

Galron

I know get so riled up over being referred to as "this"? (100) Especially since the post where

Andante

of

Fun Times

referred to the feel of the post itself, rather than aiming at dehumanising

Galron

? (95)

And like... what on Earth is this post?

Taly acknowledge me please!!!

Normally, I just see

Galron

sitting in the shadows and poking out from time to time with contributions. And his playstyle has changed dramatically since... March?

VOTE: Galron

You could be right? He is usually more chill I think which is why I asked about NEP.

Apart from what Andante said, I actually still like RR from both his take on divulge and I also thought his reaction to Andante’s push was fine.

~N

[Fun Times]

To me Kitty lacking depths in reads is scum indicative and it’s probably not something galron!scum draws attention to if they are partners with kitty.

Wtf is this? Why are you trying to tie me to kitty? No one has even hinted at something so ludicrous I guess and here you are looking like you're trying to plant a seed that will produce what exactly? Show me where anyone has compared me with kitty. Explain why you're using galron and kitty in the same sentence.

That’s a very good point. @RCE, what connects Kitty to Galron?

[Fun Times]

Greeting, do you think the change observed in Galron's behavior is best explained by Galron being scum?

This is also a good question

@Puppets

with regards to Taly.

Fun Times

- that the name of my hydra with ANDANTE.

I thought that initially because Taly demanded I heal them right off the bat which made me think of Labrynth but now I’m not so sure.

I also thought that they had misrepped my reaction to Galron because I’m dyslexic and clearly misunderstood his post but I haven’t disliked Taly’s reactions after that.

[Fun Times]

Greeting, do you think the change observed in Galron's behavior is best explained by Galron being scum?

This is also a good question

@Puppets

with regards to Taly.

To Nancy specifically.

Again, please call us Fun Times, thank you.

[Fun Times]

I’m thinking I may have been wrong on Taly initially. I’m no longer picking up Labrynth vibes. Taly was over the top aggro in that game.

Only thing I still am concerned about is they hard tr Kitty.

I have no idea rn who to divulge. Is that hammered yet?

~N

[Frogsterking]

Greeting, do you think the change observed in Galron's behavior is best explained by Galron being scum?

This is also a good question

@Puppets

with regards to Taly.

To Nancy specifically.

Again, please call us Fun Times, thank you.

Okay I will refer to you as Fun Times from now on.

[Enchant]

I think hammering divulge is last concern. If someone obvscum hard, we probably would want to depart them anyway (not likely but still).

If i would pick someone not me for PR, it probably would be Taly.

[Frogsterking]

@Taly, is there any reason you can't elaborate further about your read on Kitty?

@Enchant, it sounds like you townread Taly. Do you have any other reads right now that you want to share?

[Enchant]

I want divulge Greeting also.

[Frogsterking]

I want divulge Greeting also.

Okay is there any reason why you can't elaborate about your read on Greeting?

[Fun Times]

Greeting, do you think the change observed in Galron's behavior is best explained by Galron being scum?

This is also a good question

@Puppets

with regards to Taly.

To Nancy specifically.

Again, please call us Fun Times, thank you.

Okay I will refer to you as Fun Times from now on.

Thank you.

[Fun Times]

I think hammering divulge is last concern. If someone obvscum hard, we probably would want to depart them anyway (not likely but still).

If i would pick someone not me for PR, it probably would be Taly.

Is Taly your strongest tr?

[Enchant]

I want divulge Greeting also.

Okay is there any reason why you can't elaborate about your read on Greeting?

Probably my inability to explain thoughts. I simple think Greeting is "Low Average", which is perfect target for divulge and where scum mostly lies.

[Fun Times]

Yeah I get that but if it’s not obvious, I’d still prefer divulge, because to scum there’s really not much difference but to town it’s huge.

So what has pinged you about Greeting?

[Frogsterking]

I want divulge Greeting also.

Okay is there any reason why you can't elaborate about your read on Greeting?

Probably my inability to explain thoughts. I simple think Greeting is "Low Average", which is perfect target for divulge and where scum mostly lies.

Okay can you please explain why Greeting is low average rather than average?

[Fun Times]

Okay you already answered that. So who do you tr other than Taly?

[Enchant]

While healing self is okay, Greeting did it in strange challenging way.

[Enchant]

Okay you already answered that. So who do you tr other than Taly?

I change mind about it too often, Taly remains consistent.

No point.

[Fun Times]

As for what should we do. I was thinking about Divulge and then keep/Depart depending on the player's alignment.

However, while reading the thread it occurred to me that since we can only go after one of the options Divulge/Depart, we could end up in a situation where we keep Divulging and uncovering townies and never hit a scum. This in itself wouldn't be so bad, if it wasn't for the fact that an uncovered townie is a prime target to be killed off by the mafia the following night. Which, in result, makes this option useless unless we manage to uncover a scum.

So, I say we pick Depart to our best possible abilities today, and only use Divulge if there is no other possibility of townclearing a certain slot.

NOMINATE: Depart

The purpose of divulge isn’t to townclear a slot, it’s to use it on a slot you don’t tr but aren’t confident is scum.

[Fun Times]

Okay you already answered that. So who do you tr other than Taly?

I change mind about it too often, Taly remains consistent.

No point.

No point to giving other trs?

[Enchant]

At this stage yes.

[Frogsterking]

Hmm I'm down to compromise and divulge Enchant. My first choice is to depart Roden. HEAL: Fun Times

[Fun Times]

Hmm I'm down to compromise and divulge Enchant. My first choice is to depart Roden. HEAL: Fun Times

Why do you want to divulge Enchant?

Like I don’t understand this? Wouldn’t a compromise be to divulge Roden? How do you get from wanting to depart Roden to divulging Enchant?