That wasn't generating discussion nor was it asking trivia questions. I did that so I could figure out who would be posting in the middle of the night, and not respond to something critical at say, 8 PM on a Thursday my time when people are likely to check posts. The question had nothing to do with discussion, and was more for my personal note to reference when waiting for someone specific to post.DT wrote: @Ice
@Timezone discussion
You sir fail at discussion stimulation. It's like asking trivia questions: You are contributing, but not contributing anything of substance which rubs me the wrong way.
Ok then.DTMaster
@Mindgamer
I had the pleasure to mod pwnman. He is very anti-town newbie, but gut instinct says I need more time to get a better read. You should also look at join dates.
You don't understand what I'm talking about. That's not what I'm saying at all; for instance, I wouldn't be able to tell you whether I think pwnman is Fire or Ice Mafia; there's no distinguishable thing between them at this point.DTMaster wrote:The fact that crazy says you must specificity scum factions is retardly naive and dumb. As town, you don't specify likely scum factions untill you have scum flips. You do however, specifiy scum links between people as potential partners.
On that logic, you should be at least as suspicious of pwnman as you are of SK, if not more. Are you?Deer wrote:The thing is, I think it's stupid to even suggest that mindgamer is fire/ice mafia based on a blatantly obvious joke. I find SK pretty scummy for insinuating that in the first place, along with the piggybacking thing DT and I (kind of) brought up.
Epic fail. 2 votes is NOT a bandwagon in a 12 person game. Hell it isn't a bandwagon in a 7 person gameXScorpion wrote:Because pwnman was joining the wagon, not starting it.dtmaster wrote:Interesting, why is Saint Kerrigan's post more valid then pwnmans? Why is pwnman's wagon vote scummy?
Also the nice OMGUS vote gives me good reason to leave my vote right where it is.
The original idea that SK had about the slip was that Mindgamer was Ice Mafia because Mindgamer said ICE was obv-Fire Mafia, and that sounds like a scum-slip for Mindgamer (as in, he knew ICE wasn't Ice Mafia.) I never bought into that, but that's not the point.DTM wrote:@Crazy
Tell me, how is town supposed to make the distinction from ice/fire mafia in 3 pages, no night kills, day start game? Town is not concerned in making distinctions between Ice/Fire slips, town is only determined in finding scum slips in general of either factions.
These were the options:DTM wrote:What's troubling is no one seem to caught on that SK focused specifically on Mindgamer for an Ice slip, and Crazy is joining in on the pwnwagon for not saying Mind is Ice scum, rather pwn finds Mindgamer scummy.
Isn't the fact that SK said Mindgamer is potential ice scum ringing red flags for you? Why would, SK, be so specific in Mindgamer's post and accuse him as ice scum.Crazy wrote:The original idea that SK had about the slip was that Mindgamer was Ice Mafia because Mindgamer said ICE was obv-Fire Mafia, and that sounds like a scum-slip for Mindgamer (as in, he knew ICE wasn't Ice Mafia.) I never bought into that, but that's not the point.
is a slip in itself because only fire scum would know this. Also this post:Crazy wrote:Option E - "Mindgamer is Fire Mafia, and the post was a scum-slip" does not exist.
Just says: Mindgamer is Ice, or Fire, or Town. You are contributing thin air.Crazy wrote:A. Mindgamer is town, and the post was a joke.
B. Mindgamer is Ice Mafia, and the post was a joke.
C. Mindgamer is Fire Mafia, and the post was a joke.
D. Mindgamer is Ice Mafia, and the post was a scum-slip.
No the fact that you just cleared Mindgamer from firescum in certain scenerios isCrazy wrote: I find option D farfetched in itself; but the fact that pwnman agreed that Mindgamer made a scum-slip, and then said that Mindgamer was either Fire Mafia or Ice Mafia showed that pwnman had no idea what he was talking about, and was just piggybacking off of SK's argument while understanding nothing. That's very scummy.
I should add.Mindgamer wrote:I like the RVS.
Vote: ICEninja
Obviously Fire Mafia.
My timezone is UTC+1 / GMT+1.
I'm trying to explain my case on pwnman; not trying to evaluate Mindgamer's alignment.DTM wrote:Just says: Mindgamer is Ice, or Fire, or Town. You are contributing thin air.
There's nothing wrong with agreeing with somebody else's case, silly. Otherwise, we'd never lynch anybody. The problem is that pwnman never understood SK's argument about Mindgamer to begin with, and still followed with his vote.DTM wrote: @Crazy
1. Why would you need to explain Scott's argument to me? You and Saint are using Scott's argument and attacking pwnman. If anything: you are pwnman 2.0. doing the same thing he was.
