In post 330, Gimli wrote:if we can protect the nurse, it's even more important for it to be outed d1, as the inherited ability will be the only confirmed ability and increases our n2 impact immensely. not outing the nurse can get it killed at night.
I don't think there's a possible way to do this, I tried earlier but it didn't seem to work, the cpr doctor just messes things up quite a bit
In post 393, GrandpaMo wrote:
this is a compliment because u play rlly good especially considering u haven tplayed in two years.
also welcome back -- this is also my return as well from like a year to 2
thanks! I feel a lot of my posting has been pure ass though
are we sure that performing NAs the way we're suggesting now (focusing on 2 players) is better than going no NAs? are we sure the nurse is more useful for us hidden than outed on d1?
for instance: we might end up playing a 6er tomorrow with two living mafia and concurring nurse claims, right? isn't it better if we avoid the possibility?
In post 393, GrandpaMo wrote:
this is a compliment because u play rlly good especially considering u haven tplayed in two years.
also welcome back -- this is also my return as well from like a year to 2
thanks! I feel a lot of my posting has been pure ass though
are we sure that performing NAs the way we're suggesting now (focusing on 2 players) is better than going no NAs? are we sure the nurse is more useful for us hidden than outed on d1?
for instance: we might end up playing a 6er tomorrow with two living mafia and concurring nurse claims, right? isn't it better if we avoid the possibility?
i swear enchant's like 10 steps ahead of us and we dont even know it yet. they said we need to play the game and not stall. i feel like these questions are coming up because of the lack of the followup that tabibitos promised to do so.
im giving them the benefit of the doubt. because tabibitos will inherently explain why nurse claiming day 1 is good for their protect the nurse plan. (thats basically their strat) so . because im not understanding this nurse claim stuff yet.
i just thought it was a good idea because regardless of what doc protects the nurse, nurse will never die. i don't see the situation where nurse dies.
@elements can u enlighten me sum more? with an example
"With grandpa in the game the postcount goes up and up and up and up...." - T3 | I have a GTKAS page now. Feel free to ask me questions here!
Sorry not enough time or energy for this yet (about the mech stuff), I am fine doing what you guys agree on if it comes to that
As for reads, I thought about it and maybe Enchant is town for wanting to try targetting someone on their own early, it can e a prerogative to dismiss mech but it's probably town excited for potentially being a vig? Vigging is exciting after all.
Grandpa feels more likely town than not by saying stuff like "I already know the Nurse" on a setup where the Nurse may end up claiming anyway (otherwise it could be rolefishing). Not too sure about grandpa but I don't feel very good about anyone else so I'm gonna like his slot for now.
Elements mech solving is interesting, don't know what to think of that, did you ever do it before Elements? On what game?
- Aether
This is the first time I felt a scum ping reading Aether/Lumine posts
I think at least one of Enchant or Grandpa are town (I ruled out their fight as being scum theater) and here's why:
231 is really similar to how Grandpa talked to me when he tried to get me to change my mind out of my FoS in 159. Unless Grandpa somehow predicted I would read back and look for this, I don't think Grandpa as scum would replicate the same approach he took with me that he would take with a scum buddy because the intent is very different. Then, in 259 I think if Grandpa and Enchant were doing scum theater Grandpa would have lashed back harder, because players take things less personally when they can laugh it out in a PT after, and I think that in a theater sense it would be natural to escalate the emotion there because they had started talking about religion.
In post 391, Gimli wrote:@grandpa: I'm actually not an alt, I haven't played in two years and don't know anyone
wrt abnegation's post, I agree with the logic behind it and I've been advocating for outing the nurse as IC in d1 as well (my idea being turning the game into a 9er with an IC and not use any NAs). But, does that affect your read on freedom?
I don't like this actually because I've seen a lot of scum play this card before. Have you played on other sites since then?
i was just gonna ask u that because i had them on my bottom three of my readlist
towards a null. i first thought they voted abnegation because of their slip i saw but they did it for rvs then abnegation was going back and forth with them?
they have not contributed at all nd like i told enchant (well implied it to them) if they aint scum, then galron is my next on my list.
after that interaction i had with enchant, it made me like them a lot more and so went above galron in my readlist poe
so now i just have galron and freedom as my bottom two.
yeah, one of galron's 8 posts is voting shirou (who slipped their main acc into the thread playing under a hydra), in a way that felt like just trying to post some content and look like scumhunting. then unvoting and not moving anywhere else shows lack of intent, which I don't like
Is that something you have actually seen scum doing though?
wrt your three questions: no I didn't play anywhere else since my last game here (it was bad and I felt bad about playing mafia again). my reasons for thinking it might be scum indicative for galron to be voting/unvoting shirou, as I tried explaining already, are because it doesn't feel like a real attempt at scumhunting. Have I seen scum specifically voting a main acc that slipped into a thread? No, I don't remember this specific scenario ever happening before and am not basing the scumread in past games I played.
Why am I townreading vanderskamp? I'm not sure that I am anymore, but I liked how he pushed grandpa and that's why I had him as town. My top townread is elements, and then you're a close second. I like that you're questioning me as well and the way you're doing it.
vander's ISO doesn't give me much of a reason to townread it. I might have more reason to townread freedom's deadpan reaction to being potentially bandwagoned and whatnot, than whatever it is that I saw yesterday from vand
a stupid read from before I went to bed is that, the way people are pushing and interacting with freedom diminishes potential scum mate combinations. other than with galron, I think.
