That wasn't meant to be insulting, I'm sure you are thinking about the game, but I don't think that post was a great representation of deep game thoughts.
In post 486, Vanderscamp wrote:I don't think Titus is super town or anything but at least he's actively engaging in conflict in a game where relatively very few people are doing so.
I think scum are people like Ircher/Herta/Porkens who are just sitting back and chilling and letting Don/Titus waste time with a tunnel on each other.
I think Herta has given multiple really suspect reads and I would love to kill that slot today.
Titus, if Vanderscamp is scum what does your rule of 3 tell you?
Atleast it's silly way to embrace and throw away legitimate reason for scumread
Therefore, it makes Herta more often town than not
... Silly right?
I feel like this logic implies that every time someone gives a town read on anyone, the person giving the read is less likely to be scum, which I don't find to be true.
Regardless of the silliness the result is the same and the process (not getting the read through legitimate means) is the same.
Atleast it's silly way to embrace and throw away legitimate reason for scumread
Therefore, it makes Herta more often town than not
... Silly right?
I feel like this logic implies that every time someone gives a town read on anyone, the person giving the read is less likely to be scum, which I don't find to be true.
Regardless of the silliness the result is the same and the process (not getting the read through legitimate means) is the same.
Not really.
In Herta case it's done in some absurd way.
Wizard-Mercenary
You need replacement/players ASAP? PM me! I almost always accept.
PORKENS IS SUS FOR THEIR BAD READ TRAJECTORY ON ME, FURTIVE IS SUS FOR CRACKING JOKES IN RESPONSE TO PRESSURE AND SAYING "KILL PORKENS" OVER AND OVER, AND TITUS IS SUS FOR DISRUPTING THE THREAD BY AGGROING NANCY WHEN SHE USUALLY MIGHT LURK OUT ON D1 AS TREE. IN MY EXPERIENCE IT IS BEST TO KILL FURTIVE OR TITUS IN THIS SCENARIO AS PORKENS HAS GOOD CHANCE TO BE VI.
11 hours left. We should make a decision. I'm willing to compromise on Titus and to a lesser extent Herta. Anyone not voting one of the top 3 wagons ought to move their votes at this point.
Links: User Page | GTKAS
Do you have questions, ideas, or feedback for the Scummies? Please pm me!
I would vote porkens over Titus, I still obviously want to kill Herta but I will compromise onto pretty much anyone in several hours to ensure that we actually get a kill.
In post 461, Porkens wrote:Actually that’s wrong. I wouldn’t be happy to eliminate anyone. I have preferences of who I’d like to eliminate but they aren’t based on town/scum reads.
Like: Don Draper x Mistress (hydra of Nancy Drew 39 and Auro)
Love: Porkens
Wary: furtiveglance
Impatient: Herta
Enchanted: Vanderscamp
Wary: Ircher
Like: Titus
Wary: Enchant
Tempted: SCRRRDBEAR
This is part of it. The timing of these posts show Porkens is thinking about the game. Could be scum, but I think it's enough for Day 1.
In post 500, Ircher wrote:I have to agree that Herta's recent takes on Porkens are really bad. I could buy a TMI argument there.
In post 518, Ircher wrote:11 hours left. We should make a decision. I'm willing to compromise on Titus and to a lesser extent Herta. Anyone not voting one of the top 3 wagons ought to move their votes at this point.
