Mafia 97 - Day Night Mafia, Game Over

[Kise]

It's funny that I'd link you to Scott based on how hard he is detracting from your lynch

****

---

Vote Count:

saberwolf(2)

- Platypus_Dude, Scott Brosius

Kise(4)

- Battle Mage, Bekkatha, Sando, lobstermania

MafiaSSK(5)

- Kise, BloodCovenent, DTMaster, saberwolf, xRECKONERx

Not Voting(2)

- MafiaSSK, iPeanut

Deadline:

24/8/09 15:45 Central Time

7 to Lynch
4 to Lynch at deadline

[xRECKONERx]

I'm also very interested in this neutral result on saber. SK?

[DTMaster]

Sorry town but MafiaSSK is scum. I counter claim his town result as Day Miller. I shouldn't turn up as innocent, in fact I should be guilty on this result. SSK is pulling out results from the general feeling of the town (I'm not high on the suspicious list and sabrewolf is gaining suspicion at the moment, hence the neutral result).

I can't guarantee that Sabre is actually town but an SK in the game is quite unlikely (look at the night kill results I doubt that the SK's kills crossed with night mafia and/or got protected 2 nights in a row).

So SSK. Die scum die!

(Sorry town, I had work today so I couldn't post today. :< 8 Hour shifts FTL)

[MafiaSSK]

Lmfao, I fuggin' butchered that sentence in 796.

***to believe BC was also town cop***

Fixed. And... OK then. Neutral would mean SB is not mafia, but not town. He can be dealt with in LyLo if he isn't killed.

But now this introduces a whole 'nother level to this complex game.. It's funny that I'd link Scott you based on how hard he was defending you, pre-claim. And to boot, he's going after SW, who you now reveal you got a neutral result back from.

Speaking of which, how did you come to get a neutral result? I thought it was only 'guilty' & 'innocent' ???

I have no clue how I got a neutral result. That's what the mod said my replacee had gotten.

[MafiaSSK]

When you say they were not your choice, you mean that someone else picked them for you, or what?

Flavor claim, please.

As in Falkomagno had chosen who I inspected because he had this role.

[MafiaSSK]

I'm also very interested in this neutral result on saber. SK?

No clue.

[MafiaSSK]

Sorry town but MafiaSSK is scum. I counter claim his town result as Day Miller. I shouldn't turn up as innocent, in fact I should be guilty on this result. SSK is pulling out results from the general feeling of the town (I'm not high on the suspicious list and sabrewolf is gaining suspicion at the moment, hence the neutral result).

But I got you're town. Bah. This makes no sense.

I can't guarantee that Sabre is actually town but an SK in the game is quite unlikely (look at the night kill results I doubt that the SK's kills crossed with night mafia and/or got protected 2 nights in a row).

And yet highly possible.

[xRECKONERx]

And yet... the man you said you investigated just fucking destroyed your fakeclaim.

Hey, guys, can we lynch SSK now? Kthx.

[MafiaSSK]

And yet... the man you said you investigated just fucking destroyed your fakeclaim.

Hey, guys, can we lynch SSK now? Kthx.

But I'm a cop. You guys can't lynch me!

[DTMaster]

@SSK
Sorry more lies here. Your claim holds no water against me. If I'm scum lying I should be hung tomorrow no questions asked with rapid succession.

"prepares rope"
"saws"
"nails"
"chainsaws"
"hammers"
"etc....."

"gives it to the town"
"grabs a burning torch"

[DTMaster]

@SSK
AtE much?

[MafiaSSK]

@SSK
AtE much?

I fail to see how that's Appeal to Emotion

[DTMaster]

I read your 808 with a giant stick of sarcasm. :<

[DTMaster]

Er EBWOP: I read it as a giant post of sarcasm.

[BloodCovenent]

And yet... the man you said you investigated just fucking destroyed your fakeclaim.

Hey, guys, can we lynch SSK now? Kthx.

But I'm a cop. You guys can't lynch me!

@SSK
AtE much?

[MafiaSSK]

And yet... the man you said you investigated just fucking destroyed your fakeclaim.

Hey, guys, can we lynch SSK now? Kthx.

But I'm a cop. You guys can't lynch me!

@SSK
AtE much?

Again, how?

[saberwolf]

there are so many holes in your claim SSK, you HAVE to be scum.

let's get this day over with. I'll have to reread the last few pages, see who else other than scott and kise were connected to SSK.

[xRECKONERx]

Question: would a miller actually know he's a miller? I thought a miller appeared as townie to himself.

[BloodCovenent]

And yet... the man you said you investigated just fucking destroyed your fakeclaim.

Hey, guys, can we lynch SSK now? Kthx.

But I'm a cop.

You guys can't lynch me!

@SSK
AtE much?

Again, how?

We "

Can't lynch you

," because your a claimed cop. thats an appeal to emotion, i believe.

Question: would a miller actually know he's a miller? I thought a miller appeared as townie to himself.

some games they give out the actual role name.

[MafiaSSK]

Question: would a miller actually know he's a miller? I thought a miller appeared as townie to himself.

Most normal games do.

[DTMaster]

@ Reck

Here is proof: Scrubs Mafia

Incidentally Kelso, the miller was told he was a miller in flavor fashion. So yes some games do tell you that you are a miller or an "outsider".

(Note: I love the flavour of this game, and it's actually a game to get a cop meta on SSK. Go figure. I stumbled upon this game by accident a while back and saved it since I'm a scrubs fan, but Enough off topic talk.)

[xRECKONERx]

What an awesome game flavor.

Anyway, yeah, SSK is scum.

[Scott Brosius]

Giant hole in SSK's claim. The investigations he listed probably just went along with general opinion although listing SW as neutral seems strange. It would be suicide for DTMaster to claim like that if he was scum though.

Unvote
Vote:MafiaSSK

[Kise]

I can't guarantee that Sabre is actually town but an SK in the game is quite unlikely (look at the night kill results I doubt that the SK's kills crossed with night mafia and/or got protected 2 nights in a row).

Neutral/3rd-Party could also indicate Survivor. Check this link out for other roles -->

http://www.mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php ... hird-party

But, I have my doubts that SSK is cop and really investigated saber. We'll see soon.

[Sando]

Miller could go both ways in knowing whether or not they're a miller.

Night SK seems highly unlike given the kills that have happened, and we know for sure that there is a night-mafia. Day-SK seems fairly unlikely, but not hugely so.

This reply from SSK to why he didn't think BCs claim was valid:

Because I'm a cop too.

This makes no sense given that he knew the flavour of cop, IE that he could only get guilties on day mafia, so any reasonable person would given credence to the idea of another cop, and a night-cop at that.

I'm trying to wrap my head around the 'neutral' result. I would have thought a cop would get a guilty on a anti-town role like SK. Also, why claim it if it's not true? It makes the claim much less believable, and best case scenario for the claimer is we believe it's an SK and lynch them. I don't see why a real cop would get that result, or why a fake-cop would claim it. Also, none of the sanity's would return a neutral result afaik.