Eminence in Shadow: Season 1 [Game Over]

[Gamma Emerald]

I think koba’s point holds water, I was also in the townstumps game so I have at least a vague memory of what they’re talking about

[PenguinPower]

[Big Chungus Gaming]

I think koba’s point holds water, I was also in the townstumps game so I have at least a vague memory of what they’re talking about

Them being afk was a big part of helping Nancy and I slide by in lylo bc iirc they were one of the stumps

[T3]

VOTE: T3
how about we just kill this, I feel like he's reacting to all the wrong things and in all the wrong ways

Such as

[Gamma Emerald]

Sakura is an IC this game btw

Why

Stuff like this where you are approaching players who aren’t playing with full consideration like you expect to get something from them

[Luka]

idont like either top wagon

[T3]

Ok here's another attempt

I think it's +town when someone pulls up something from hundreds of posts ago that has nothing to do with the current topic. It shows organic thought

Maybe
I just don’t really care for how he engaged with players that I feel like weren’t acting in good faith (Luka and Alisae), feels like he was doing a Don Quixote, which I think is +scum because it’s a way of looking productive but you’re just throwing your efforts at a solid object

I’m a bit annoyed at Alisae in particular

Idc about Luka I was just trying to push him but didn’t get an AI response

[T3]

VOTE: Peng

[T3]

Ok here's another attempt

I think it's +town when someone pulls up something from hundreds of posts ago that has nothing to do with the current topic. It shows organic thought

Maybe
I just don’t really care for how he engaged with players that I feel like weren’t acting in good faith (Luka and Alisae), feels like he was doing a Don Quixote, which I think is +scum because it’s a way of looking productive but you’re just throwing your efforts at a solid object

I’m a bit annoyed at Alisae in particular

Idc about Luka I was just trying to push him but didn’t get an AI response

Also have I not been doing other stuff too??

[T3]

VOTE: Alisae

I have no real read on Peng or jjh and I think that limming Alisae is strictly better for town’s EV

[Firebringer]

Having invaded the base that his sister was held at. The seven shadows made quick work of the dastardly cultist. Our hero however managed to...get lost on his way. Somehow he still managed to run into one of the cultist and kill him and save his sister.

Day 1 - Our Story Begins
Vote Count 1.19

jjh927 [6][E-3] - Alisae, Cephrir, Klick, Whemestar, Save The Dragons, Penguinpower,
Dunnstral [3][E-6] - PookytheMagicalBear, Luka, Sakura Hana,
Alisae [3][E-6] - SirCakez, KawaiiKame, T3,
PenguinPower [2][E-7]- Dunnstral, Gamma Emerald,
Gamma Emerald [2][E-7] - ssbm_Kyouko, Big Chungus Gaming,



Lurking in Shadows (Not Voting - 1) : jjh927,

With 17 Alive, It Takes 9 to Eliminate.
Deadline is (expired on 2024-01-07 15:45:00)

Mod Note: jjh927 has been prodded

[jjh927]

Okay, second prod is a bit of a reality check
I'm honestly not sure if that's happened to me before but yeah, real life has been a lot busier over christmas

Need to catch up from where I was and properly determine my scumpile

[jjh927]

Huh that's a helpful votecount

[Big Chungus Gaming]

VOTE: PP

[T3]

On one hand we have a lurker who may or may not contribute on later days and an easily sortable good player who is lurking for unknown reasons

On the other hand we have a player with poorly thought out reads and who is unwilling to compromise whose future contributions will invariably disrupt the gamestate and make it difficult to solve

[T3]

Someone please give me a good reason for not voting Alisae that isn’t “uh um good vibes”

[jjh927]

Oh, just to make the reasons known on my lurking it is 100% real life

If there's any meta questions my most recent game was an actual scumgame

[T3]

I dont think either of the reactions these two had to Alisae were commensurate with er posting, and Gamma's feels hollow, or fake, or forced, however you want to describe it.

I feel that from Cakez but not Gamma at all

[jjh927]

General takes here
I think the people making commentary on my meta are poorly informed
I really don't feel like town!Alisae votes me without a confident read
Without going back to look, I think Pooky is playing very similarly to gng upick and that's why I would consider him to be hard town here.
I don't think I have a second interesting enough read in isolation for Klick's request at the present time. 'Interesting' is the qualifier though. Tonight, when I am no longer phoneposting in response to an email ping, I'll make a proper readslist and Klick or anyone else can quiz me on something I guess.
Out of my wagon, I'm confident Klick and Wheme are town and a bit optimistic that STD is town and maybe actually readable, but I've had an eye on Cephrir for basically the whole phase, PP could easily be scum, and I've already mentioned Alisae
I'll put down a vote when I centre myself with a readlist

[jjh927]

I dont think either of the reactions these two had to Alisae were commensurate with er posting, and Gamma's feels hollow, or fake, or forced, however you want to describe it.

I feel that from Cakez but not Gamma at all

I think Gamma's posting appearing forced to some people is a known phenomenon as either alignment

[ssbm_Kyouko]

These are what I'm referring to with Gamma

Spoiler: the quotes

btw gun to head if competent players haven't TR'd Gamma yet then she probably is just a wolf.
I remember Gamma being like super easy to TR when she's town so.

I hate everything about this read
How about you don’t hide behind some third-rate BoP technobabble and actually give a real opinion?

what are you going to do
vote me

viewtopic.php?t=91760 here gamma was very easy to tr early

Shut the fuck up, you don’t get to claim you correctly TRed me in that game after your meltdown in reaction to being wagoned

what are you going to do
vote me

Maybe
Depends on how I feel at the end of this

cry about it

nothing u say is going to make me actually give a fuck to play, I play on my own time, sorry.

I'm too town for elim and I don't even have to try hard to do it

VOTE: alisae
this feels like a possible scum play and I just fucking hate your guts rn so you exiting the game is an improvement

I'm too town for elim and I don't even have to try hard to do it

fucking bet

I have minimal tolerance for players approaching me in bad faith

Hate is a strong word

your point being? Alisae’s read on me is absolutely trash-tier, he knows it, and is avoiding addressing the real issues by stating “I play on my own time”.
You even said your vote on me would be removed when Alisae said to, so you are the exact reason why that garbage needs to be called out.

Maybe the reason I lack conviction is I have seen Alisae openly play in bad faith so I see getting rid of em as a “cleaning up” measure. Have you tried considering that?

I'll think about this - as I recall there was a town game of yours I read in that recent meta dive where Alisae was the subject of your ire

[Klick]

idont like either top wagon

Who we voting then coach

[Klick]

UNVOTE:

jjh don't push yourself to effort harder than you actually can
What you just posted as general reads was fine and helpful

[Klick]

On one hand we have a lurker who may or may not contribute on later days and an easily sortable good player who is lurking for unknown reasons

On the other hand we have a player with poorly thought out reads and who is unwilling to compromise whose future contributions will invariably disrupt the gamestate and make it difficult to solve

Someone please give me a good reason for not voting Alisae that isn’t “uh um good vibes”

Town!Alisae is a large asset who will contribute more positively later on than you are giving credit for

That combined with said 'good vibes' makes me resistant to an Alisae push

[ssbm_Kyouko]

VOTE: Alisae

I have no real read on Peng or jjh and I think that limming Alisae is strictly better for town’s EV

I expect em to to be more beneficial as town than e would be hard to catch as scum