Mini Theme 2330 - A Questionable Almost-Normal Game - Postgame

[JacksonVirgo]

I'm sitting on that for a moment

[usesPython]

I think not seeing anything wrong with Laps cop claim as a cop is pretty bad

[Political Clout]

Why do work when you can get other people to do it for you

because I'm not the one making stuff up about what I did.

[usesPython]

Why do work when you can get other people to do it for you

because I'm not the one making stuff up about what I did.

We play from memory and misremember sometimes

[ketchup777]

As soon as Koba flipped I knew what we were dealing with, it's obvious is it not? Drew caught it, as did I and Titus did too hence their claim.

Was it?

That’s the issue.

What made it all cops, not just three or four?

It wasn’t obvious to me.
It isn’t something which is clearly the case, just from two different Cop flips.

Yes, everyone looking would suspect shenanigans via knowing they are a third Cop.

What

confirmed

it was shenanigans, and what made it not worth sitting on?

For instance, you and Drew remained ambiguous. When reading, I didn’t know you were referring to Cop shenanigans. "Notice something?" Could have meant anything. You didn’t hint at an innocent and neither did Drew. Neither of you indicated you had investigated.

Why didn’t Titus do similarly?

Why did she get explicit and not leave things vague?

Especially given it’s

Titus

, whose modus operandi is vagueness in claims?

while I make no comment on Titus' slot, I agree that I went from believing it was a 1cop-multimiller setup, to a 2cop overnight, to a 3 cop after the flip. I thought the funny thing was that there'd be 3 of us counterclaiming, and my mind didn't immediately jump to all cops until I saw that there'd been like 2+4=6 claimed/proven cops in a short timespan

[usesPython]

I'm sitting on that for a moment

How sure are you

[JacksonVirgo]

70/30

[usesPython]

UNVOTE: PC

who do you want dead rn?

[ketchup777]

Especially given it’s

Titus

, whose modus operandi is vagueness in claims?

For those unfamiliar with Titus's meta;
Titus is infamous for trying to coordinate inthread with other townies and attempt to lay traps for scum.

To communicate secretly with players using code words, off of an understood connection.

I can think of many, and link at least one in 30 hours.

So, if you assume Titus did see the JV-Drew interaction,

why didn’t she try to lay a trap for scum?

Why didn’t she try to work with JV and Drew?
Why did she explicitly claim, rather than remain vague and see from others if her suspicion was correct?

She didn’t act like a third Cop trying to scope out the setup.

She acted like she knew everyone was a Cop and there was no point in laying a trap.

sure, I look forward to your linking one

[ketchup777]

Who's the miller claim?

Koba and you, remember your antics all those years ago?

[JacksonVirgo]

Oh so there's no genuine miller?

[ketchup777]

If you say so bestie

[JacksonVirgo]

I think the focus on PC always was a distraction from Ganski. I didn't ever really think it looked damning, I said so to get the best response from them

[JacksonVirgo]

I wanna wait for PC to respond before I add more to the conversation

Hence this post

[ketchup777]

I think not seeing anything wrong with Laps cop claim as a cop is pretty bad

Unfortunately I might be biased, because I knew Lap’s claim was real (by checking the end of the thread) before I read through the final 100 posts of day 1. However, when I saw his cop flip, though a surprise, I was like oh! of course there’s more than one cop haha that makes sense

I imagine I would have believed him if I were there at the time too

I don’t buy all this certainty that a cop thinks there can’t be two cops, we’re in a QUESTIONABLE game. Why not stop and think about how that could actually be fair? Why rush?

Drew/Jackson/Titus surprise team?

[JacksonVirgo]

Playing on this site has conditioned me, and others, to think an ungated Cop is already busted so multiple just digs into your brain as "this isn't right" regardless of a questionable game. There's a reason why I voted them, and then backed out when I came to my senses.

[ketchup777]

Anyway, we need to coordinate our cops incase scum have 1+ non-godfathers. but also it’s possible mafia have a roleblock (tho no one claimed roleblock last night yet). I’d like to wait until light claims before I suggest some ideas

[JacksonVirgo]

Cops are the new VT. There's going to be sprinkled roles like the Disloyal but mostly they're the new VT, no point in coordinating anything really.

[ketchup777]

Playing on this site has conditioned me, and others, to think an ungated Cop is already busted so multiple just digs into your brain as "this isn't right" regardless of a questionable game. There's a reason why I voted them, and then backed out when I came to my senses.

Oh yeah actually you behaved how I think makes sense actually.

Drew went all in, not taking the time to think, and quoting Kobas post about him being the hammer as a lame excuse to hammer. hmmm

[JacksonVirgo]

Hypoclaims could be interesting regardless as if someone is a Disloyal cop or smthn and die we don't lose all the info

[usesPython]

Cops are the new VT. There's going to be sprinkled roles like the Disloyal but mostly they're the new VT, no point in coordinating anything really.

We'll wait until light claims to comment on this further

[ketchup777]

Cops are the new VT. There's going to be sprinkled roles like the Disloyal but mostly they're the new VT, no point in coordinating anything really.

I think we want to make sure we have at least 2 people check everyone if possible. As noones claiming miller it’s possible a normal cop gets lucky

[ketchup777]

stop revealing all your thoughts me

[Political Clout]

I wanna wait for PC to respond before I add more to the conversation

Hence this post

I never even saw this.

[JacksonVirgo]

Drew went all in, not taking the time to think, and quoting Kobas post about him being the hammer as a lame excuse to hammer. hmmm

I genuinely think both of their reactions makes perfect sense, they were already being scum-read and then they claimed a Cop (when koba and drew both were cops). I think my retraction was only because I pretty much lock-towned them through their content