Open 870 | White Flag Mountainous | Postgame

[petapan]

Vote Count 3.02

Popocatépetl
Mexico-Puebla-Morelos, Mexico
Elevation: 5,426 meters

fireisredsir (3):

Cat Scratch Fever, Shirou, NorwegianboyEE

Shirou (1):

furtiveglance

Not Voting (5):

fireisredsir, Gimli, giuseppina, Klick, Toto

With 9 alive, it's 5 to eliminate.

Deadline for Day 3 is January 31 at 6:30 PM EST.

Deadline Timer:

(expired on 2023-01-31 18:30:00)

[furtiveglance]

If you're not going to provide any reasonings then what's the point of ur push Shirou. Do you think i'm so easily limmable you can just say you got me and that's enough?

I'm gonna provide some reasons tomorrow, just not what I believe to be the meta tell.

Either way Norwe...you seem more interested on knowing why I'm scum reading you rather than having a problem with the read itself?

What do you expect? An outrage? I get scumread and tunneled as town almost every game.
It's routine to me at this point, identify cause for the scumread. Try to identify if attacker is town or scum. Dismantle the argument. Try to put focus on the real mafia.

Tgp is probably town for that.

I also didn’t particurarly like the theories about Shirou bussing from Aristeia. I think it’s to the interest of scum to make Shirou’s reputation falter in this game because there are no nightkills so mafia must really try to make the powerful and potentially problematic players less influental. And Shirou imo is probably one of the strongest players in this list simply because of how menacing he is. Scum nightkill them early almost every game no matter how bad their reads may be at that moment.
Not fanboying, just an observation.

there are nightkills

I thought mountainous meant no nightkills.

If this is scum, I'll just have to cope. But it isn't

[furtiveglance]

their* ISO

[fireisredsir]

i also kinda had written him off as town and i keep coming back to that but im not as sure as i would like to be

[furtiveglance]

i also kinda had written him off as town and i keep coming back to that but im not as sure as i would like to be

Do you enjoy this? The not-knowing

[fireisredsir]

that just leaves klick and gimli which. feels unsatisfying to me

which brings me back to shirou

[Lazy Shirou]

Replacing giuseppina.

hm

it's me again isn't it

i'm sorry i'm a petulant child that keeps screaming until i get what i want but idk if i can ever change or if i want to change bc if neither of fire/furt is scum this game is wild and i want to see it with my own eyes asap

[furtiveglance]

Replacing giuseppina.

hm

it's me again isn't it

i'm sorry i'm a petulant child that keeps screaming until i get what i want but idk if i can ever change or if i want to change bc if neither of fire/furt is scum this game is wild and i want to see it with my own eyes asap

I'm about to blow your mind

I don't think Fire is mafia. I re-read Ari/Fire and I don't think so

[fireisredsir]

i also kinda had written him off as town and i keep coming back to that but im not as sure as i would like to be

Do you enjoy this? The not-knowing

thats an interesting question and im not exactly sure what you mean

i find the puzzle of trying to solve the game to be enjoyable, so i guess yes in a way? but in this specific case for the sake of solving the game it would be easier to do so if i did know norwee's alignment

[furtiveglance]

Replacing giuseppina.

hm

it's me again isn't it

i'm sorry i'm a petulant child that keeps screaming until i get what i want but idk if i can ever change or if i want to change bc if neither of fire/furt is scum this game is wild and i want to see it with my own eyes asap

Shirou, what happened to your Lucian read. Why did you drop it

[furtiveglance]

i also kinda had written him off as town and i keep coming back to that but im not as sure as i would like to be

Do you enjoy this? The not-knowing

thats an interesting question and im not exactly sure what you mean

i find the puzzle of trying to solve the game to be enjoyable, so i guess yes in a way? but in this specific case for the sake of solving the game it would be easier to do so if i did know norwee's alignment

This is my favourite part of Mafia

Trying to work out who it is, it's just the essence of the game

Quite stressful tho

[Lazy Shirou]

i cannot stop thinking and fearing the possibility of me being wrong on both of them

and that's exactly why i also want they dead asap

if there's such a sweet rush in this game as a final day where i realize this game is a hard puzzle and the answer won't be simple, i crave it.

i'm sorry pina i never meant to offend you or anything in this game by rushing if this is what it's about

[Lazy Shirou]

Replacing giuseppina.

hm

it's me again isn't it

i'm sorry i'm a petulant child that keeps screaming until i get what i want but idk if i can ever change or if i want to change bc if neither of fire/furt is scum this game is wild and i want to see it with my own eyes asap

I'm about to blow your mind

I don't think Fire is mafia. I re-read Ari/Fire and I don't think so

yes ofc bc he's either a partner or you want him flipping town to discredit me on u

very clever furtive i give it a B+

[Lazy Shirou]

i'm about to blow ur mind furtive

i love chatting with u in sitechat but after many hours thinking i still want u exterminated in this game

s2

[Lazy Shirou]

pls petapan i need dayvigs u gotta give me dayvigs pls

[fireisredsir]

This is my favourite part of Mafia

Trying to work out who it is, it's just the essence of the game

Quite stressful tho

i agree then yea

i think the most exciting part (of playing town, since i usually enjoy scum more) is when i think i've found a solve or when i realize i was wrongly townbinning a scum who's been playing a really good game

i have trouble expressing those solves confidently though because i feel a lot of intense embarrassment and shame when i get things wrong

so i guess the overall more fun experience is the process of sorting it out

[Cat Scratch Fever]

that just leaves klick and gimli which. feels unsatisfying to me

which brings me back to shirou

Why is this unsatisfying? If you're town, i think my solve actually goes to klick/gimli

[NorwegianboyEE]

This is my favourite part of Mafia

Trying to work out who it is, it's just the essence of the game

Quite stressful tho

i agree then yea

i think the most exciting part (of playing town, since i usually enjoy scum more) is when i think i've found a solve or when i realize i was wrongly townbinning a scum who's been playing a really good game

i have trouble expressing those solves confidently though because i feel a lot of intense embarrassment and shame when i get things wrong

so i guess the overall more fun experience is the process of sorting it out

I feel dirty and violated if someone i strongly townread is scum.

[furtiveglance]

i'm about to blow ur mind furtive

i love chatting with u in sitechat but after many hours thinking i still want u exterminated in this game

s2

You're never in sitechat

Are you an alt?

[furtiveglance]

This is my favourite part of Mafia

Trying to work out who it is, it's just the essence of the game

Quite stressful tho

i agree then yea

i think the most exciting part (of playing town, since i usually enjoy scum more) is when i think i've found a solve or when i realize i was wrongly townbinning a scum who's been playing a really good game

i have trouble expressing those solves confidently though because i feel a lot of intense embarrassment and shame when i get things wrong

so i guess the overall more fun experience is the process of sorting it out

I feel dirty and violated if someone i strongly townread is scum.

Yeah but that's the risk you take for the glory of being right

[fireisredsir]

that just leaves klick and gimli which. feels unsatisfying to me

which brings me back to shirou

Why is this unsatisfying? If you're town, i think my solve actually goes to klick/gimli

idk it might be right? it just feels like neither did much to position themselves well off the tgp flip and that makes the scumteam feel kinda... limp, i guess

which maybe they were? but i feel like those solves in my experience are usually less likely to actually be correct

that's more of a general feeling than specific to this game. and due to this mechanic id probably still want to flip in there bc even if there is a hidden scum somewhere else they can't solo endgame. and it's believable that one of them could be partnered with someone else

[furtiveglance]

that just leaves klick and gimli which. feels unsatisfying to me

which brings me back to shirou

Why is this unsatisfying? If you're town, i think my solve actually goes to klick/gimli

I think Klick is town, but Gimli is my biggest scumread by a mile. A country mile. I think Lucian's posting was extremely weak and has bad
associatives with TGP

I may as well put a vote down because I think Gimli's elimination ends the game. I was waiting for most/everyone to be here and people are now

VOTE: Gimli

[fireisredsir]

i actually usually don't feel bad at all if i strongly townread scum. im just impressed at how well they played

i do feel like a little bad if i townread them but had doubts but wasn't willing to push those doubts hard enough. or sometimes slightly salty if i townread them for really dumb reasons

[fireisredsir]

like i dunno gimli ending the day strongly townreading me and furtive just doesn't feel like someone who has planned ahead very far as scum

which like

it's possible that he is just scum who didn't plan ahead very far and then that's why he kinda limply came into the day with "well you guys can lim furtive. i disagree but i won't stop you"

like tbh thats probably more likely than him doing that as town

i guess i just usually assume scum have more of a long term agenda and goals and he would really need to not die as someone in the poe

[fireisredsir]

i do think that probably someone who std scumread is scum tho