Mafia Reunion | Postgame

[Maestro]

Cakez doing exactly what I said he would do if he were converted is, not particularly surprising

if people want to do a Cakez run we could do it tomorrow or if Dan flips red but not before; I have reasonz for this thx

[Maestro]

oh for fk's sake I keep getting pagetops I do not want

ALSO, I obviously mean magenta bc nobody's technically flipping red? y'all knew what I meant rite

[Maestro]

Two of Emerson, Blair and Nova can be trusted.

My names are Blair, Dakota and Nova

just combining both of these btw

[Roden]

Cakez doing exactly what I said he would do if he were converted is, not particularly surprising

if people want to do a Cakez run we could do it tomorrow or if Dan flips red but not before; I have reasonz for this thx

Just want to point out that there is no tomorrow if town gets mis-elim'd again and scum have three successful conversions.

[Maestro]

uh no? unless my math is wrong

[Maestro]

uh

@MOD: I think the "remaining players" in OP might be messed up? did Gamma actually replace Celeb? I know we're still waiting on a Gamma replace, or I guess I thought we were...

I'm very confused now & would like to be held tightly and told everything will be alright

[Roden]

but yeah I think Drew is more town than you by far, if thats' what yuou mean? should be obvious

what does chainsaw mean again? been aqwhile since igaf about Maf terms

Spoiler: From the wiki

The general form of this tell is "a player who defends another player by attacking the other player's attacker is very probably scum".

The key to identifying this tell is intent - it is possible to confuse Chainsaw Defense with a player who simply finds the attacker scummy and has no intent of defense. In general, you can be reasonably sure that this tell is involved if a) the player supposedly using Chainsaw Defense has not previously been especially critical of the player he is now attacking, and b) the player supposedly using Chainsaw Defense seems to find the player he is supposedly defending at least reasonably pro-town.

[Maestro]

Roden LMAO I have not loved your play all game so (a) does not apply to me, and (b) is a very silly reason to call somebody scum independent of (a) but nice try, keep firin' off into the dark there, bruhther, bound to hit shit eventually

[Roden]

uh no? unless my math is wrong

We're at 12 players, Day 3

3 scum still live, and have had two chances to recruit

Worst case scenario, 5 scum (3 group, 2 converts) currently exist vs 7 town

Mis-elim + successful conversion means 6 scum vs 5 town on Day 4, which is a town loss

Another reason why we should've kept the 3p around, but no point crying over spilt milk at this point

[Maestro]

I didn't have much influence on the 3p, yeah, but ok ig that math checks out?

[Maestro]

[

ActionDan

,

Aureal

,

bianco

,

Drew

,

FLeaf

,

NotCeleb/Gamma

,

Roden

,

SirCakez

,

Theta

,

Thomith

,

Titus

]

IMO ppl in gross-throw-up-green + Theta, I'd love to hear more from, FLeaf I could hear less from

Cakez' vibe z still don't mesh w me here, idk why but maybe it's that theyv'e said "yup them calling me out like they have is fair-game, but I will say idk if it comes from Town or Scum and also I won't actualyl bump up my interaction/engagement in response, nah, that sounds boring"

[Roden]

Roden LMAO I have not loved your play all game so (a) does not apply to me, and (b) is a very silly reason to call somebody scum independent of (a) but nice try, keep firin' off into the dark there, bruhther, bound to hit shit eventually

I don't think we've even interacted up until now

If you were critical of me earlier then either it was in your head or I somehow missed it, in that case maybe you could point it out

[Maestro]

with the math in mind ig I still don't get why some are separating into piles, probCult vs. probConvert, idk why it matters if we have to hit 1 of

any

of those to get past today?

PE: I will also fuilly admit it could be for other reasons I can't get into bc site rules lol

[Flavor Leaf]

uh no? unless my math is wrong

We're at 12 players, Day 3

3 scum still live, and have had two chances to recruit

Worst case scenario, 5 scum (3 group, 2 converts) currently exist vs 7 town

Mis-elim + successful conversion means 6 scum vs 5 town on Day 4, which is a town loss

Another reason why we should've kept the 3p around, but no point crying over spilt milk at this point

It would be 6-6 i think

And that’s why i wanted to specifically fade 3rd party because it wasn’t an extra player out of the game and didn’t take out a town slot.

[Aureal]

If Thomith is on the level and still town then he can use the dance party to make sure it's not elo after a townflip today.

Also since it doesn't seem to have been made clear yet, from Leaf's info about addict/traitors I would assume they don't have communication with the main scum team and don't need to be removed in order for town to win, we just need to get the original scum. So yes, absolutely we should be focusing on getting them.

[Roden]

I didn't have much influence on the 3p, yeah, but ok ig that math checks out?

I wasn't sure if this needed to be said, but the worst case scenario is the biggest reason I'm even putting out my suspicions on who I think is converted. We need to hit group scum today and avoid converts, because even if we hit a convert we would still make zero progress since there's a good chance they just get replaced with another convert and Day 4 is still ELO. It's why I have no intention of voting Titus or Cakez.

[Flavor Leaf]

Hitting a convert is still better than hitting town, but going for group scum should be prioritized for sure.

[Flavor Leaf]

If you think Titus and Cakez are converts, who are they following?

[Roden]

I don't think they're making an effort to follow anyone.

[Roden]

Titus if converted is in anti-spew mode, and Cakez is tossing votes around with minimum reasoning.

[Theta Alpine]

oh wait traitors would not have access to factional abilities would they

so it literally becomes a game of finding the original cultists in order to win

[Roden]

VOTE: radical rat
sheeping Dan here

First Day 2 vote and the earliest he could've been converted. It looks like he's hiding behind a town!Dan.

VOTE: flavor leaf that quickhammer was trash IDC about role claims for now

This spews Leaf as not group scum imo.

Dan and Maestro's postings in the PT have felt very town. Hell even Maestro pointed out I was coasting in there compared to them so I'm inclined to townread both for now.

This feels like scum trying to pocket town with hard town reads. Slightly less inclined to think Drew/Maestro are a thing. Not impossible for Cakez to pair up a town with a group scum though.

Drew reads pretty town in game and in the pt

I probably want to eliminate Aureal or Bianco today. Maybe Roden or Theta??

FL is probably town but I really feel like that quickhammer was a gambit play he'd make as scum so I'm not writing him off

Yes I wouldn't eliminate FL today, but I'm definitely not putting him in my safe town reads, which would be Dan, Maestro, Titus and Thomith

Drew suspiciously missing after he just said he was town.

VOTE: aureal
I'll actually make a real vote for the day now

Considering this vote didn't stick, this unfortunately might have been distancing...

Dan isn't scummy at all why would we eliminate him today

More hardcore white knighting.

That's because I'm not...

This is backpedaling you said that you thought Titus and I were covered to cult because of activity changes. How is that not saying we are scummy?

VOTE: roden

Literally repeating the exact same argument Drew made.

[Narration]

Hu Tao replaces Gamma Emerald.

[Flavor Leaf]

And it’s not even Tuesday

[Hu Tao]

Hu Taown here to save the day