Just to give everyone an idea:
17. SpyreX -
133
(+13 from SV)
10. JacobSavage - 91
4. SIR CYANIDE - 62
8. LukePukeDuke - 11 (+42 from Konowa)
14. Papa Zito - 22 (+1 from Fugitive, +28 from Farside)
6. Unsight - 39
18. InflatablePie - 37 (as of this post; +2 from Henry)
20. Nikanor - 1 (+34 from Maemuki, +3 from Julano)
12. Leafsnail - 33
15. Pomegranate - 19 (+9 from Shadow Dancer)
Most posts per playerslot: SpyreX (146)
Median posts per playerslot: Unsight/InflatablePie (39)
Least posts per playerslot: Jag Johan (26)
Average posts per playerslot: About 55
Mod posts: 58
Going solely on number of posts, I would be more than willing to pick anyone below me/Unsight. If I had to pick an order, I'd go with something like Nikanor, Pom, Jag, Leafsnail.
Again, this list isn't counting content, just post count. Just going by things off the top of my head at 6 AM, here's a different rainbow-list:
InflatablePie
JacobSavage*
Papa Zito
SpyreX
Unsight
SIR CYANIDE
~~~~~
Leafsnail
Jag Johan
Pomegranate
Nikanor
LukePukeDuke
*I'd like to mention the highly unlikely (IMO) but possible chance of a Mafia Role Cop.