Mafia Reunion | Postgame

[ActionDan]

It is frustrating to deal with you. You either do not seem to understand my argument or don't want to. Leaning the former but dont know how to explain to you any better

[Flavor Leaf]

I don’t get any of it

[Doctor Drew]

I don't mind claiming my role at this point. I directly protect against conversions. There is abother role that does punish scum worse than denying the conversion

And again, if this role claim is correct......how did you know that maestro and cakez weren't converted?

Yes, I did prevent any actions from outside the FG from targeting you, but you didn't know that at the time.

And if you are town and being legit, you would not know that your action was successful or not.

Yet you somehow KNEW that neither maestro and cakez were not converted.

How?

???

How would you know that they weren't converted, protective roles would have no way of knowing this

[Roden]

Are we really questioning why the equivalent of a Doctor might believe that their action succeeded

[Flavor Leaf]

They could have been converted on opposite nights from when they were targeted, or started as scum.

I think I’m seeing what he’s saying, though, of why maybe it was all town at first based on roles and that it was meant to be a conversion prevention group.

That being said, NK15 role makes it look like group scum could have started in there.

There’s been no other things shown that show other communication stuff

[Flavor Leaf]

Are we really questioning why the equivalent of a Doctor might believe that their action succeeded

I have a similar feeling for this, but for some reason, I think we’re questioning it for different reasons.

I think there’s no way of knowing or not, so why are we questioning it, when Drew’s arguing that?

Are you implying that it makes sense?

[ActionDan]

For nk15 I was think8ng on this for a bit because its made no sense to me no matter how I sliced. But what if addicts can talk to each other but not group scum. Then it works whether or not a traitor addict started in fg or not

[Doctor Drew]

Are we really questioning why the equivalent of a Doctor might believe that their action succeeded

Well it isn't as simple as that, but kinda.

But that wasn't even the crux of my issue with Dan

[Flavor Leaf]

It’s different because a normal doctor would see a night kill, which could help them lean “oh i didn’t protect” but a no kill would have doc believe they did protect.

There’s nothing here for him to be able to know either way. I do think it helps because the others could have only been targeted on specific nights, but i don’t think it’s impossible that they were.

Cakez was in the name list, and if scum IS one of Blair or Nova, they would know 100% the other one of them is a free conversion.

[Flavor Leaf]

For nk15 I was think8ng on this for a bit because its made no sense to me no matter how I sliced. But what if addicts can talk to each other but not group scum. Then it works whether or not a traitor addict started in fg or not

And then NK15 can check for conversions in the FG.

If that’s a thing, I imagine eventually I should get that info based on what I’ve gotten.

[Doctor Drew]

Also Dan, one other thing.

You said you targeted Maestro with your action N1, as you put it you 100% know they were not converted.........then why assume that it was my action that prevented them from being potentially converted?

[ActionDan]

It is frustrating to deal with you. You either do not seem to understand my argument or don't want to. Leaning the former but dont know how to explain to you any better

Scratch that drew is town. Claim and timing would not have happened otherwise. I will keep reminding myself of this

[Doctor Drew]

It is frustrating to deal with you. You either do not seem to understand my argument or don't want to. Leaning the former but dont know how to explain to you any better

Scratch that drew is town. Claim and timing would not have happened otherwise. I will keep reminding myself of this

Also Dan, one other thing.

You said you targeted Maestro with your action N1, as you put it you 100% know they were not converted.........then why assume that it was my action that prevented them from being potentially converted?

[ActionDan]

Also Dan, one other thing.

You said you targeted Maestro with your action N1, as you put it you 100% know they were not converted.........then why assume that it was my action that prevented them from being potentially converted?

When did I say that? I asked if you targeted maestro because it made sense you would since you never claimed a n1 target and I had already claimed to have targeted maestro n1. Thus making your n1 claim close to irrelevant (yes I could have been rbed but that's not something I even considered)

[Doctor Drew]

Also Dan, one other thing.

You said you targeted Maestro with your action N1, as you put it you 100% know they were not converted.........then why assume that it was my action that prevented them from being potentially converted?

When did I say that? I asked if you targeted maestro because it made sense you would since you never claimed a n1 target and I had already claimed to have targeted maestro n1. Thus making your n1 claim close to irrelevant (yes I could have been rbed but that's not something I even considered)

Post 70 in the FG

[ActionDan]

I have 3 percent power our family is driv9ng back from ab all day event. Will be here in an hour or 2

Pedit

That 100% was for effect to say instead of just guessing based on play I had a role action to support. Mia culpa for not thinking of rbs at that moment in time

[Doctor Drew]

I have 3 percent power our family is driv9ng back from ab all day event. Will be here in an hour or 2

Pedit

That 100% was for effect to say instead of just guessing based on play I had a role action to support. Mia culpa for not thinking of rbs at that moment in time

I will just preface this that the emoji I am about to post has nothing to with your irl stuff, have safe travels and I hope you and your family had fun

But

[Doctor Drew]

I have 3 percent power our family is driv9ng back from ab all day event. Will be here in an hour or 2

Pedit

That 100% was for effect to say instead of just guessing based on play I had a role action to support. Mia culpa for not thinking of rbs at that moment in time

I will just preface this that the emoji I am about to post has nothing to with your irl stuff, have safe travels and I hope you and your family had fun

But

Why would he assume it was me who prevented maestro from being converted, when Dan claimed a role that can prevent conversions......and he claimed he used it on maestro??

[Maestro]

you guys we were friends wtf haqppened here

[Maestro]

they were getting pissed @ each other in FG too, idk what's going on but this srsly seems like just a HUGE misunderstanding about Dan/Drew/other NA targets...? can we just have anybody who's claimed or vagueclaimed clarify NActions, if that's such a huge issue? fk sake

[ActionDan]

Also Dan, one other thing.

You said you targeted Maestro with your action N1, as you put it you 100% know they were not converted.........then why assume that it was my action that prevented them from being potentially converted?

When did I say that? I asked if you targeted maestro because it made sense you would since you never claimed a n1 target and I had already claimed to have targeted maestro n1. Thus making your n1 claim close to irrelevant (yes I could have been rbed but that's not something I even considered)

"When did I say that?" Refers to the 2nd half. Pretty sure I never assumed it was specifically your action and your action alone at any point that was the cause of Maestro being not converted. I only assumed you actioned on Maestro N1 before you claimed that in fact it was me. This was because your non-mention of it up to that point was due to it being redundant as I had effectively claimed the same

[Flavor Leaf]

they were getting pissed @ each other in FG too, idk what's going on but this srsly seems like just a HUGE misunderstanding about Dan/Drew/other NA targets...? can we just have anybody who's claimed or vagueclaimed clarify NActions, if that's such a huge issue? fk sake

i dont feel like this is the issue at all?

[Flavor Leaf]

Drew on Maestro N1, Dan N2

Dan on Cakez N1, Maestro N2

from what i've seen. The issues are clearly coming from things beyond what the night actions are. I picked up on that not even being that thread.

[Doctor Drew]

Drew on Maestro N1, Dan N2

Dan on Cakez N1, Maestro N2

from what i've seen. The issues are clearly coming from things beyond what the night actions are. I picked up on that not even being that thread.

I was on Dan both nights

Dan claimed to be on maestro D1, cakez D2

[Maestro]

why did everybody target me N1?

I think one of you mentioend this in FG but I only said a couple things about "if I'm converted, you should X" bc I'm not used to Cult games & uit feels like playing to full-wincon as Town in Cultgame necessitates prepping others for like, Justice-LEague-style dealing w/ you if you go rogue, so I've been trying to do that, ig

PEdit: Drew literally just spent a page trying to clarify a role thing about Dan therapizing me, no? & don't say I'm fucking blank-walling plz & thank you, that comment has run its course & pisses me off

PE2: what is clear to you obviously may not be for me, my guy, either take me at face value/help me understand or don't fucking answer the post/qyestion?

PE3: ok