Open 891: STDBINSBICACOT (Game Over)

[davesaz]

I think Alisae has too many TRs for only 20 pages, and some of them might be people I'd say have too little content to read at all.

town but wtf kind of take is this???????

I had to go back and re-read your list. Drew for example, IMO hasn't really said anything that's AI.

[Alisae]

I think Alisae has too many TRs for only 20 pages, and some of them might be people I'd say have too little content to read at all.

town but wtf kind of take is this???????

I had to go back and re-read your list. Drew for example, IMO hasn't really said anything that's AI.

That is your opinion

[davesaz]

did you know that finding villagers is easier than finding mafia?

I find lean towns easier than lean scum, but true townreads are extremely hard for me.

[Alisae]

Dave bro do u wanna say ur shaddowez stance or whaaaaaaat

[Roden]

I don't see Roden asking for examples of him freezing in another game like his last post suggests. I don't need examples of him freezing in the past to seee he's freezing here. There's no interaction w anyone else's posts.

"I don't need to prove that my accusations hold water"

Lmaoooo

[Roden]

I think Alisae has too many TRs for only 20 pages, and some of them might be people I'd say have too little content to read at all.

town but wtf kind of take is this???????

I had to go back and re-read your list. Drew for example, IMO hasn't really said anything that's AI.

That is your opinion

What do you find AI about Drew? A lot of his posts feel dry to me.

[davesaz]

Dave bro do u wanna say ur shaddowez stance or whaaaaaaat

I have a soft spot for "missing while RL" situations which might be acting as a block on properly reading what is posted.
Would have to review it to see.

[gob]

whats going on people

[davesaz]

Here are the thoughts I had last night when looking through Shadow's iso

27 could be a signal to the scum team if he's the traitor and they didn't choose to recruit him

185 doesn't go anywhere and doesn't even feel like a real thought

I don't really like how he called my 124 shade in 190. Asking if I think Titus is scummy for anything specific feels like a busywork thought considering later on he claims he scumreads her for certain things she was doing around this time, which indicates to me that he should have already been at least slightly suspicious of her when he wrote this. He didn't seem too interested in my response either. Unrelatedly, his comment to gob here feels hedgy wrt Roden

191 and 195 feel sorta like an attempt to shade the claimed Cop to position himself to eventually vote there if need be

237 feels a little pedantic and doesn't go anywhere, and I think it's weird how shadow doesn't offer any thought about Crescent's alignment despite thinking she tried to make a case out of something that didn't happen

279 is super hedgy

436 I talked about last night but I think his posturing around Alisae is slimy and then the Titus stance feels very convenient considering she got two votes right before this post

I don't like how Dunn responded to 443 but Shadow didn't seem interested in the response. This is pretty common, shadow just asking questions to ask them. It just seems like he's trying to look like he's solving

449 is a misinterpretation of what Gob said but it reads as being self-conscious about being voted for

I don't really see it, at various points. The reasons given in #27, #191, #195 are poor. I will almost never consider a post like #27 to be AI. When I see someone claim something like Cop right away for no reason, it's almost always a VT dicking around, or scum dicking around. I don't see being willing to probe his way being scum-slanted. #237 could have been stronger, but unlike #231, it was a response to a part of the post that actually mattered. Immediately questioning Dunn for an out of nowhere Titus vote immediately after saying Titus looks scummy is a decent look, and was quickly followed by questioning Gob for a reason for voting him. #449 isn't bad at all. Gob has never given a legitimate reason for voting Shadow, and had sat there since 336. Shadow asking him to give an actual reason feels like a real question instead of a subconscious outburst.

#436 is the post here that sits in my "do not like" pile. The post really doesn't exist but to say "I'm busy", and to lay possible groundwork for voting off an inactive.

I agree he feels hedgy and noncommittal, but I disagree with almost every other point you made. Reading his ISO does not give me a strong read on him in either direction.

I think I'm pretty much in between Black and Crescent on these points, on average. If I filter out "shaddow isn't

really

here" thinking from those posts, the parts that resonate as possible scum are asking questions to look like asking but apparently not caring what the answers are (the Dunnstral question), and selectively commenting on some things while paying little attention to other very similar things happening at almost the same time (such as difference in approach to Titus and Alisae, especially when he's claiming to be busy himself).

[davesaz]

whats going on people

You said Shaddow is possible scum. Are you ever going to say why?

[davesaz]

<snip>

Not liking Roden here.

I wasn't either until this.....Roden's interactions with pisskop felt strange, but not forced. As I was reading my initial thought was "I don't like this", then it gets kinda dropped and gamestate changed. He also disappeared, but I did today too so I have not stones to throw.
<snip>

Why does gob's very brief post change your thought on Roden?

[gob]

whats going on people

You said Shaddow is possible scum. Are you ever going to say why?

Already did.

[gob]

<snip>

Not liking Roden here.

I wasn't either until this.....Roden's interactions with pisskop felt strange, but not forced. As I was reading my initial thought was "I don't like this", then it gets kinda dropped and gamestate changed. He also disappeared, but I did today too so I have not stones to throw.
<snip>

Why does gob's very brief post change your thought on Roden?

Yea that is a little odd lol.

[davesaz]

whats going on people

You said Shaddow is possible scum. Are you ever going to say why?

Already did.

I'm not seeing anything I'd interpret as a why. Care to point it out?
I have a very hard time understanding you, and that makes you very hard for me to read. If you're town it's rather important for you that I can TR you.

[Alisae]

I think Alisae has too many TRs for only 20 pages, and some of them might be people I'd say have too little content to read at all.

town but wtf kind of take is this???????

I had to go back and re-read your list. Drew for example, IMO hasn't really said anything that's AI.

That is your opinion

What do you find AI about Drew? A lot of his posts feel dry to me.

ok

[Alisae]

Dave bro do u wanna say ur shaddowez stance or whaaaaaaat

I have a soft spot for "missing while RL" situations which might be acting as a block on properly reading what is posted.
Would have to review it to see.

And this stops u from having a read there, how?

[davesaz]

Dave bro do u wanna say ur shaddowez stance or whaaaaaaat

I have a soft spot for "missing while RL" situations which might be acting as a block on properly reading what is posted.
Would have to review it to see.

And this stops u from having a read there, how?

I don't think what I said was that hard to understand. I had been discounting / ignoring the slot because that's what I do when it seems someone is absent for RL reasons. I ignored your slot too, until you showed up.

That said, read my next post after the one you quoted. I said I would re-read shaddow taking off the filter.

[davesaz]

I've been treating Roden the same way btw.

[Doctor Drew]

I think Alisae has too many TRs for only 20 pages, and some of them might be people I'd say have too little content to read at all.

town but wtf kind of take is this???????

I had to go back and re-read your list. Drew for example, IMO hasn't really said anything that's AI.

That just simply isn't true, I haven't said too much here but I have made it clear what my alignment is.

[Doctor Drew]

<snip>

Not liking Roden here.

I wasn't either until this.....Roden's interactions with pisskop felt strange, but not forced. As I was reading my initial thought was "I don't like this", then it gets kinda dropped and gamestate changed. He also disappeared, but I did today too so I have not stones to throw.
<snip>

Why does gob's very brief post change your thought on Roden?

Yea that is a little odd lol.

First thing I agree with Gob about lol

[Alisae]

Drew can u vote shaddowez

[Doctor Drew]

Drew can u vote shaddowez

I literally cannot remember a single post by them.

Let me check out the War and Peace that is their iso.

[Alisae]

Drew can u vote shaddowez

I literally cannot remember a single post by them.

Let me check out the War and Peace that is their iso.

Do you HAVE to ISO them?

[Doctor Drew]

I will say, not much jumps out at me expect scum reading Titus......and then getting upset that others are scum reading her?

Argh, does this mean Titus is scum here potentially with Shadow?

Pre Edit: As fun as it is to random vote someone, I had to refresh my memory a bit.

VOTE: Shadow

[Alisae]

wow i just started playing TODAY and I already got a wagon going when people were struggling to get a wagon going
incredible