Veiled Committee Mafia: List Mods Edition [game over]

[camelCasedSnivy]

my case on aureal is that im paranoid

my case on random nurse because of the claim

actually, i think nurse could be in our group and just added the "non-consecutive" in case he needs to use his power to stop a breaking strategy

[camelCasedSnivy]

also im 90% sure ranger is lying about the miller part because that seems really extraneous aspect to a role

[camelCasedSnivy]

*seems like a

[camelCasedSnivy]

nurse does seems to be a bit different from the other game i was in with him

[DragonEater70]

You know what, time to scumcase Ranger.

actually tomorrow cause it's fucking late

@Koba I'm sure you will be happy since I am no longer pushing Cook and stepping up my game like you wanted.

Also while I'm on it I might as well towncase the hell out of Aureal because I don't like the votes on her at all. But again, this be tomorrow.

Oh shit I just remembered I was suppose to submit a clue to Codenames. Uhhh I'll do that and then go to sleep.

[Ranger]

I give up. Cook ur gonna have to fight this out yourself bc it's not helpful that I'm trying to defend u while you're basically doing nothing atp

Post solving content like giving us a PoE or a town core or any sort of reads, bc the more you play like this the more it feels like you are intentionally anti spewing basically.

Why would Cook need to fight when you're giving her an out?

Cook > Meuh > Aureal > No-lim > All other eliminations today.

I honestly don't care about your Random Nurse push.

Could Random Nurse be scum? Sure. I disagree with the read; I could be wrong.

Could Cook be town? I'm fairly certain the answer is no.

Cook is in my group of four, guaranteed.
Since we have a group of four, there's guaranteed scum in the group of four.
My role directly counters Cook's.
Cook's play is that of scum.

Random Nurse

could

be scum; I guarantee Cook

is

scum.

[Ranger]

why is cook scummy

2472, 2155, backed by 2043 and 999.


You can see the behavior I mention of Cook's demeanor shift around 2006/2008 among others.


For why my role is a direct counter to Cook's, refer to 1979.


Supporting the Meuhslot-Cook connection, you can look to the likes of 1990 (not the best, I don't have handy the posts best discussing the connection), with things like 716 demonstrating it.

[Ranger]

Ranger please give me your AniX towncase so I can townbin you.

Honestly, I've forgotten why I townread AniX.

I don't really think AniX is scum; I've no reason for it. Right now, gut I guess.

Sorry, I know it's not the answer you want.

[Ranger]

RN's ISO here is night and day with the town!RN I just played with so
VOTE: RandomNurse

Funny you mention night/day differences as this is night/day difference from the Meuh I've seen from your towngames.

[Ranger]

RN's ISO here is night and day with the town!RN I just played with so
VOTE: RandomNurse

Funny you mention night/day differences as this is night/day difference from the Meuh I've seen from your towngames.

It honestly feels like Meuh isn't even trying to hide being scum.

Cook's been the lead wagon for the entire time I've been pushing her.

DKKoba proposes a Random Nurse wagon, which has some support (mostly from the scummiest slots in the game), and Meuh joins the efforts there.

This is not the level of analysis a town-Meuh shows, and Meuh's vibes are completely off.

[Ranger]

I'll read up some in my lunch break today, and probably finish tonight. Anything anyone wants in the immediate future?

Review 2043, and 2756, go into the Cook-Ranger joint iso to see when Cook's demeanor changed (it was after I called Cook deepscum), go into a Cook-Drew iso to see their connection, and optionally:
Iso camelCasedSnivy and KatyKimFanClub to confirm they're town.

[Ranger]

Is there a full claim list somewhere?

For a likely breakdown of the setup, 2043.

It's not guaranteed, Bingle disagrees with some of the groupings, yet the 'implosion' grouping of four is guaranteed, and per game mechanics, that group of four {Ranger, Cook, camelCasedSnivy, KatyKimFanClub} is guaranteed to have one scum.

In the off chance you actually

aren't

scum with Cook, you should be voting her.

[Ranger]

why are we doing apathy elimination

Cook isn't an apathy elimination. Cook is the best definitive lead for scum we have.

There's no

definitive

group of four beyond the 'implosion' group. I've suspicions, yet nothing absolutely confirmed. The definitive group's guaranteed one scum, so to hit scum, you shouldn't be voting outside {Ranger, Cook, camelCasedSnivy, KatyKimFanClub}.

My role directly counters Cook's, in a way further guaranteeing we are in the same group. As the roles are direct counters, and Cook's role provides massive +scum utility by crippling town players with negative modifiers, there's a high chance Cook's role is a scum role.

These, aside from Cook's play.

[Ranger]

You know what, time to scumcase Ranger.

That'll be interesting.

[DkKoba]

why are we doing apathy elimination

Cook isn't an apathy elimination. Cook is the best definitive lead for scum we have.

There's no

definitive

group of four beyond the 'implosion' group. I've suspicions, yet nothing absolutely confirmed. The definitive group's guaranteed one scum, so to hit scum, you shouldn't be voting outside {Ranger, Cook, camelCasedSnivy, KatyKimFanClub}.

My role directly counters Cook's, in a way further guaranteeing we are in the same group. As the roles are direct counters, and Cook's role provides massive +scum utility by crippling town players with negative modifiers, there's a high chance Cook's role is a scum role.

These, aside from Cook's play.

i will vote you out before cook if you want to play it this way

[DkKoba]

like if you think cook is scum over camel/kkfc we dont need that energy going into d2, so fucking what if it counters yours? it doesnt mean its scum, i have made town roles that counter town roles when designing setups and its actually pretty common? like the idea is that there is a risk that townies will hit eachother and reduce the chances of usefulness ???

cook's play is fine, townier than yours i might add, as i find it odd you dropped the readslist thing and are actively pushing reasoning.

[DkKoba]

like "this role counters mine!!!" is the most non reasoning of all time? jingle back me up please

[ofrhz]

I still don't think cook's read progressions are real. The aureal read makes no sense.

We could also just lim meuh

[KatyKimFanClub]

Ranger is making a lot of sense tbh

[KatyKimFanClub]

First person to quote this gets

culted

amway'd

[Cook]

this is a parachute

[DkKoba]

this is a parachute

take parachute

[DkKoba]

wait am i about to get pranked

[Cook]

it doesn't do anything i just realized how similar amway is to parachutes

[Bingle]

oH god I did not think the role list was that intense

It's also not completely accurate. There is additional nuance to multiple roles. For example, Cook is a random neg utility she doesn't know about, DK flips as a currently alive member of the scumteam, not just a member of the scumteam, and Aureal's role required like 8 pages to get all of the details on.