Mini Theme 2330 - A Questionable Almost-Normal Game - Postgame

[ketchup777]

Why do I keep accidentally getting pagetops

You’re just cool like that


Hi can I get cool points too

[ketchup777]

Ok maybe ketchup is town

How so?

He's finally starting to feel like how he felt in our last game. Are you not seeing it?

I am to a degree, but that doesn't mean much on its own. Unless you know how his scum game differs from his town games.

I probably would have made 50 posts instead of 119

But guessing ofc

Do you think the best strategy as scum is to lurk and post less?

im not ketchup- but yes i personally do because out of sight = out of mind

tadaaa

It’s always(usually) the quiet ones

[ketchup777]

The "you seem to be on a similar wavelength" line in particular feels a lot like it could be fishing

Or, they seemed to be on a similar wavelength. Considering they seemingly caught exactly what I caught, and asked ketchup if they thought I was town because of that discrepency which I then brought up and talked about. Don't kid yourself

response feels genuine...

Why is it genuine for sure and not frustrated wolf

[ketchup777]

jackson your gifs are making me laugh too much

[ketchup777]

I’ll drop you to unsorted

[ketchup777]

/like I think the likelihood of ketchup v jackson being TvT

is probably at least as high as it being TvS after the page 19 interactions

mm i think I was letting bias cloud my judgments, it does kind of feel like he’s town again (he was in the last one we played together)

[ketchup777]

56 kinda feels like a townie post

in tone but not in content methinks as disengagement tends to maf probably but who knowssss

Don't like the fencesitting.

I actually though ketchup was newer than he is, but I'm still very inclined to townlean this way of thinking

56 kinda feels like a townie post

in tone but not in content methinks as disengagement tends to maf probably but who knowssss

Don't like the fencesitting.

I would never
VOTE: Titus

having just said that, this response makes me feel very nervy about ketchup

I skipped paged 9 just light hedging their bets here.

Hmm I like this, interesting take. However aware that lots of people have said I say a bunch of stuff that makes them nervous so could be nothing

[ketchup777]

ok i just had a bit of a revelation. still think ranger is a good vote atm but lol rereading something with town python and town LG in mind after I had changed my mind on those 2 slots was pretty interesting implications for someone elses alignment

give us the tea, don't tease meeeeeeeeee

the tea was that i reevaluated jackson to more towny

I was hoping for something spicier, but I see nothing wrong with that

I read this as spider the first time, it all make so much more sense nowww

[ketchup777]

Ok well maybe this is where I drop that I think lap/titus/ranger is my current running solve

150ish posts before that you said I was town. Want to explain the opinion flip?

yeah i was high asf

I think town would be more likely to get high tbh

Because town!koba probably has nothing to hide whereas scum!koba has everything to hide. Allowing yourself to post to the thread while high as mafia would be an amusing but dangerous enterprise. On the contrary, being high as town would merely help to bring out your inner thoughts and you would probably appear more honest at the same time.

[ketchup777]

I'm pretty confident that lap is flipping scum here

Is still this only from misremembering JOAT or do you have other reasons?

Your town games you were more free. Here you seem nervous or something. Like unsure how to act.

Ironic since here I'm just going full stream of consciousness posting while last game I spent like 15 fucking minutes perfecting the wording on each of my socialist propaganda posts

So you’re saying there’s a contrast between what your towngame was and what you think looks like a towngame. Interesting

VOTE: Laplacian

Still heavy sus on Ranger and Titus but Laplacian also makes it into my top 3 now I think

[ketchup777]

so you're claiming? /jk

Crumbing, there's a difference!

Can someone explain the reference to me

[ketchup777]

Is top of your list most scummy or least scummy?

Which one was accompanied with a declaration of being a serious vote?

This misunderstanding feels like it should never have happened dumbtelling tbh.

Agreed

Look, if Ranger immediately votes his top townread next to his list, how am I supposed to magically work out that he was joking? Yes he said 'lol' but that could have just been because he thought Koba was so obvious, or something else entirely.

Anyway, I think Ranger has conveniently posted a few more lists so she can subtly slip onto the Light wagon, while getting off Hu Tao after getting no support there. I don’t think Hu Tao had done nearly enough to warrant being Ranger’s top scum read for 9 pages. She opened with her standard 'Hi.’ and then a few other friendly posts, nothing scummy at all imo. Ranger’s reads list feels very forced, as though she knows she is endplayed into this line of play style but unsure who to say she suspects. The stopping of reads lists after getting to a point where she could vote Lightganski also feels oh so conveeeeeenient

[ketchup777]

Oops messed up quoting. that should be it from me now though. Want to vote Ranger but Lap’ll be ok for now

[ketchup777]

VOTE: Hu Tao
Serious vote.

why hu tao?

Vibes.

Why

not

Hu Tao?

A very generic and evasive answer

[ketchup777]

Usually vibes come with like a reason. Like did one of my posts come off weird to you?

Yes, all of them.

Again, no specifics. Feels like she knows she’s making it up

[usesPython]

Is top of your list most scummy or least scummy?

Which one was accompanied with a declaration of being a serious vote?

This misunderstanding feels like it should never have happened dumbtelling tbh.

Agreed

Look, if Ranger immediately votes his top townread next to his list, how am I supposed to magically work out that he was joking? Yes he said 'lol' but that could have just been because he thought Koba was so obvious, or something else entirely.

Anyway, I think Ranger has conveniently posted a few more lists so she can subtly slip onto the Light wagon, while getting off Hu Tao after getting no support there. I don’t think Hu Tao had done nearly enough to warrant being Ranger’s top scum read for 9 pages. She opened with her standard 'Hi.’ and then a few other friendly posts, nothing scummy at all imo. Ranger’s reads list feels very forced, as though she knows she is endplayed into this line of play style but unsure who to say she suspects. The stopping of reads lists after getting to a point where she could vote Lightganski also feels oh so conveeeeeenient

You got the order wrong. Top of the list is town, bottom is scum.

[usesPython]

Ketchup what's your read on Hu Tao

[ketchup777]

Is top of your list most scummy or least scummy?

Which one was accompanied with a declaration of being a serious vote?

This misunderstanding feels like it should never have happened dumbtelling tbh.

Agreed

Look, if Ranger immediately votes his top townread next to his list, how am I supposed to magically work out that he was joking? Yes he said 'lol' but that could have just been because he thought Koba was so obvious, or something else entirely.

Anyway, I think Ranger has conveniently posted a few more lists so she can subtly slip onto the Light wagon, while getting off Hu Tao after getting no support there. I don’t think Hu Tao had done nearly enough to warrant being Ranger’s top scum read for 9 pages. She opened with her standard 'Hi.’ and then a few other friendly posts, nothing scummy at all imo. Ranger’s reads list feels very forced, as though she knows she is endplayed into this line of play style but unsure who to say she suspects. The stopping of reads lists after getting to a point where she could vote Lightganski also feels oh so conveeeeeenient

You got the order wrong. Top of the list is town, bottom is scum.

No I’ve realised that now. I’m taking about 49 as why I was confused which way up the reads list went. Danger voted Koba, his top town read. I knew one of the Koba/Hu Tao votes were a joke but I didn’t know which

[ketchup777]

Sorry, Ranger and her*

[ketchup777]

Ketchup what's your read on Hu Tao

Town because she feels very similar to Mini Normal 2325 which I just played with her, where she was also town. I can do an ISO dive at some point but I might save most of those until day 2 (if I’m alive)

[usesPython]

Do you have any other reads of Ranger that you disagree with/don't understand

[Black]

I lost my trial.

Oh no how long are you going to prison for D:

[Titus]

I lost my trial.

Oh no how long are you going to prison for D:

My client's sentencing is next week.

[Hu Tao]

I lost my trial.

Oh no how long are you going to prison for D:

LMAO

[Hu Tao]

I'll catch up later on