In post 918, redFF wrote:
dr drew pretending he didn't know there is a 3p
Red pretending he didn't catch up on the game.
You clearly read the setup, so why play dumb about catching up on the game that you subbed into?
I can maybe see red!mafia, still haven't done my re-read, but the logic here isn't very strong. Catching up on the game requires reading the 27 pages before they got here, while reading the setup literally means looking at the four points at the bottom of post 1.
In post 918, redFF wrote:
dr drew pretending he didn't know there is a 3p
Red pretending he didn't catch up on the game.
You clearly read the setup, so why play dumb about catching up on the game that you subbed into?
I can maybe see red!mafia, still haven't done my re-read, but the logic here isn't very strong. Catching up on the game requires reading the 27 pages before they got here, while reading the setup literally means looking at the four points at the bottom of post 1.
P-edit: Porkens, you need to explain.
- Nyx
I rarely read the the specific setup(meaning, it is 9:3:1 as it is here, stuff like that), I read the theme and any special mechanics of the game before I join in, I generally like crazier closed setups with borderline bastard elements, and a setup chosen by chatGPT seemed to fit that.
Yes I then went back and looked at the post you mentioned and saw the set up here after you mentioned it.
Red when asked if that caught up with the game responded with 'uhhh', if you bothered to start with page one and saw the setup, why would you just stop there?
'dREW DID IT BETTER' - T-Bone
'doctor drew our hero' - Shiki
'I love playing with him, he's got an amazing presence to him that just feels like the game is lacking something when he's not there' - JacksonVirgo
I could explain. Menal could explain. That would give the mafia and 3p a ton of information.
or OR you could all just accept that Menal, me, and KT are locktown and start eliminating the probscums. Which will be what we do anyway if we do reveal, and this way we deny mafia/3p any more infomration.
In post 920, Porkens wrote:
I am mechanically certain that KT is town. It's an inconvenient truth.
I will play along, I just need to hear from KT, and Menal needs to explain more.
It would be really clutch if playing along included not needing to have menal explain more.
I don't want Menal to explain more about there role, just explain the SK thing, if talking about it outs their role.....they they should shut the fuck up.
But I do really need to hear from kitty.
Pre Edit: Hmm ok(I swear to Christ if there is a Cult situation that I am not involved in, I will be very upset)
VOTE: Red
'dREW DID IT BETTER' - T-Bone
'doctor drew our hero' - Shiki
'I love playing with him, he's got an amazing presence to him that just feels like the game is lacking something when he's not there' - JacksonVirgo
In post 929, Porkens wrote:
I could explain. Menal could explain. That would give the mafia and 3p a ton of information.
or OR you could all just accept that Menal, me, and KT are locktown and start eliminating the probscums. Which will be what we do anyway if we do reveal, and this way we deny mafia/3p any more infomration.
I can live with not knowing everything but given you could die tonight I want specifically to know if you can rule out Menalque being mafia and Titus having roleblocked KittyTacky. Because that's the scenario I'm wondering about.
In that scenario, either KittyTacky is SK and got blocked, or is town and SK targeted furtive, or there's no SK. So it seems to me this scenario could apply even if you have certainty of Kitty being town.
"holy shit this entire time i thought imaginalitys profile was a purple seahorse" - camelCasedSnivy
I think I can rule out Menal mafia because of what they have claimed so far plus the fact that they claimed anything. I can't guarantee that titus didn't block kittytacky, but I doubt it.
In post 918, redFF wrote:
dr drew pretending he didn't know there is a 3p
Red pretending he didn't catch up on the game.
You clearly read the setup, so why play dumb about catching up on the game that you subbed into?
Yeah, there's something wrong about this. Drew, why are you playing dumb about the fact that the literal first thing Red was told ingame was about the setup?
Happy to lim red for now and then talk more about who we lim tomorrow
I am also kinda bothered by drew completely missing the 3rd party talk that happened I think twice (?) earlier in the game and that I managed to pick up on despite barely having been here? But was reading him as strongly town before that so I’m not sure how much to read into it
I picked up on the SK talk, which had me confused.
I didn't realize it was an open setup and that 3p was in play, like I said glossed over it.
'dREW DID IT BETTER' - T-Bone
'doctor drew our hero' - Shiki
'I love playing with him, he's got an amazing presence to him that just feels like the game is lacking something when he's not there' - JacksonVirgo
Like I said it’s really mostly gut, but I think I have a very good gut.
Is it gut or are you mechanically certain? Because no offence but I don’t really care about how sure you are based on gut when I have strong mechanical reasons to think that KT is scum or 3rd party scum. If you have a mechanical clear on KT then I need you to tell me yes or no to the question of whether it was from last night?
