Micro 1083: Garlic Bread Heist! (Game Over)

[Alisae]

like I don't think they're mafia for that post.
I don't think that would be very convincing.

I think they are making that post as a member of the mafia

[Alisae]

like only u sky tris and sheep posted at that point

[Garlic Bread]

oh my god the person shea made a joke about because 2 people already voted for them happened to later flip mafia


clearly the only conclusion here is that he was 100% informed of baltar's alignment....


this is the same tired type of illogical arguments you threw out in team mafia trying to get people to vote mith

regardless i have been sure as hell trying to do my due diligence on a slot that has been actively insulting me in the earlier parts of the game once my identity was revealed -> if you think to convince me with arguments that have 0 bearing on one's alignment beyond a coincidence we can just eliminate you.

[Alisae]

I am sorry that I am better villager than you are @ micros

[Garlic Bread]

like I don't think they're mafia for that post.
I don't think that would be very convincing.

I think they are making that post as a member of the mafia

or u can not waste our time discussing obviously inconclusive posts if you are aware its not convincing ?

[Garlic Bread]

yes because shea is going to get super big mad at me for pushing sheep while letting me push baltar for free and then later himself also pushing baltar

mhmm

[Alisae]

or u can not waste our time discussing obviously inconclusive posts if you are aware its not convincing ?

wasting time lmfao
ya cuz that time isn't being used by anyone

[Alisae]

yes because shea is going to get super big mad at me for pushing sheep while letting me push baltar for free and then later himself also pushing baltar

mhmm

Sure wynaut, I would consider that good team play.
Shea getting mad at you and deliberating making game atmosphere worse is a tool that's in his toolbox and if it means people will trust you or be willing to work with you less they'll do it

[Alisae]

if I am town who is it koba?

[Garlic Bread]

its either you or tris and thats my final answer

i'll recheck my role pm if im alive at final 4 and 2 town flips from that pair

[Alisae]

TRIS???????????

[Alisae]

why would it be tris?

[Garlic Bread]

hey i'm voting you first aren't I?

[Alisae]

ok you are wrong or mafia
probably just wrong

[Garlic Bread]

actually i take it back its either ali or xof but tris is insurance

[Alisae]

xof??????????????

[Garlic Bread]

Vibes:

Garlic Bread - I'm kinda all over the place here. Like, the non-gimmick vibes Bread gives off reminds me somebody I've played with before, but I can't quite pinpoint it, but it does make me feel differently about some of their posts. They're not a Day 1 problem is really the gist of it. I thought the gimmick was cute, and preferred over serious posting. Serious posting in the gimmick isn't my favourite either. I don't have a conclusion on them one way or another, but my gut says to keep a close watch as this is a player who plays hard as either alignment.

Baltar - I like Baltar posts. Nothing pings me badly, his reactions seem genuine and nothing he's said feels like it's trying to get me to read him in a certain light. A kind of, can't be arsed to waste energy maintaining perception vibe, but in a way I have to nod in mutual understanding/respect about. Idk, it works for me. Haven't really seen anything I'd call AI yet, but he posts in a way that he's a good person to revisit after we have any flips imo.

hellbooks - Early hellbooks posting was fun and good vibey. I kinda feel like she's overcorrected in response to pressure, and jokes she makes now hit different and less fun. Like, the vibes have changed, and i'm unsure if this is scummy defense reaction or justifiable "somebody took something i meant in a joking way as something that upset them and now they're grumpy with me" defense, both can read the same and I don't think I know hellbooks well enough to know how the difference feels.

Alisae - This just feels like good Alisae I like playing with. Though this is how Ali also read to me in TM when i was still reading their game, so maybe Ali's just really good at getting me to trust them >:( I'm sure if there's anything I should find sus here, it'll pop up eventually. Good vibe box for now.

Shea - I'm never sure if I'm just reading Shea in a positive light just because of how much I like him as a person, or because that's how he's playing in games. And I'm aware this is a weak spot, but here we are. That being said, while you started out by saying that you wanted to lurk and chill more, I'm missing some of that very pointed directed questioning you do a lot in games. That isn't to say you aren't questioning people on things they say and giving your thoughts to them, but there's usually a different force to them that I'm not seeing here. But I don't think it's AI, might just be Tired

sheep - People who make posts that are almost wholly one single sentence always make me wrinkle my nose, unless they're doing a Gamma Emerald and responding in real-time as they read the game. sheep's vibe is just lost. Like, I think he's more noncommital than I am. I wish he'd give more specific reasonings or what posts and which words caused his vibescheck results to change. It's just a lot of fluff, but fluff that if somebody says something strong enough he can change his opinion as he needs to. Which might be scummy, but I'm not confident on that.

tris - tris pops in and posts some silly, which I don't mind, because she also has some posts that show she's thinking about the game and how she's thinking about it. I would like a little more, but I think this is a good amount of tris.

Skygazer - whomst? no but actually, i know I've read Skygazer posts but I couldn't tell you a single thing about them on gut. Which after skimming iso here, seems to be a shame cuz these are some decent posts. I think I just keep losing her amidst all the hyper posters. They've got a ton of posts that have reasoning in them, and even if meta only means so much I do appreciate that they mention which games they're comparing to, and i tend to like people who ask for specific places to focus and then follow up once they've gotten that. Very solid good vibes box.

I don't have strong enough opinions on most people to gather everybody into their respective town pool, null pond, and scum puddle this time round. But since it was said the people who are in good vibes territory being mentioned would be preferred, that would be Skygazer and Alisae.

[Alisae]

their baltar read can come from town is there something else that strikes you as off in that post

[Alisae]

It's not like Baltar was incapable of faking wolfhunting because he was certainly trying to do that

[Garlic Bread]

funny thats not the part that concerns me, I'm looking for TMI because of the fact the threadstate has every slot having pushed on shea/made interactions that are fairly convincingly unpaired in some way

[Alisae]

oh

im not great at trying to find tmi if its not early stages of the game but ig this is kind of early

[Garlic Bread]

but also i think youre kinda TMIing rn worse than what I saw here so eh + the attempted hammer had a bad reaction when called on it to me + weird push onto shea + undisclosed tell that applies to current gamestate and how you have treated them before in the past as scum

[Alisae]

I don't see it

[Alisae]

you can be wrong ig its rly not my problem if you don't wanna vote mafia

[Alisae]

how did u get so bad at reading me lol