Mini Theme 2330 - A Questionable Almost-Normal Game - Postgame

[usesPython]

Also

V/LA until the 13th, we should be able to post during that time except for the 5th and 13th

[Doctor Drew]

I doubt it's truly a Ganski/Ranger/PC solve but it sure feels like it

Sometimes it really is that easy

VOTE: PC

Also there is no chance that I as scum(unless you are my buddy) would claim an inno on you, the person who tends to read me the best here.

[Ranger]

Ranger our problem with you this game is that we can't track your progression on a few key players. How is Hu Tao's early game different enough from her later posting to go from vibing scummiest to vibing genuine and town? Why is PC town?

Political Clout feels identical to the game we just played where he was town. Additionally, despite his take being wrong, we genuinely believe he thinks it’s true, which would spew him town.

Hu Tao's early game had a more stilted forced feeling; we thought she was trying too hard. Her later posts felt more natural. I saw more light-hearted content and a sense of casual solving. Not strongly enough to lock her as town; strong enough to not push her. On D2, I just haven’t felt she’s shown the trait I’m looking for; scum who knew about the cop-heavy nature of the game. It’s far from impossible to mask said trait, or for me to miss it, yet I get neutral to positive vibes from what I’ve seen.

Why ask this now rather than D1?

[Ranger]

yet gut pings as possibly not uninformed Cop.

Clarify this please

With the Cop reveal D2, we now know that there’s presumably 1-3 Godfathers among a slough of Cops.

Every Town Cop on D1 believed they were the only cop. As Uninformed, they didn’t know.

Every scum on D1 knew. On D1, they would have to fake believing they are the only Cop.

Not-Uninformed-Cop is thus the sign of scum.

[JacksonVirgo]

I fail to see how that answers my question

[JacksonVirgo]

For everybody you're calling likely informed, can you elaborate on

[Titus]

VOTE: Titus
Gut.
I believe a town-Titus would handle my slot nearly identically to how Titus did if planning to investigate me. A Ranger N1 copcheck fits her mindset perfectly.

However, pending review, my mental memory of Titus's D1 has a slight mistake from a pre-planned scum narrative to mimic her townplay.

A scum-Titus would know she would need to mimic her town-cop mindset and would be playing attempting to mimic it.

I believe she made a slight mistake, and did something she wouldn’t have if actually town.

It’s weak, and she could just be a cop. I want to place the vote for now, pending review and investigation.

Poor Ranger. Oat allergy?

[usesPython]

Why ask this now rather than D1?

Lap got quickhammered, why do you think?

[usesPython]

And you've already explained Hu Tao before I think we just can't see the change in vibes in those posts which is our issue cause you're normally decently trackable even when we disagree

[Titus]

Hipgun firing a team of
{Titus, Doctor Drew, +1}, with the final being among {usesPython, light_ganski, JacksonVirgo}.

Titus I believe slipped not being a genuine uninformed cop.
Doctor Drew, I believe slipped not being a genuine uninformed cop around his earlypage Koba Miller claim interactions.

The third is Gut guesswork.
UsesPython looks town to me yet they always do even when scum; objectively they

may

have made a similar non-uninformed Cop slip.
Light_ganski looks like scum and also may have.
JacksonVirgo has been town to me, yet gut pings as possibly not uninformed Cop.

Enchant is town.
Political Clout I’m fairly sure is town.

{Black, ketchup777, Hu Tao} are technically unsorted, yet vibe as genuine and town to me.

All of this is pending review.

Yeah no. Never happened.

[usesPython]

Also

V/LA until the 13th, we should be able to post during that time except for the

5th

6th and 13th

[Ranger]

After consideration, I’ve moved Titus from gut scum off a possible scum indicator to definitive scum from a smoking gun.

Look here.

Ranger's not scum.

There's got to be a catch. No fewer than 3 cops in a game. Wtf

Read every post prior on D2. It’s the page before.

Read every day two post,

closely

, then look at Titus's post.

Notice something?

[Ranger]

After consideration, I’ve moved Titus from gut scum off a possible scum indicator to definitive scum from a smoking gun.

Look here.

Ranger's not scum.

There's got to be a catch. No fewer than 3 cops in a game. Wtf

Read every post prior on D2. It’s the page before.

Read every day two post,

closely

, then look at Titus's post.

Notice something?

I’ll let you figure it out for a bit.

It’s a separate giveaway to the prior, and builds on top of the other slip, yet this one is by far the bigger.

Think about it for a while.

Think what a town cop would be thinking.
With two flipped cops, yet no indication there’s more than three.

Can you see what I saw?

[Ranger]

I fail to see how that answers my question

Every actual town Cop believed they were the only Cop on D1.

The scum clearly knew there was more than one Cop in the game, because they clearly have pre-planned Cop fakeclaims heading into D2. They had information we didn’t.

This information would be reflected in play, because every town player plays differently as a Cop thinking they’re the only Cop compared to how they would knowing the truth.

I believe it will be easy to inadvertently spot the scum TMI, where their cover slipped, and instead of playing as if they’re the only Cop, they accidentally showed they knew there were multiple cops.

I found a gigantic sign from Titus of this, as well as suspected signs elsewhere.

[Ranger]

For everybody you're calling likely informed, can you elaborate on

Titus was originally her D1 Ranger read. I’ve since spotted something far more condemning.

Drew was Miller interactions with Koba.

You, usesPython, and light_ganski are similarly Maybes, along with your D2 opener potentially being primed for the reveal in advance.

Since I’m working off memory of interactions, all but the Titus tell need to be verified by reading back.

[Ranger]

Why ask this now rather than D1?

Lap got quickhammered, why do you think?

Not until well after my last post. My reads were far from new at my last post, too. Why wait and not immediately ask?

[usesPython]

I fail to see how that answers my question

Every actual town Cop believed they were the only Cop on D1.

The scum clearly knew there was more than one Cop in the game, because they clearly have pre-planned Cop fakeclaims heading into D2. They had information we didn’t.

This information would be reflected in play, because every town player plays differently as a Cop thinking they’re the only Cop compared to how they would knowing the truth.

I believe it will be easy to inadvertently spot the scum TMI, where their cover slipped, and instead of playing as if they’re the only Cop, they accidentally showed they knew there were multiple cops.

I found a gigantic sign from Titus of this, as well as suspected signs elsewhere.

Counterpoint: scum figured out everyone's a cop after Drew and JV vagueposting/Titus claimed 3rd cop and scum are just people with bad cop equity like PC

[usesPython]

Why ask this now rather than D1?

Lap got quickhammered, why do you think?

Not until well after my last post. My reads were far from new at my last post, too. Why wait and not immediately ask?

It's called being asleep

[Ranger]

As for the Titus reveal.

Perhaps ask this.

Why is it we know everyone is a Cop?

We only have two Cop flips.

Yet everyone has claimed Cop, and results.

What started it?

[Alianna]

2.04

Votecount 2.04

light_ganski (2): JacksonVirgo, Black
Ranger (2): Enchant, Political Clout
Titus (1): Ranger
Political Clout (1): usesPython

Not Voting (5): Titus, light_ganski, Hu Tao, Doctor Drew, ketchup777

With 11 players alive, it takes 6 votes to secure an execution.

The day deadline is in (expired on 2024-03-14 01:04:13).

Mod Notes: The combined mod ISO is here.

[Ranger]

Counterpoint: scum figured out everyone's a cop after Drew and JV vagueposting/Titus claimed 3rd cop and scum are just people with bad cop equity like PC

The vagueposting gave no indication of a Cop setup.

Titus was explicitly claiming Cop.

Do you see the issue with an explicitly unprompted third Cop claim?

[Alianna]

Also

V/LA until the 13th, we should be able to post during that time except for the

5th

6th and 13th

Noted.

[JacksonVirgo]

What started it?

I started it, technically

[JacksonVirgo]

As soon as Koba flipped I knew what we were dealing with, it's obvious is it not? Drew caught it, as did I and Titus did too hence their claim.

[Titus]

Ranger, I don't get at all what you're saying. The goal posts seem to be moving but I can't even track where they were. I am ill so maybe that's part of not seeing it.

Part of me think Ranger may be doing leaps to try and deflect from PC.