In post 450, Thestatusquo wrote:
trying to play mafia by having a solve 18 pages into day 1 is truly bizarre.
Please Stop Evaluating the Accuracy of my Reads By How they are Presented and the Confidence behind them and Instead Evaluate them for what they Are, thank you
This is literally insane. Of course I'm going to evaluate the way you come up when I'm evaluating whether they're good or not.
If you don't want criticism on how you form reads form them in a more sane way
In post 450, Thestatusquo wrote:
trying to play mafia by having a solve 18 pages into day 1 is truly bizarre.
Please Stop Evaluating the Accuracy of my Reads By How they are Presented and the Confidence behind them and Instead Evaluate them for what they Are, thank you
This is literally insane. Of course I'm going to evaluate the way you come up when I'm evaluating whether they're good or not.
If you don't want criticism on how you form reads form them in a more sane way
In post 450, Thestatusquo wrote:
trying to play mafia by having a solve 18 pages into day 1 is truly bizarre.
Please Stop Evaluating the Accuracy of my Reads By How they are Presented and the Confidence behind them and Instead Evaluate them for what they Are, thank you
This is literally insane. Of course I'm going to evaluate the way you come up when I'm evaluating whether they're good or not.
If you don't want criticism on how you form reads form them in a more sane way
You Misread.
I Meant You Should Not Have a Negative Bias towards my Conclusion Because you think my Method is "Wrong"
In post 450, Thestatusquo wrote:
trying to play mafia by having a solve 18 pages into day 1 is truly bizarre.
Please Stop Evaluating the Accuracy of my Reads By How they are Presented and the Confidence behind them and Instead Evaluate them for what they Are, thank you
This is literally insane. Of course I'm going to evaluate the way you come up when I'm evaluating whether they're good or not.
If you don't want criticism on how you form reads form them in a more sane way
You Misread.
I Meant You Should Not Have a Negative Bias towards my Conclusion Because you think my Method is "Wrong"
But i absolutely should when it comes to determining if i agree with you.
Meh Just Have seen Too Many Town Games Lost Because of dismissed Correct Reads for that Reason is All
On Another Note My Goal for You vs Baltar is to 1. Solidify my Read on Both of You and 2. Make sure You don't Speak Past Eachother
I mean This in a Nice Way as in Cooperation so Please don't take This as Me talking Down, I May Yet be Convinced if Reality is Indeed One Of You Two, I Just Do Not want this To become Circular is All.
(I Feel Pensive About You Blowing up On me If I'm being Honest)
Hello Alisae Would You Like to Consider My Read of HellBooks and Sheep paired and Tell Me if I am Missing Something that Maybe Disproves it Or See If you Do Agree.
(I Also Find Pleasure in the Fooling Part as a Puzzle by Figuring Out Paths To victory and In Closed, Solving the Setup and PR readings, the Latter 2 Also being Something I enjoy as Town)
Hello Alisae Would You Like to Consider My Read of HellBooks and Sheep paired and Tell Me if I am Missing Something that Maybe Disproves it Or See If you Do Agree.
You think hellbooks is aligned with sheep?
I feel like hellbooks hasn't done anything super alignment indicative at all but I want to say they're probably town so like idunno lol
Hello Alisae Would You Like to Consider My Read of HellBooks and Sheep paired and Tell Me if I am Missing Something that Maybe Disproves it Or See If you Do Agree.
You think hellbooks is aligned with sheep?
I feel like hellbooks hasn't done anything super alignment indicative at all but I want to say they're probably town so like idunno lol
She Has A kinda Scummy Gaslight Gatekeep Girlboss Vibe if That Makes sense
Are you Team Resolve Sheep and Go From There?
X is scum so i will find y on page 18 with neither of them flipped is so fraught with peril that i think your read of x is no better than rand even if i buy the premise that x is scum.
And quite frankly you don't get to appeal to proficiency (i.e so many correct reads ignored) when playing on an alt because i can't go verify that claim myself. I doubt it on face because I've been playing this game a very long time and I've never seen the methods you're describing here be more than mildly successful except by dumb luck but you definitely don't get to go 'trust me I'm good' when you're playing on an alt and i can't verify that.
Which is to say that the part of the game you're missing that alisae is referring to i think is you have to convince people to actually Lim your scum reads. If you're going to convince me to Lim your scum reads it's never going to be with arguments like those
I mean like idunno lol I wouldn't even say i want to resolve anything right now i just want more things to happen and this gamestate doesn't feel like people actively have to play
