Veiled Committee Mafia: List Mods Edition [game over]

[Cook]

oh right and on that note i need to type up my thoughts on snivy

[Skygazer]

my role pm is default text color other than my rolename. which is green and not red because i'm definitely town haha

again i don't think it'll help us solve much at all tbh and it seems like a time sink. the same listmod could use different formattings. scum could lie about their formatting. etc etc

[DragonEater70]

Alisae can I get a tl;dr about your red PM?

i laughed out loud irl

Alisae can I get a tl;dr about your red PM?

OMG OMG OMG OMG

woah there. you can't have two reactions to the same post.

slow your roll

Okay Aureal has got a point.

[camelCasedSnivy]

then why do you want to vote ircher

they feel scummy

gut feeling

[Cook]

vibes

lmao

[KatyKimFanClub]

Like, how tf does a TOWNIE with a red PM not remember that fact because it should've triggered some confusion. A Mafia, on the other hand, wouldn't see anything strange and probably wouldn't even register that town can get red PMs until someone points it out.

The way I read it, she might have mixed up the red ooc modtext in this thread and the red PMs. At least, that's what I did because at first I thought I had red PMs too.

[Save The Dragons]

wait what about alisae's response makes you think they are scum and not that they didn't understand you were talking about PM color (which is something we definitely shouldn't be concerned about because the sample PM is red so scum know that PMs are red)

[Aureal]

Like, how tf does a TOWNIE with a red PM not remember that fact because it should've triggered some confusion. A Mafia, on the other hand, wouldn't see anything strange and probably wouldn't even register that town can get red PMs until someone points it out.

The way I read it, she might have mixed up the red ooc modtext in this thread and the red PMs. At least, that's what I did because at first I thought I had red PMs too.

What the heck does this mean?

wait what about alisae's response makes you think they are scum and not that they didn't understand you were talking about PM color (which is something we definitely shouldn't be concerned about because the sample PM is red so scum know that PMs are red)

Did you even read what Alisae posted in response to me, it clearly comes from a mindset of red PM=Mafia.

[KatyKimFanClub]

What the heck does this mean?

Maybe this is super tenuous but the initial Alisae red PM claim and then

I mandella effected i thought xyzzy used their ooc formatting for role pms.

This made me think her PM wasn't red at all and she just made a mistake?

[KatyKimFanClub]

I think I'm missing an important Alisae post and I shouldn't have butted my head in here without knowing it.

[DragonEater70]

What the heck does this mean?

the [ ooc] tag creates text that looks like this:
words and more words

Now KKFC was saying either one of two things:

1. That when they read the sample PM in the OP, the entire post was using the ooc tag, not only the PM. Therefore they thought that the actual PM would be white/green (this is basically a scum claim).
   
2. The more likely option, that when they received their PM it had the ooc tag, and for a second they thought they were scum then realized it's just the ooc tag rather than indicative of alignment. However this is not a good defense of what Aureal had been saying about Alisae.

[DragonEater70]

btw I'm back from watching anime.

[DragonEater70]

@Katy: the exact confusion you seem to have had is what Alisae seems to be missing which is why Aureal suspects her.

[Alisae]

yeeeeeeeeeeees talk about me moooooooooooore

[Alisae]

this is the moment I've been waiting for baby!!!!!!

[KatyKimFanClub]

What the heck does this mean?

the [ ooc] tag creates text that looks like this:
words and more words

Now KKFC was saying either one of two things:

1. That when they read the sample PM in the OP, the entire post was using the ooc tag, not only the PM. Therefore they thought that the actual PM would be white/green (this is basically a scum claim).
   
2. The more likely option, that when they received their PM it had the ooc tag, and for a second they thought they were scum then realized it's just the ooc tag rather than indicative of alignment. However this is not a good defense of what Aureal had been saying about Alisae.

My role PM is colorless. My impression is that Alisae thought she had a red PM, then realized it was not red and rather the red text she had been seeing was in this thread. I didn't see anything inherently scum about this, but I think Aureal is a good player, and thus there's probably an argument or post that I'm missing.

[Alisae]

I think Aureal is a good player,

lmao

[KatyKimFanClub]

I think Aureal is a good player,

lmao

? I'm working with a small sample size but yeah?

[DragonEater70]

My role PM is colorless

Then what exactly confused you about the color of your PM?

At least, that's what I did because at first I thought I had red PMs too.

[DragonEater70]

Actually can we NOT have another Aureal v Alisae? I'm still traumatized from Newbie 2114.

[KatyKimFanClub]

Then what exactly confused you about the color of your PM?

1) I got a colorless (normal color?) role PM
2) I went to the thread to find the rule to confirm my role
3) The post with rules was in the red OOC text
4) I think at that point I thought in my head "I have a red role PM"
5) I read posts like 41 and thought to myself "checks out"

The way I read it, Aureal made a joke about Alisae having a red PM (scum), and then Alisae actually thought she got a red PM, then she realized she didn't? But my understanding of events could be entirely wrong.

[DragonEater70]

Then what exactly confused you about the color of your PM?

1) I got a colorless (normal color?) role PM
2) I went to the thread to find the rule to confirm my role
3) The post with rules was in the red OOC text
4) I think at that point I thought in my head "I have a red role PM"
5) I read posts like 41 and thought to myself "checks out"

The way I read it, Aureal made a joke about Alisae having a red PM (scum), and then Alisae actually thought she got a red PM, then she realized she didn't? But my understanding of events could be entirely wrong.

Okay these points 1-5 make a lot of sense. I'm unsure about Alisae thing but tbh I prefer to hold judgement on that for later. I have to reread the StD v Bingle thing like I'd promised.

[Doctor Drew]

I think Aureal has been watching too many of my games lol.

[DragonEater70]

@Bingle, for you:

they started game townie

?

So far all I've seen is popins and easy takes. They seem relaxed, but I don't think STD being relaxed in the main thread is particularly hard for him to fake and all of his takes just feel like they're incredibly safe. Do you disagree?

I can agree that they've mostly posted safe takes. I don't think scumreading AniX or townreading Cook or Bingle is risky, especially with little to no explanation provided like StD did.

anix being scum is an easy take?

It's a safe take which is not the same.

Yes?

Like, their posting is performative as shit. But anyone who has ever talked to AniX could tell you that. For example: (Was gonna link a thread that I now think is in the SPeezy cause I can't find it easily on this account) that time when they posted like 400 paragraphs as a protest against popularity contests.

Saying AniX is scummy here is like the easiest stance you could possibly take.

No clue what is SPeezy, I think I agree it is the easiest stance to make which is why I was hesitant to scumread AniX even when they were making silly accusations because that's just TOO easy to scumread.

why aren't more people taking it

You mean people like Ali and Koba and Cook?

i mean people like you and at least 2 other town reads Anix got

I don't see how this is disingenuous still. It's probably a thoughtless remark not realizing that some people either just read the game differently or intentionally go against consensus read.

anix barely has reads for someone posting with such verbosity

This I definitely agree with. I don't feel AniX has given any meaningful reads and has only given a few baseless mech reads which are not even AI (Koba's purported post restriction wouldn't be attached to a scum role IMO). And this is why I'm still voting AniX right now.

[DragonEater70]

I think Aureal has been watching too many of my games lol.

Hm?