Mini Normal 2314 - The Mafia Have a Cop [END]

[JacksonVirgo]

Unless that question was not relating to Drews meta

[jjh927]

It's more that trying to convince Flavor Leaf that Una is scum in this situation achieves literally nothing and is therefore an action driven by pure optimism and not scum motivated

[Hu Tao]

Hu Taoooooo, and Dreew are scuuuummm..
Morning tooo, most everyoneeeeee

I think you're town but its worrying your reads aren't evolving. Besides gut from the beginnings of the game, why am i scum?

[jjh927]

See, that kind of question is why I'm really liking Hu Tao here

[Hu Tao]

thinking back, maybe flavour wouldn’t be so on the nose with a signal,, the lack of thought/backtrack was clumsy xD can see it as a classic fl move done thoughtlessly,, lean town
but this is still scummy

I'm gonna say Hu Tao reacted on instinct in a way that is more likely to come from town
Drew looks town off of it to me for similar reasons
Una is putting in some effort but not getting anything off of it yet
Gera looks like someone who will be very easy for me to place later despite not giving substantial content

i.e: sounds like a whole lot of saying something to look like something even though it points out nothing about no one in particular xD
marcistar has Hu Tao vibes from last game) iykyk, although more in your face so a little unsure how much is personality
remember disliking before, its still bothering me now
can go there, jv’s caught on too,, that was a good post
liking jv, bulge, off the top of my head

still continuing to read ty ty

After last game, if nono scumreads someone hard, I'm going to have to look into the person they scumread.

[Hu Tao]

@Jackson - if you'd humor me for a moment - if you were told that there's one scum in Drew/Hu Tao guaranteed, which would you lean on being scum based on this early game?

I think Hu Tao is actually a difficult person for me to read as I always end up TRing them (small sample size) but I would say Drew here nonetheless. Not sure why you're asking this, nor why you're asking me but there you go.

I'm always town. Trust

[jjh927]

Do you want to bounce some ideas then? I think Nono is 100% town here on the grounds that they have taken a very unique stance within the gamestate, despite ultimately being wrong. This was my canned answer to the question I asked geraintm

[Hu Tao]

2 HOURS AND A HALF TO PUT BLEACH IN

GURL I WAS FEELING SO SICK IDK HOW PPL DO THIS

If Alisae wasn't the mod I would swear you were an Alisae alt

[Hu Tao]

@Jackson - if you'd humor me for a moment - if you were told that there's one scum in Drew/Hu Tao guaranteed, which would you lean on being scum based on this early game?

I think Hu Tao is actually a difficult person for me to read as I always end up TRing them (small sample size) but I would say Drew here nonetheless. Not sure why you're asking this, nor why you're asking me but there you go.

i got you. Hu Tao is town here.

I get pinged so hard at times when Hu tao is scum.

Are you scum here? This is the opposite of what you said before when you were town

[Hu Tao]

Hu Tao pulled a heist in a recent game, and claimed a guilty on Nono who had a guilty on them before Nono claimed it, and we misfaded Nono. I even spent the day before that saying Hu Tao was obv scum, and still believed it.

They a dangerous scum player but they have a tone difference that peaks out when they're scum.

Okay, I suppose if that is a reason for a change possibly

[jjh927]

Ah right you're doing a proper catchup. Sure

When you get here, the slots I particularly want to discuss are Marci and The Bulge

[marcistar]

criminal offensive side eye

[Hu Tao]

Do you want to bounce some ideas then? I think Nono is 100% town here on the grounds that they have taken a very unique stance within the gamestate, despite ultimately being wrong. This was my canned answer to the question I asked geraintm

Can you send me a scum game of yours?

[Hu Tao]

Ah right you're doing a proper catchup. Sure

When you get here, the slots I particularly want to discuss are Marci and The Bulge

Marci seems natural but I'm not sure if this is how they can act as scum too.

Has The Bulge posted more than like 5 times?

[jjh927]

Unfortunately you're gonna have to make do with these because none of them are perfect for meta
This would have been one if I hadn't been force replaced due to mod error
This is where I replaced into a completely doomed mafia slot in team mafia for a day phase
I believe this is my most recent full scumgame but it's from 2 years ago

If you'd like some towngames for reference, I did dig up my last 10 towngames (going back 3 years to the day, it looks like) in case I needed to prove to geraintm that accurate day 1 reads exist

Spoiler:

Datisi's University - Number 1 scumread was scum!Wheme, but didn't get the lim day 1. Notably had 3 out of 4 scum in the 4 names in my scumreads. Died n1
Datisi's Cafe - Number 1 scumread was scum!Malakittens. Was fine with the scum!Ircher elim that happened day 1 though as well.
GNG's upick - Number 1 scumread was scum!Gypyx. Lim didn't happen due to a dumb mechanical plan I said wouldn't work, that didn't work.
Superfight mafiaCaught scum day 1. Mafia tried to kill me N1 but due to the mechanics could not
Anything uPickCaught not 1 but 2 scum due to a big old TMI that nobody else believed until we limmed one of them on day 2.
Townstumps mafiaCaught scum day 1. Notably off wagon at eod because I was trying to find more.
Krazy's animal upickCaught scum day 1
Pokemon battlesCaught scum day 1
Cards of destiny mafiaCaught scum day 1
Mystery box of silver 10Did not catch scum day 1. Notably, day 1 lasted 4 and a half days and based on reading my iso I don't think I was caught up

[jjh927]

Ah right you're doing a proper catchup. Sure

When you get here, the slots I particularly want to discuss are Marci and The Bulge

Marci seems natural but I'm not sure if this is how they can act as scum too.

Has The Bulge posted more than like 5 times?

The thing I'm thinking about with Marci is that she seems to be posting a lot more to appeal to people than to read them, but it's not exclusively so, nor is it damning. Just what's keeping me up at night.

The Bulge did a block of posts and I don't like them at all. I think the focus on JV was gamestate driven

[marcistar]

Ah right you're doing a proper catchup. Sure

When you get here, the slots I particularly want to discuss are Marci and The Bulge

Marci seems natural but I'm not sure if this is how they can act as scum too.

Has The Bulge posted more than like 5 times?

The thing I'm thinking about with Marci is that she seems to be posting a lot more to appeal to people than to read them, but it's not exclusively so, nor is it damning. Just what's keeping me up at night.

The Bulge did a block of posts and I don't like them at all. I think the focus on JV was gamestate driven

do u remember who my votes on rn i dont even remember

[Flavor Leaf]

@Jackson - if you'd humor me for a moment - if you were told that there's one scum in Drew/Hu Tao guaranteed, which would you lean on being scum based on this early game?

I think Hu Tao is actually a difficult person for me to read as I always end up TRing them (small sample size) but I would say Drew here nonetheless. Not sure why you're asking this, nor why you're asking me but there you go.

i got you. Hu Tao is town here.

I get pinged so hard at times when Hu tao is scum.

Are you scum here? This is the opposite of what you said before when you were town

The less consistent i am the more likely it is i am town to be fair

[Flavor Leaf]

@Jackson - if you'd humor me for a moment - if you were told that there's one scum in Drew/Hu Tao guaranteed, which would you lean on being scum based on this early game?

I think Hu Tao is actually a difficult person for me to read as I always end up TRing them (small sample size) but I would say Drew here nonetheless. Not sure why you're asking this, nor why you're asking me but there you go.

i got you. Hu Tao is town here.

I get pinged so hard at times when Hu tao is scum.

Are you scum here? This is the opposite of what you said before when you were town

Also, this is not true.

I feel I’ve said you pinged me when you were scum multiple times.

The only time it was different was in Blood Over Utopia, and you corrected me that game when you said I mostly town read you for your predecessor, which is true, I town read your slot there because of Roden

[Flavor Leaf]

But I also have something very specific that you do as scum, Hu Tao, and it’s happened multiple times.

Not entirely ready to divulge what that is, but if I see it, I’ll be able to case you all around.

Some things are worth keeping at the chest, and I won’t ever use that pure reason as a main reason you’d be scum.

I think you are town here, more similar to that one game where I was Miller rather than scum.

[Flavor Leaf]

I think Xergarus is coasting scum

[Flavor Leaf]

JV I am not town reading, but that could make them town.


I think scum team is good at having townie vibes this game based on how I’m reading every slot in the game.

[jjh927]

I think Xergarus is coasting scum

This seems reasonably likely given they were very late to the party on the miller thing. It kind of read like scum that wasn't very accurately informed of the gamestate

[Doctor Drew]

2 HOURS AND A HALF TO PUT BLEACH IN

GURL I WAS FEELING SO SICK IDK HOW PPL DO THIS

If Alisae wasn't the mod I would swear you were an Alisae alt

Ali is much more compared in their chaos haha.

I really strongly am town reading Flavor and JJh now, the paranoia is basically gone. JJh reminds me of Datisi's University(funny I remember the only time I saw you as scum was like 4 years in Big 4 Mafia, also the only time I have won as a third party lol.....also think Flavor told me he co modded that game ironically).

Hu always scares me, but I will trust Flavor for now that they are playing as town.

Marci I have I have no fucking clue lol.

Gamma is Gamma I guess? Not really scummy or townie, so whatevs.

Still gonna say Una is scum.

Pre Edit: Oh forgot about Xeg, I could switch back to them as well.

I think I need to iso JV as well

[Doctor Drew]

2 HOURS AND A HALF TO PUT BLEACH IN

GURL I WAS FEELING SO SICK IDK HOW PPL DO THIS

If Alisae wasn't the mod I would swear you were an Alisae alt

Ali is much more compared in their chaos haha.

I really strongly am town reading Flavor and JJh now, the paranoia is basically gone. JJh reminds me of Datisi's University(funny I remember the only time I saw you as scum was like 4 years in Big 4 Mafia, also the only time I have won as a third party lol.....also think Flavor told me he co modded that game ironically).

Hu always scares me, but I will trust Flavor for now that they are playing as town.

Marci I have I have no fucking clue lol.

Gamma is Gamma I guess? Not really scummy or townie, so whatevs.

Still gonna say Una is scum.

Pre Edit: Oh forgot about Xeg, I could switch back to them as well.

I think I need to iso JV as well

*Composed not compared, in regards to Ali lol