I don't think that you are defending robotnik, I think you are excluding him from this death list even though he has displayed the same scum tells as some of the people on it, most notably your primary lynch target. I don't understand why. Are you trying to give him a second chance?
A lot of it is the MS vote. A whole lot.
Rggh, I'm digging your style, Spy, but I wish you'd chosen someone other than MS. I know you won't take meta arguments, but when I was literally in a game that was running AS THIS GAME was running and was scum, and got MS lynched with essentially exactly the same sort of reasons, I'm really not hungry to jump on the wagon.
Also, could you detail a littlem ore clearly your view of the claims? I know you've made a few predictions but there's a lot of bustle in your (admittedly awesome) posts and I just want to nail down where you are on them.
I dig that and if this is just lol, play welp. As it sits though I can't buy it. The volume of nothing is amazing.
The claims?
Nhammen is probably a roleblocker - its such a weird role to LIE about. Alignment? Yep, even though he's on my death list I still say town by a margin.
The Masons? Well, aside from the crazy lord who is just crazy Faraday seems pretty town sooo I think it might have been smoke-and-mirrors moddery where by not SLAM DUNK confirming them they eat each other alive (see crazy lord).
Further I have an issue with symmetry and Lynch is my #1 town read BEFORE the claim so the mystical last member probably town.
Is there others I've missed?
Ehhhhhhhhh....
No I can't do it. My gut just keeps insisting that he is town.
His vote on Sevis keeps sending me for loops. I need to evaluate what night talk the night before would lead up to that post, what that would say about any scum team that he is a part of and what his scum buddies would have done when he made that post. (I want to say a MS with a team would have been coached into not making a vote that is guaranteed to draw the ire of others.)
SHHH You're spoling a SECRET REVELATION if I'm right about him.
-----
Additionally I can swing without too much sad to any of that killing list AND MAYBE EVEN ROBOTNIK MAYBE.