Mini Theme 2330 - A Questionable Almost-Normal Game - Postgame

[JacksonVirgo]

This post is an acknowledgement of what you just said but I am not able to respond just yet but I want to

[Titus]

I'm likely out for the evening

[usesPython]

We're available what's the current beef

[Doctor Drew]

We're available what's the current beef

Titus hates us, Ketchup hates us.....no one likes us, I am lonely

But Jackson likes me....please don't so you hate me

[JacksonVirgo]

We're available what's the current beef

Titus hates us, Ketchup hates us.....no one likes us, I am lonely

But Jackson likes me....please don't so you hate me

Did you miss my question or haven't gotten around to answering yet?

[Doctor Drew]

We're available what's the current beef

Titus hates us, Ketchup hates us.....no one likes us, I am lonely

But Jackson likes me....please don't so you hate me

Did you miss my question or haven't gotten around to answering yet?

You mind linking me to the question again?

[JacksonVirgo]

Spoiler:

Lap is clear town to me

The claim was cursed so I wanted to dip my toes in but no, they’re just town

Can you explain? More so the cursed claim thing

It’s just a rough claim

Gave me enough pause that I wanted to throw my heart over the edge to see how it felt

Ok....

But what sort of claim would make you consider it as a fake claim?

It’s just a rough claim

Gave me enough pause that I wanted to throw my heart over the edge to see how it felt

Ok....

But what sort of claim would make you consider it as a fake claim?

It felt like it was possibly a desperation claim, that had an easy way out if they give a wrong result.

Isn't that the sort of claim scum would make??

@Drew, can you explain your mindset with these posts? I wrote up my own analysis and felt it better to hear it from you specifically

[Enchant]

I did turn in lazy sludge huh?

[Doctor Drew]

Spoiler:

Lap is clear town to me

The claim was cursed so I wanted to dip my toes in but no, they’re just town

Can you explain? More so the cursed claim thing

It’s just a rough claim

Gave me enough pause that I wanted to throw my heart over the edge to see how it felt

Ok....

But what sort of claim would make you consider it as a fake claim?

It’s just a rough claim

Gave me enough pause that I wanted to throw my heart over the edge to see how it felt

Ok....

But what sort of claim would make you consider it as a fake claim?

It felt like it was possibly a desperation claim, that had an easy way out if they give a wrong result.

Isn't that the sort of claim scum would make??

@Drew, can you explain your mindset with these posts? I wrote up my own analysis and felt it better to hear it from you specifically

I was confused a bit about your teetering on the edge about it being a 'rough claim' to believing it was from town........but was more so heavily hinting that I knew it was a fake claim(obviously in retrospect it wasn't.....but at that time I thought it was)

[Ranger]

Preamble:

Spoiler: This is every D2 post prior to Titus' entrance

@Enchant, any first words?

Man. I was about to come into today upset at koba. Because Lap's claim sounded like it was there to find miller's. But I was also going to say koba was probably town for it because of Lap's role. But now I'm shook. Also why would scum even kill the Miller claim.

@Enchant, any first words?

Any last words?

Man. I was about to come into today upset at koba. Because Lap's claim sounded like it was there to find miller's. But I was also going to say koba was probably town for it because of Lap's role. But now I'm shook. Also why would scum even kill the Miller claim.

I got no time for shook ones #mobbdeep

Man. I was about to come into today upset at koba. Because Lap's claim sounded like it was there to find miller's. But I was also going to say koba was probably town for it because of Lap's role. But now I'm shook. Also why would scum even kill the Miller claim.

I'm upset Lap went out but it is what it is. I think Drew is town from that, so at least there's that.

VOTE: Ganski
For good measure

Scum is probably somewhere on the wagon. I'd say I like PCs vote the best out of all. So he's prob town.

I think Ranger and Ganski both look bad given that flip

@Enchant, any first words?

Any last words?

Of course, my last words are

Spoiler: Last Words

Drew, you catch what I caught?

Yes I think so

Special;

Quite an interesting setup

Drew, you catch what I caught?

[JacksonVirgo]

Oh oh, what's gonna drop

[JacksonVirgo]

I love my fuckin' gifs lmao

[Doctor Drew]

I love my fuckin' gifs lmao

I also love Mobb Deep

[JacksonVirgo]

If Ranger ain't gonna praise me about how huge brain I am I don't want it

[Ranger]

With the preamble established, let's look at this Titus post. You know every post in D2 before this one, and this was Titus's first post of the day.

Ranger's not scum.
There's got to be a catch.

No fewer than 3 cops

in a game. Wtf

Titus

immediately

claimed third cop, and said there must be a catch, claiming an innocent on me.

Why would

Titus

, infamous for keeping cards close to her chest unless absolutely necessary, claim Cop

unprompted

, and out her innocent with zero pressure on

either her or her target

? She had no votes, I had no votes, both were under minimal suspicion.

From the perspective of a town-Titus

, why couldn't this have been a valid setup?

Spoiler: Hypothetical Setup

This is a Valid Normal setup

Town Disloyal Cop
Town Cop
Town Cop
Vanilla Townie x 7

Mafia Roleblocker
Mafia Goon x2

Titus has played Normal Games where every town role was the same.

There's Normal Games like this which feature three investigatives.

What stopped the game from being a Normal game with 3 cops, maybe some extra TPRs, and some mafia PRs against them?

In a town-Titus perspective,

at the time she claimed

, it was fully possible

she was the only living investigative left

. What if there were only 3 Cops in the entire game? Titus recklessly would have outed herself on D2 with a single result in her

first post

.

This makes no sense in a town-Titus world, especially as I believe she specified she hadn't read the prior content (although I can't find that in her iso). She'd have no reason to hand the scum free kills on myself and herself and prevent herself from generating any read. Especially because it's

Titus

. These actions wouldn't fit for

any

player; they are extra egregious from Titus.

This makes sense in a scum-Titus world, as she would know the Cop-heavy nature of the setup either through explicit information or Scum Godfathers deduction, inferring it from the scum roles. She would know her claim would trigger a chain-reaction of Cop claims, revealing the all-Cop setup on D2.

A town-Titus would hold her role close to her chest. She may have implied it with a sentence like "I smell shenanigans", left unexplained.

A scum-Titus gave it away with the bolded part, the true key. "no fewer than 3 cops".

Why did Titus assume there were

no fewer than

three cops, instead of

at least

three

?

That's the perspective slip.

[Ranger]

Oh oh, what's gonna drop

Without the fluff, as succinctly as I can,

this was Titus's first post of the day.

Ranger's not scum.
There's got to be a catch.

No fewer than 3 cops

in a game. Wtf

Titus

immediately

claimed third cop, and said there must be a catch, claiming an innocent on me.

Why would

Titus

, infamous for keeping cards close to her chest unless absolutely necessary, claim Cop

unprompted

, and out her innocent with zero pressure on

either her or her target

? She had no votes, I had no votes, both were under minimal suspicion.

From the perspective of a town-Titus

, why (out)?

At the time she claimed

, it was fully possible

she was the only living investigative left

.

A scum-Titus gave it away with the bolded part, the true key. "no fewer than 3 cops".

Why did Titus assume there were

no fewer than

three cops, instead of

at least

three

?

That's the perspective slip.

[Ranger]

this was Titus's first post of the day.

Ranger's not scum.
There's got to be a catch.

No fewer than 3 cops

in a game. Wtf

Titus

immediately

claimed third cop, and said there must be a catch, claiming an innocent on me.

Why would

Titus

, infamous for keeping cards close to her chest unless absolutely necessary, claim Cop

unprompted

, and out her innocent with zero pressure on

either her or her target

? She had no votes, I had no votes, both were under minimal suspicion.

From the perspective of a town-Titus

, why (out)?

At the time she claimed

, it was fully possible

she was the only living investigative left

.

A scum-Titus gave it away with the bolded part, the true key. "no fewer than 3 cops".

Why did Titus assume there were

no fewer than

three cops, instead of

at least

three

?

That's the perspective slip.

This is the heart of it.

[Ranger]

I'm fine with light or Jackson

Perhaps consider;

this was Titus's first post of the day.

Ranger's not scum.
There's got to be a catch.

No fewer than 3 cops

in a game. Wtf

Titus

immediately

claimed third cop, and said there must be a catch, claiming an innocent on me.

Why would

Titus

, infamous for keeping cards close to her chest unless absolutely necessary, claim Cop

unprompted

, and out her innocent with zero pressure on

either her or her target

? She had no votes, I had no votes, both were under minimal suspicion.

From the perspective of a town-Titus

, why (out)?

At the time she claimed

, it was fully possible

she was the only living investigative left

.

A scum-Titus gave it away with the bolded part, the true key. "no fewer than 3 cops".

Why did Titus assume there were

no fewer than

three cops, instead of

at least

three

?

That's the perspective slip.

[JacksonVirgo]

Before I add my thoughts, why make a special section for my two posts about the setup when u didn’t use them for anything? Lol

[Ranger]

i'm not saying no right now because titus is up there as a potential partner to them

If Titus is potential scum to you, perhaps listen;

this was Titus's first post of the day.

Ranger's not scum.
There's got to be a catch.

No fewer than 3 cops

in a game. Wtf

Titus

immediately

claimed third cop, and said there must be a catch, claiming an innocent on me.

Why would

Titus

, infamous for keeping cards close to her chest unless absolutely necessary, claim Cop

unprompted

, and out her innocent with zero pressure on

either her or her target

? She had no votes, I had no votes, both were under minimal suspicion.

From the perspective of a town-Titus

, why (out)?

At the time she claimed

, it was fully possible

she was the only living investigative left

.

A scum-Titus gave it away with the bolded part, the true key. "no fewer than 3 cops".

Why did Titus assume there were

no fewer than

three cops, instead of

at least

three

?

That's the perspective slip.

[JacksonVirgo]

Lol, well Ranger is town.

VOTE: Titus

Awaiting her response

[Ranger]

Before I add my thoughts, why make a special section for my two posts about the setup when u didn’t use them for anything? Lol

It also was meant to have the Drew section there. The 'special' part of it was merely highlighting how they weren't hinting at being a Cop. You and Drew said

nothing

in your "notice something?" exchange. Noticing something could've been a shared read. Noticing something could've been a thought about scum killing Koba. Noticing something could've been spotting a suspect interaction at the end of D1. There was nothing which, even if Titus

did

read it, would have told her you were Cops.

[Ranger]

titus usespython lightganski I think this might be the team.

Join me on Titus please?

I want her at l-2 minimum. We can continue discussing if need be and not place her higher if there's value in continued talks. If you're satisfied though, Titus should get 5 - 6 votes.

[Ranger]

consider my vote on Titus for now but also I would never do her like that while she’s ill (I totally would but whatever)

Please return to voting her when you feel it's safe to. Though we need not end the day, she should be the lim today.

[Alianna]

~•~