Mafia #100 - Game Over

[X]

Vote Count

Battle Mage

: (4) tubby216, qwints, Benmage, Black Jinx

hewitt

: (1) randomlunatic

qwints

: (1) Kise

Not Voting

: (10) Hulk, dramonic, hewitt, Slicey, magichands, orangepenguin, Snow White, Volume, DeathNote, Battle Mage

Vote Threshold

: 9

Happiness with Posting Level

:

Satisfied

ConfidAnon has requested replacement. Hulk replaces ConfidAnon. Thanks, Hulk!

[tubby216]

a power role claim, obviously.

qwints that would've been an impossible claim for BloodCovenent if he was scum after we attacked him for breadcrumbing and he denied it. So why after that did you assume that he would claim a power role after he'd already denied the apparent breadcrumbing to turn around and say oh just kidding I actually was.

Not really. He was attacked for soft claiming a role that knew another's alignment. That leaves plenty of PR's (most likely doctor) for him to claim.

BM, perhaps you didn't notice but Pomegranate flipped doctor. Somebody's got some splaining to do.

unvote, vote: Battle Mage

i really do not like this post by qwints, there could very well be two doc's in this game however its highly doubtful that BM is a second doc,,,,,,,,,,,,, more on that later

[tubby216]

BC's first post seems town. Why would he want me here if he was scum?
12 by Magichands seems a bit over-stated.
14 by BC is really unnecessary.
25 by Kise is overly-cautious.
32 by Konowa is highly protown.
39 by Volume is scummy. Especially if BC is town methinks.
131 by BC is very scummy, as is his use of the cop breadcrumb as a defence.

Got bored. BC could well be scum. Magichands is 100% obvtown.

Vote: BC

================[[]]

Hammah Baby!

Gdnight all.

BM

This is not a town aligned BM post this is BM scumm posting, pro town BM would have dug a lil deeper. pro-scum BM is reckless and figures he has more his team so it doesn't matter if he gets caught or not

Okay so this is what I'm taking away from the nightkills, the Sicilian Mafia Goon probably means that there's more than one Mafia faction. I'm guessing there's either three Mafia factions or two and a vigilante/serial killer.

i dont remember ever seeing 3 mafia groups in a large normal...

Love the way Tubby just owned Hewitt.

Also amused that 3 of the people i would have potentially pursued today, all got killed. Should be advantageous.

BM

pay attention to the bolded part you just kinda left this out there also not cool


now onto the replacements,,, how are you reads goin? anything to input now?

[Battle Mage]

BC's first post seems town. Why would he want me here if he was scum?
12 by Magichands seems a bit over-stated.
14 by BC is really unnecessary.
25 by Kise is overly-cautious.
32 by Konowa is highly protown.
39 by Volume is scummy. Especially if BC is town methinks.
131 by BC is very scummy, as is his use of the cop breadcrumb as a defence.

Got bored. BC could well be scum. Magichands is 100% obvtown.

Vote: BC

================[[]]

Hammah Baby!

Gdnight all.

BM

This is not a town aligned BM post this is BM scumm posting, pro town BM would have dug a lil deeper. pro-scum BM is reckless and figures he has more his team so it doesn't matter if he gets caught or not

Why did you not mention this until now? Also, do me a favour, and don't tell me what protown BM WOULD do-it looks silly from my PoV. Scum-BM is not reckless at all. You've seen me as scum right? And you've seen me as town. Tell me-which alignment do i fare better as?

Okay so this is what I'm taking away from the nightkills, the Sicilian Mafia Goon probably means that there's more than one Mafia faction. I'm guessing there's either three Mafia factions or two and a vigilante/serial killer.

i dont remember ever seeing 3 mafia groups in a large normal...

Love the way Tubby just owned Hewitt.

Also amused that 3 of the people i would have potentially pursued today, all got killed. Should be advantageous.

BM

pay attention to the bolded part you just kinda left this out there also not cool

whats wrong with that?

Tbh, if Tubby cant read me as town here, then im probably doomed. It's possible he is scum, but if he is, so is Hewitt, so you guys can work that out on your own. I dont see a Mafia Watcher playing as Tubby has.

I'll get some more thoughts down later, before my inevitable lynch.

BM

[X]

Vote Count

Battle Mage

: (4) tubby216, qwints, Benmage, Black Jinx

hewitt

: (1) randomlunatic

qwints

: (1) Kise

Not Voting

: (10) Hulk, dramonic, hewitt, Slicey, magichands, orangepenguin, Snow White, Volume, DeathNote, Battle Mage

Vote Threshold

: 9

Happiness with Posting Level

:

Satisfied

Over 96 hours have passed since Day 2 began. Prodding magichands and Volume.

[tubby216]

@BM it diddn't hit me until now, Normally i go into a game thinking you are town.

but when you claimed it rang a bell so i went back and re-read and it hit spo i pointed it out,

[Kise]

Still not liking qwints from D1 -- L-1'ing BC and then unvoting with the excuse, "it's too early for a lynch". So what was the purpose of endangering BC with an L-1 vote if you felt it was too early?

Come on, people.

[Benmage]

zzzz this game is dragging. I'd be down for a qwints lynch to be honest. However i think this battle mage claim was a dumb gamble.

[Kise]

If he's really a doc, mafia will kill him. If they don't, then oh well, he can continue to protect.

[Benmage]

If he's really a doc, mafia will kill him. If they don't, then oh well, he can continue to protect.

Hrmmm or they roleblock him, let him live so we mislynch him. Idno, i'm willing to give him a day. No clue why he claimed still, but okay i'll switch back to qwints.

unvote vote qwints

[Battle Mage]

@BM it diddn't hit me until now, Normally i go into a game thinking you are town.

but when you claimed it rang a bell so i went back and re-read and it hit spo i pointed it out,

Well, you're wrong. Sorry, but i'm town. And, frankly, you have nothing to lose by giving me the benefit of the doubt here. Assuming u watch Hewitt, he wont be killed. I'll be protecting you, so if you die, i'll be confirmed scum, and lynched tomorrow. If i'm not a doctor, you were dead before my claim anyway, so it makes no difference. Odds are, scum will kill me tonight, or, if they think i am lynchable, kill someone completely random. Either way, with me alive, you wont be killed. With me dead, you will. Where's the motivation for BM-scum to put myself out in the open like that?

If you think it through, you'll realise that me being scum makes absolutely no sense.

BM

[tubby216]

ok i will play along

unvote

vote: qwints

[dramonic]

Thats no good BM. If you are scum you can just not kill Hewitt and your gambit works

[tubby216]

here is how this works,

BM must protect me tonite,

we must decide on a target for hewitt,,

if i die bm is either scum or roleblocked,

if hewitt fails to kill he is either role blocked or scum

but i will not announce who i am watching, just know tthat it may be either

myself, bm or hewitt

and i will leave it at that.

[tubby216]

right now we should lynch qwints, and have hewitt kill either Deathnote or orangepenguin


what do you all say

[Battle Mage]

Thats no good BM. If you are scum you can just not kill Hewitt and your gambit works

eh? Someone else could have killed Hewitt regardless if i was scum, and i wouldnt be implicated. But, besides killing Hewitt, if i was scum, my claim means my team cannot kill Tubby. Which is nonsensical. Unless ofc, u think i am a complete idiot-scum?

BM

[Battle Mage]

here is how this works,

BM must protect me tonite,

we must decide on a target for hewitt,,

if i die bm is either scum or roleblocked,

if hewitt fails to kill he is either role blocked or scum

but i will not announce who i am watching, just know tthat it may be either

myself, bm or hewitt

and i will leave it at that.

Yep, ill protect you tonight. Tubby, there is no point you watching yourself. I'd suggest keeping the WIFOM down to just 2 players- me and Hewitt. Or alternatively, just say you're going to watch Hewitt. I think me dying might be a best case scenario here, given some people see me as a definite potential mislynch.

How could Hewitt fail to kill? lol

I dont see any reason to suspect a mafia RB. If there is one, they will probably target you tonight, and kill Hewitt.

BM

[Battle Mage]

I dont see any reason to lynch Qwints today. His behaviour towards BC yesterday gives me town-vibes.

BM

[Battle Mage]

Contributed very little to this game, first he defended my wagon here, then he notes that he agree's with something that Dramonic says. That's about all the he said regarding my case. Now he jumps on my wagon with no case of his own. He mentions the "appeal" of mine, which is more of a statement. It shouldn't be regarded as anything important.

He wasn't defending you against Konowa. He was scumhunting; asking Konowa why he voted w/ no explanation. That's not defending you, so, he did not turn 180 because he was never taking your side to begin with.

@BC - Prove your role... how many words are there in the 2nd line of your role PM? How many words in the 3rd line of your role PM? (yes, I'm going there again)

X:

This question is certainly not allowed to be answered.

@Ditto - Ignoring me, are we?

@Konowa - No, the fact that the wagon rose does not prove anything. There are a lot of [town] players here, so when they see a slip, they eat that shit up like piranha food.

This could be a clever gambit, but if not, Kise is almost certainly town too.

BM

[tubby216]

I dont see any reason to lynch Qwints today. His behaviour towards BC yesterday gives me town-vibes.

BM

re-read in iso i find him not so town

[Benmage]

here is how this works,

BM must protect me tonite,

we must decide on a target for hewitt,,

if i die bm is either scum or roleblocked,

if hewitt fails to kill he is either role blocked or scum

but i will not announce who i am watching, just know tthat it may be either

myself, bm or hewitt

and i will leave it at that.

Yep, ill protect you tonight. Tubby, there is no point you watching yourself. I'd suggest keeping the WIFOM down to just 2 players- me and Hewitt. Or alternatively, just say you're going to watch Hewitt. I think me dying might be a best case scenario here, given some people see me as a definite potential mislynch.

How could Hewitt fail to kill? lol

I dont see any reason to suspect a mafia RB. If there is one, they will probably target you tonight, and kill Hewitt.

BM

This doesn't seem smart. If there is a (scum)roleblocker and they block battle mage we have one townie(vig) killing another townie(watcher) seems so idiotic.

The sheer fact that bm is for this makes me think hes even scummier.

[Benmage]

I dont see any reason to lynch Qwints today. His behaviour towards BC yesterday gives me town-vibes.

BM

re-read in iso i find him not so town

word.

[tubby216]

here is how this works,

BM must protect me tonite,

we must decide on a target for hewitt,,

if i die bm is either scum or roleblocked,

if hewitt fails to kill he is either role blocked or scum

but i will not announce who i am watching, just know tthat it may be either

myself, bm or hewitt

and i will leave it at that.

Yep, ill protect you tonight. Tubby, there is no point you watching yourself. I'd suggest keeping the WIFOM down to just 2 players- me and Hewitt. Or alternatively, just say you're going to watch Hewitt. I think me dying might be a best case scenario here, given some people see me as a definite potential mislynch.

How could Hewitt fail to kill? lol

I dont see any reason to suspect a mafia RB. If there is one, they will probably target you tonight, and kill Hewitt.

BM

This doesn't seem smart. If there is a (scum)roleblocker and they block battle mage we have one townie(vig) killing another townie(watcher) seems so idiotic.

The sheer fact that bm is for this makes me think hes even scummier.

so you think hewitt scum?? or did you miss the part where we direct his kill tonite

[Kise]

I'm still not favorable on directing the vig. It's hewitt's choice, but I think he should definitely not target BM nor tubby tonight so we have a chance to see if these roleclaims ring true at all.

[Battle Mage]

I dont see any reason to lynch Qwints today. His behaviour towards BC yesterday gives me town-vibes.

BM

re-read in iso i find him not so town

Erm, i just did reread him in iso. Thats when i made the post you quoted. Qwints is a poor choice for lynch.

BM