Mafia Reunion | Postgame

[Radical Rat]

There's so many to choose from

Ugh decisions are hard

Assign a game to each real name in the set up, whoever gets voted out first is the decided game

How would one know the real names?

In theory a flip would show

Ya, but Roden kinda said that in a way that they know the real names

This isn't the first time the list of known names was mentioned. Why didn't you have anything to say about this before?

[Radical Rat]

I can also confirm that conversions were not mentioned in the signup thread at first, though the Enthusiasts being colored in Cult Purple kinda gave it away for me.

[Flavor Leaf]

I probably wouldn’t have signed up for a cult game if i knew

[Flavor Leaf]

Alright

i am a frog in wolf's clothing

Damn this is a cult-like game. Idk how to go about going forward, people will just get converted who i town read.

I’m an undercover journalist. Scum team give ‘REAL NAMES’ to convert.

I was trying to bait to see who knew about it early.

[Doctor Drew]

There's so many to choose from

Ugh decisions are hard

Assign a game to each real name in the set up, whoever gets voted out first is the decided game

How would one know the real names?

In theory a flip would show

Ya, but Roden kinda said that in a way that they know the real names

This isn't the first time the list of known names was mentioned. Why didn't you have anything to say about this before?

As I just stated I didn't know the names were public knowledge until this point

[Flavor Leaf]

Target*

I thought names would be randomized with role, but it looks like they’re entirely separate.

I have another part of my role, but it’s not entirely useful at the present. Maybe it’ll have use, but we’ll see

[Theta Alpine]

i am
confused as to why we are already having a claim out but okay then

that is about what i suspected as soon as i noticed we were in a cult game though

[Flavor Leaf]

i am
confused as to why we are already having a claim out but okay then

that is about what i suspected as soon as i noticed we were in a cult game though

I claim early every game basically

[Radical Rat]

There's so many to choose from

Ugh decisions are hard

Assign a game to each real name in the set up, whoever gets voted out first is the decided game

How would one know the real names?

In theory a flip would show

Ya, but Roden kinda said that in a way that they know the real names

This isn't the first time the list of known names was mentioned. Why didn't you have anything to say about this before?

As I just stated I didn't know the names were public knowledge until this point

Right, but someone else already implied knowing and you didn't care is my point. I don't remember who it was, but it was while we were discussing massclaiming names

[Theta Alpine]

actually thinking about it

informed modifier best play is to out early probably
especially if you do not have a useful role otherwise

[Flavor Leaf]

actually thinking about it

informed modifier best play is to out early probably
especially if you do not have a useful role otherwise

I also recall a player asking for a mass name claim earlier.

[Theta Alpine]

yes
but would scum actually be so bold as to straight up ask for a mass name claim

[Flavor Leaf]

yes
but would scum actually be so bold as to straight up ask for a mass name claim

Yeah, that was my thinking. It was bold, but like if they didn’t think about a possible informed?

I can see it both ways.

[Doctor Drew]

There's so many to choose from

Ugh decisions are hard

Assign a game to each real name in the set up, whoever gets voted out first is the decided game

How would one know the real names?

In theory a flip would show

Ya, but Roden kinda said that in a way that they know the real names

This isn't the first time the list of known names was mentioned. Why didn't you have anything to say about this before?

As I just stated I didn't know the names were public knowledge until this point

Right, but someone else already implied knowing and you didn't care is my point. I don't remember who it was, but it was while we were discussing massclaiming names

Rat wanted people to claim Names

I didn't know names were in the setup post

Who implied knowing?

[Doctor Drew]

There's so many to choose from

Ugh decisions are hard

Assign a game to each real name in the set up, whoever gets voted out first is the decided game

How would one know the real names?

In theory a flip would show

Ya, but Roden kinda said that in a way that they know the real names

This isn't the first time the list of known names was mentioned. Why didn't you have anything to say about this before?

As I just stated I didn't know the names were public knowledge until this point

Right, but someone else already implied knowing and you didn't care is my point. I don't remember who it was, but it was while we were discussing massclaiming names

Rat wanted people to claim Names

I didn't know names were in the setup post

Who implied knowing?

Oh you are Rat lol

But the question still is vaild

[Flavor Leaf]

Thoughts on massclaiming names?

I think it'd be a good idea to lock people into name claims early, prevent shenanigans on that front.

Nah nah.

And out of RVS we go.

We don't know what the names do per se, this is role phishing.

Pre Edit: Titus knows the score

Why’d you talk about this if you didn’t know what names were?

[Radical Rat]

and have a reasonable certainty of the accuracy of the claims due to having an exact list of them, I don't see a need to rush to do it.

This one

[Doctor Drew]

Thoughts on massclaiming names?

I think it'd be a good idea to lock people into name claims early, prevent shenanigans on that front.

Nah nah.

And out of RVS we go.

We don't know what the names do per se, this is role phishing.

Pre Edit: Titus knows the score

Why’d you talk about this if you didn’t know what names were?

I know my name and I know we all have a name.

I did not know know ALL names were public knowledge as I said

[Flavor Leaf]

It’s probs NAI, Drew, but i think people can be in the right if they think you sketch here.

[Doctor Drew]

It’s probs NAI, Drew, but i think people can be in the right if they think you sketch here.

Do you think I am sketch?

[Radical Rat]

Alright

i am a frog in wolf's clothing

Damn this is a cult-like game. Idk how to go about going forward, people will just get converted who i town read.

I’m an undercover journalist. Scum team give ‘REAL NAMES’ to convert.

I was trying to bait to see who knew about it early.

Given this information...

Theta was the first to bring this up as a possibility, though honestly I believe the train of thought kinda way she got there, and it was a thought I'd had as well, so I don't want to shade her for it.

There WAS however a certain bias of mine that got confirmation though...

[Flavor Leaf]

Titus kinda scummy

[Flavor Leaf]

VOTE: Titus

[Radical Rat]

Essentially, what I believe massclaiming offers is everyone knowing who they're targeting instead of having to guess if theirs is a role that targets flavor names. Whether this is a net benefit to Town or to Scum depends on the exact roles in play, which we do not know, nor should we be trying to speculate on so early.

However, it is my belief that the chance is worth taking to enforce consistency and accountability.

I have a strong suspicion that the cult can use names to convert. You're nullifying town's advantage by massclaiming so nah.

VOTE: Rat

This reads to me as though Kitty is softing role information. Yet it would be strange if we had multiple roles giving the same information as Town.

So... 50/50 shot between Kitty and Flavor, and I was already suspicious of Kitty

[Theta Alpine]

i mean

it was kinda obvious to me seeing both conversions and real names and thinking

hmm if i was a game designer and holding cult in my hand and a real names mechanic in the other and thinking how to balance cult