In post 422, ActionDan wrote:
I just want you to know FL, that I absolutely caught that crumb, signaling town investigative.
Good crumb though. Not that I had much doubt but this further means naerys less lilely to be scum eliminating them as killer / vanillaizer.
I agree with your list minus Kitty / Celebloki. There are things in Kitty's response that continue to be objectively untrue, for example their disposition on looker. I can classify their other opinions re: contributions/ good and bad vibes as subjective opinions but it isn't quite fitting into place just yet.
I was of the opinion that drew was nominally towny. I'll revisit.
Yeah, I wouldnt have claimed, but I wanted to explain my progression overall this game. I think there's a chance Kitty could have done this as scum, but it was enough for me to be okay changing wagons. Wasn't ready for day to end yet.
Noting your Drew read, though. Drew and I get in paranoia feuds a decent amount, so it's possible.
In post 422, ActionDan wrote:
I just want you to know FL, that I absolutely caught that crumb, signaling town investigative.
Good crumb though. Not that I had much doubt but this further means naerys less lilely to be scum eliminating them as killer / vanillaizer.
I agree with your list minus Kitty / Celebloki. There are things in Kitty's response that continue to be objectively untrue, for example their disposition on looker. I can classify their other opinions re: contributions/ good and bad vibes as subjective opinions but it isn't quite fitting into place just yet.
I was of the opinion that drew was nominally towny. I'll revisit.
Yeah, I wouldnt have claimed, but I wanted to explain my progression overall this game. I think there's a chance Kitty could have done this as scum, but it was enough for me to be okay changing wagons. Wasn't ready for day to end yet.
Noting your Drew read, though. Drew and I get in paranoia feuds a decent amount, so it's possible.
It's not clear to me what "this" Is that would have been hard to fake.
I'm not tunneled on Kitty being super scummy but I continue to dislike their reads and general slot and think it's pretty dangerous to write them off based on comments/interactions from the wagon.
In post 417, Flavor Leaf wrote:
the fact im using bad logic and reasoning instead of good logic for a lot of my earlier reads is not scumFlavor. lol
you saying i aint shown townie is cap
I never said that
I said you show townie eventually, just haven't seen it yet.
Maybe you think you have, and maybe you actually have, but I haven't seen what I eventually do see yet.
i think whatever tell you got back then isn't actually a townie tell and is just something i happened to do as town once or twice.
cuz you've said that line before when I was town.
I have, at the very least, said to Alianna in our hydra chat that sorting you on D1 is a fools game since you will show your town self if you are town(then called you town right after that lol).
Also I definitely said that you aren't that hard to read and you will expose yourself as town in previous games.
'dREW DID IT BETTER' - T-Bone
'doctor drew our hero' - Shiki
'I love playing with him, he's got an amazing presence to him that just feels like the game is lacking something when he's not there' - JacksonVirgo
In post 417, Flavor Leaf wrote:
the fact im using bad logic and reasoning instead of good logic for a lot of my earlier reads is not scumFlavor. lol
you saying i aint shown townie is cap
I never said that
I said you show townie eventually, just haven't seen it yet.
Maybe you think you have, and maybe you actually have, but I haven't seen what I eventually do see yet.
i think whatever tell you got back then isn't actually a townie tell and is just something i happened to do as town once or twice.
cuz you've said that line before when I was town.
I have, at the very least, said to Alianna in our hydra chat that sorting you on D1 is a fools game since you will show your town self if you are town(then called you town right after that lol).
Also I definitely said that you aren't that hard to read and you will expose yourself as town in previous games.
Obviously in regards to Alianna and our hydra, was not this game. Was Blood over Utopia.
'dREW DID IT BETTER' - T-Bone
'doctor drew our hero' - Shiki
'I love playing with him, he's got an amazing presence to him that just feels like the game is lacking something when he's not there' - JacksonVirgo
In post 373, Vanderscamp wrote:
I don't understand why we're moving from the kitty wagon, I don't find anything they've said recently towny.
I also think Naerys' posts today are very bad.
If we're moving wagons I would rather go there.
I think it’s a mix of AtE/meta, where I personally haven’t ever seen Kitty fight like that to stay alive, as either alignment.
When they’re caught, and pressured that hard, they normally come in awkward and still go down, where here, I think they made a connection to some people, and AtE was in fact pretty strong.
But I understand why some wouldn’t buy it, it just felt like others needed more to end up limming Kitty, and if Kitty is scum, they did enough to avoid getting the required votes on them.
I will say, though, if Kitty is town, scum moving off of Kitty after Kitty claimed VT is highly likely.
When i open this game, and starting read, i immediatly close it because i starting strongly consider self last townie alive and others are just jesters.
In post 346, KittyTacky wrote:
"He's putting in more effort so he must be scum because he puts in more effort as scum" is a fallacious 'tell'. Maybe I'm taking this game more seriously.
Is it fallacious or just annoying from your perspective?
Yes it's fallacious. What if I decide I am putting in more effort as town?
When i open this game, and starting read, i immediatly close it because i starting strongly consider self last townie alive and others are just jesters.
In post 427, Vanderscamp wrote:
Don't know, not especially, but it's a genuine question.
I dislike Gamma's reads and don't think they've been overtly towny.
Feels kinda weird this is only coming up now when Drew has said he townreads and wants to sheep me from daystart
<Embrace The Void>
“A flipped coin doesn't always land heads or tails. Sometimes it may never land at all...”
I trust you, but I don't think you understand why I trust you.
'dREW DID IT BETTER' - T-Bone
'doctor drew our hero' - Shiki
'I love playing with him, he's got an amazing presence to him that just feels like the game is lacking something when he's not there' - JacksonVirgo
In post 346, KittyTacky wrote:
"He's putting in more effort so he must be scum because he puts in more effort as scum" is a fallacious 'tell'. Maybe I'm taking this game more seriously.
Is it fallacious or just annoying from your perspective?
Yes it's fallacious. What if I decide I am putting in more effort as town?
Than putting in more effort as scum would not be your meta.
Fallacy doesn't mean anything that could possibly be wrong.
In post 429, Vanderscamp wrote:
VOTE: Roden for what I feel might have been TMI about ATE
Walk me through this one
When you made post #332 I did not agree with you that anything Kitty said was town-indicative.
What Kitty said wasn't overly scummy or anything but it was probably one of the least town-indicative ATEs I've ever seen and I think you got a Kitty town read too easily.
In post 427, Vanderscamp wrote:
Don't know, not especially, but it's a genuine question.
I dislike Gamma's reads and don't think they've been overtly towny.
Feels kinda weird this is only coming up now when Drew has said he townreads and wants to sheep me from daystart
In post 429, Vanderscamp wrote:
VOTE: Roden for what I feel might have been TMI about ATE
Walk me through this one
When you made post #332 I did not agree with you that anything Kitty said was town-indicative.
What Kitty said wasn't overly scummy or anything but it was probably one of the least town-indicative ATEs I've ever seen and I think you got a Kitty town read too easily.
If the AtE is that bad and ineffective then why do you think I jump off the wagon as scum
