Cosmos Mafia (Postgame)

[professotic]

Enchant is a dude!??
I mean I think they are town as well but I thought they went by she.

[professotic]

So T-Bone do you still think I’m wolf that “slipped” lol
Do you still think I “lied” despite me explaining literally everything I have said?

Man like can you tell me who you think the Solar Cult are? Cause I’m Town Mate.

[MegAzumarill]

VC 4.0.6


Dingle Dangle Scarecrow (4) Radical Rat, Junkochan, professotic, Mathblade [E-3]


Meuh (2) Firebringer, Ydrasse,

Enchant (1) Cat Scratch Fever
Professotic (1) T-Bone,


Not Voting (5): Enchant, Porkens, Dingle Dangle Scarecrow, Past Present future , Meuh,

With 13 Alive it takes 7 to eliminate
Deadline: (expired on 2022-12-07 14:56:15)

[Dingle Dangle Scarecrow]

Enchant is a dude!??
I mean I think they are town as well but I thought they went by she.

You're thinking of Elements

[professotic]

Oh that’s right, Elements is female

[professotic]

Man I had it vice versa.

[T-Bone]

So T-Bone do you still think I’m wolf that “slipped” lol
Do you still think I “lied” despite me explaining literally everything I have said?

Man like can you tell me who you think the Solar Cult are? Cause I’m Town Mate.

I mean when first asked you about what you said you denied it. Then you tried to insult me and make a threat that you will never play with me again if I'm town. Only after those things did you offer a clarification for what you meant. I would call that first thing lying and that second thing an attempt at emotional manipulation. Maybe had you not done that I'd be more inclined to believe you. Instead of blaming me for thinking you have scumslipped blame yourself for posting the way you did initially and the way you handled it when pressed. I think those things mean you're scum tbh. I can't imagine someone who is town, who thinks they are a god tier player as town, would act like this when pressured. Because then either you're not town or you're not as good as you say you are. I think you're playing to the best of your abilities like I think every player does, and that you've made a mistake and have revealed yourself as scum.

[T-Bone]

Professor's next post had I said that he, X, Y, and Z are solar would have been "aha you're only searching for solar cult cause you're lunar!" So I'd sooner skip that nonsense. There are a few players who I feel could be either scumteam including Prof in my PoE. I think the players who cannot most likely could only be a member of one scumteam (DDS, Math, Rat, to make off the top of my head) are also more likely to be town.

[T-Bone]

Wow word salad lol. I think the players who are confirmed as not on one scumteam and who are most likely not one scumteam* is what I meant to write to describe those players. DDS/Math is confirmed to all of us and Rat is also confirmed not solar to me.

[T-Bone]

Let me redirect my focus, Prof and I have already given our opinions on his posts.

I've only gotten opinions from meuh and CSF about Prof. Setting aside the slip that may or may not be scum, what about Professor's play makes you think what you think about their alignment (town, scum, or null)? Is it something they are doing? Is it because you don't think scum could do that commuting type action they did? What do you see about Prof's play that I'm not seeing at this point?

[MathBlade]

Prof can you please explain your astral ghost ability again?

[Cat Scratch Fever]

Uhh i thought tictac was kind of townie for him. Would like to see him post more though

Prof what do you think about the DDS claim?

[Cat Scratch Fever]

I've been confused this game by the shitty claimed roles we have had, specifically why we don't have good investigative claims on the board

DDS's role + delayed kills in this game would quite possibly mean DDS' role the strongest we have. At the very least, I do not understand why we can't try to have them confirm their role. If we're wrong about DDS and they flip town, I think it'd be difficult to come back from.

If you're adamant about Scum!DDS, try to find their partners at least

I would also like some opinions on this post!

[Cat Scratch Fever]

Ydrasse why are you voting meuh?

[MegAzumarill]

Fixed Minor Error With VC Showing E-4 instead of E-3

[Past Present Future]

One way to verify DDS role is to have them use it on PPF since meuh will be on PPF

Verifying their role doesn't make them town though, and I'm still struggling to see the intended use of their role

This is why I've said my role doesn't feel that strong! I don't really know what we're meant to do with it

I've been trying to target people that I think are strongly town, not the most likely NK target, and could potentially be targeted
In theory a self-watch is strong-ish but not when someone else gets the info

So we're a Town Illuminator
Every Night/Noon, we can target someone and they'll see who targets them that phase, minus ourselves
If no one else targets them, they'll be told no one targeted them
Effectively it's a 'target this player and they get to self-watch for the night'

Night 1 we illuminated T-Bone
Noon 1 we illuminated Ydrasse
Night 2 we illuminated Scarfmanship

wait a minute

@mod can I get whatever pm's scarf received?

I was specifically hoping you/Ydrasse wouldn't turn up until after T-Bone answered me that's why I claimed while T-Bone was posting and you two weren't

@Dangle, why would you choose to target players that you tr but in your opinion unlikely to be nk targets? I understand that if any of them actually do get targeted, then they get confirmation but how does that work, considering according to you, them all being unlikely targets?

Like who would have been likely to target Ydrasse? I would think it would have made far more sense to have targeted Meuh/Mastina, RR or Math for example since all of them were more likely to be targeted than any of the targets you selected.

[Past Present Future]

I've been confused this game by the shitty claimed roles we have had, specifically why we don't have good investigative claims on the board

DDS's role + delayed kills in this game would quite possibly mean DDS' role the strongest we have. At the very least, I do not understand why we can't try to have them confirm their role. If we're wrong about DDS and they flip town, I think it'd be difficult to come back from.

If you're adamant about Scum!DDS, try to find their partners at least

I would also like some opinions on this post!

I’ve been thinking about MMR post suggesting them and Math as being possible traitors but knowing what they flipped, if they weren’t just wifomming and had some actual reason to think that traitors exist in this game, would they really out their best guess for Lunar traitor?

I mean you can argue possible distancing but it seems more likely that they were either bssing with that, assuming they even have any valid reasons to even think that but pretty much nothing they posted really makes a lot of sense but I don’t think Dangle looks like an MMR buddy.

[Ydrasse]

Ydrasse why are you voting meuh?

mathblade told me to like pages ago

[Past Present Future]

Ydrasse why are you voting meuh?

mathblade told me to like pages ago

What is your read on Meuh?

[Ydrasse]

i have like none i assumed it was a mech thing
i’m literally just waiting to die this game lol and if i’m alive at the end i’m divining the vca to solve

[MathBlade]

UNVOTE:

Lots of work meetings.

[Dingle Dangle Scarecrow]

@Dangle, why would you choose to target players that you tr but in your opinion unlikely to be nk targets?

Because if they get NK'd the action is useless

I understand that if any of them actually do get targeted, then they get confirmation but how does that work, considering according to you, them all being unlikely targets?

Unlikely

night kill

targets

Like who would have been likely to target Ydrasse? I would think it would have made far more sense to have targeted Meuh/Mastina, RR or Math for example since all of them were more likely to be targeted than any of the targets you selected.

It's great that you think those targets make sense

Our #1 priority was targeting people that we thought were town. Because it provides very little benefit to the town if a scum randomly receives some info. Mastina and RR can be likely night action targets as much as they want, but it doesn't benefit me to give them info about who targeted them at night if they're not town.

[Cat Scratch Fever]

Enchant wagon?

[Dingle Dangle Scarecrow]

I'm not sure. He doesn't feel that scummy to me.
...but I'm now remembering that I said almost this exact sentence before in another game where Enchant was scum
I'll consider it

[Cat Scratch Fever]

Rat's push does seem like clinging onto a possibility instead of trying to figure out what is probable. I'm just unsure how they are scum without tbone, who i think is town. If they're indeed scum who is healing town for the cred, then they are a problem for a later day. I suppose they could both be scum doing a hail Mary play, but that feels very eh