NY 114: Mafia vs. Werewolves (Game Over)

[Pomegranate]

Thoughts on Dr. Robotnik lynch: As I am on his bandwagon, I would most defindently be glad to see him gone. However, I suggest waiting until Dr. Robotnik claims at L-1 before deciding if we should lynch him then or not.

He's at L-4. There's time yet.

[Unsight]

Midnight's Sorrow: I feel like Midnight's Sorrow hasn't been the most exceptional of town players, but I also haven't seen a good case against him. Yes, he hasn't really pushed the game forward in any significant way, but he's done more than plenty of people in this game. Overall, I'm leaning town.

Socrates: SGR was scummy as hell to me, but Socrates is not. He also has an interesting relationship with nhammenscum... The jury's still out on this one.

Lowell: Not much to say about Lowell. Hell, I didn't even know he was in the game... Which, in most instances, would point to scum, but this is Lowell we're talking about....

I would join the Dr. Robotnik wagon, but seeing Nacho go all-out against such an easy (if scummy) target without mentioning the other wagons rubs me the wrong way.

I believe that if Dr. Robotnik was town, then he would've been lynched on Day 1. People (including Vi) attempted to smash through wagons on him, and failed. If he were town, I'm sure that both scumteams would've jumped on that opportunity and managed to bring enough town to their side for a lynch...

What do you see as the relationship between Socrates and nhammen?

And why would Robotnik's wagon not exploding be a tell? There wasn't a shortage of wagons yesterday.

[Parama]

LOLwell is all I can say.

ALSO.
Guys, we are lynching out of
{Midnight's Sorrow, Shrinehime, Timeeater, Nhammen} today. Stop playing Lynch all Lurkers and DO SOMETHING FFS.

Also Pome is almost certainly scum, just sayin' just sayin'. Not liking any of her recent posts (wasn't paying attention to earlier ones but now I'm interested.)

I am convinced.

Vote: Dr. Robotnik

.

Is this REALLY all you have to say on the matter?

[Pomegranate]

No. But I am in a week of finals, so the answer is yes for right now.

[Midnight's Sorrow]

Sevis/Shrine is scum.

This slot has done far more genuine scum tells then most of the people being voted for today. He posts have been nothing

but

Anti-Town, almost always contradicting of themselves. Several people have been down his back last D-1, and now, now that a NP has gone by, these very same people(Sanzing Vi of course ) are suddenly having cold feet on this slot. A slot that they were so sure was scum last DP. Add to the fact that YET again this slot is going to get away, this slot is seeing so much resistance for being lynched, it isn't even funny. Especially when all anyone has to do is ISO the slot to figure out that he is the answer to this DP's question.

If we're to go with the WIFOM that MAYBE the werewolves killed Vi to frame Sevis/Shrine, there's only two options. This slot is either Town, or its Mafia. Based on his posts, Town is out of the question, so that leaves only being Mafia. So I ask the rest of the Town, whats the difference between Mafia and Werewolves to us???

Let me answer for you, there isn't one. Either one is scum, both of which is our solemn duty to our Wincon to expunge.

So ask you all now. Whats the bloody hold up?? It sure as hell aint me, thats for sure.

[Shrinehme]

I've mostly caught up, barring a few pages.

Vote: Dr. Robotnik

lynch is great.

[Parama]

unvote, vote: Shrinehme

[Lowell]

@ssbf- because this wagon is in not smart, but I'm tired of arguing the point. I've explained why socrates is the obvious choice, but I'm willing to vote robo if that's what we're doing.

[Shrinehme]

Add to the fact that YET again this slot is going to get away, this slot is seeing so much resistance for being lynched, it isn't even funny.

Actually I'm pretty much on everyone's list except SSBF's. No one is explicitly resisting. Dr. Robotnik & others are just higher up.

If we're to go with the WIFOM that MAYBE the werewolves killed Vi to frame Sevis/Shrine, there's only two options. This slot is either Town, or its Mafia. Based on his posts, Town is out of the question, so that leaves only being Mafia.

I don't see why Vi has to have been killed to frame anyone. A power player is a threat to anyone if he's not on their side.

Town is in the question. Sevis was newb/VI/whatever.

[Midnight's Sorrow]

Add to the fact that YET again this slot is going to get away, this slot is seeing so much resistance for being lynched, it isn't even funny.

Actually I'm pretty much on everyone's list except SSBF's. No one is explicitly resisting. Dr. Robotnik & others are just higher up.

There are several signs of resistance, one being people finding the slot scummy, but going for the easy lynch instead. Resistance. It is not black and white.

If we're to go with the WIFOM that MAYBE the werewolves killed Vi to frame Sevis/Shrine, there's only two options. This slot is either Town, or its Mafia. Based on his posts, Town is out of the question, so that leaves only being Mafia.

I don't see why Vi has to have been killed to frame anyone. A power player is a threat to anyone if he's not on their side.

Town is in the question. Sevis was newb/VI/whatever.[/quote]

No. Sevis was not newb/VI/whatever. Vi himself even said his play this game was unlike him.

[Shrinehme]

There are several signs of resistance, one being people finding the slot scummy, but going for the easy lynch instead..

Let's be serious here.

Sevis lynch is easier than the Robotnik one. Latter can defend his actions.

No. Sevis was not newb/VI/whatever. Vi himself even said his play this game was unlike him.

Never seen Sevis play before tbh.

I guess you can verify his by looking through his games.

[Midnight's Sorrow]

There are several signs of resistance, one being people finding the slot scummy, but going for the easy lynch instead..

Let's be serious here.

Sevis lynch is easier than the Robotnik one. Latter can defend his actions.

But I was being serious. Are you trying to use the Replacement Halo card here?

Heres where he said so about Sevis:

I don't disagree with Lowell accusing Sevis tbh. I keep getting the impression of an experienced player holding way way way back.

[SpyreX]

I'll hammer this but under extreme distaste. Even shrine is better than this and thats with MS being such a proponent.

[Super Smash Bros. Fan]

I'm going to look into Lowell more. I'm starting to get a bad vibe off of him.

@ssbf- because this wagon is in not smart, but I'm tired of arguing the point. I've explained why socrates is the obvious choice, but I'm willing to vote robo if that's what we're doing.

Okay then, here's a question. Do you think Dr. Robotnik is town?

[Lowell]

Meh, who knows. I have no opinion. He's not as obviuosly scum as socrates, which is what's annoying.

[nhammen]

1) inconsistent posting and lurking are very different things. Inconsistent posting is refering to him appearing when he needs to defend himself, and then disappearing when the wagon cools down.

Oh. Tell me more.

Parama needs to be on the must-die list but the rest is fine with me.

This is why you're a brick wall.

Posting for the sake of posting is uncool.

But I'm not posting for the sake of posting.

I'm posting for the sake of telling you why you're absolutely wrong.

Because saying "your wrong" is the same thing as telling

why

someone is wrong. I'm glad you cleared that up.


I've noticed I'm in a very sarcastic mood today...

Sevis/Shrine is scum.

This slot has done far more genuine scum tells then most of the people being voted for today. He posts have been nothing

but

Anti-Town, almost always contradicting of themselves. Several people have been down his back last D-1, and now, now that a NP has gone by, these very same people(Sanzing Vi of course ) are suddenly having cold feet on this slot. A slot that they were so sure was scum last DP. Add to the fact that YET again this slot is going to get away, this slot is seeing so much resistance for being lynched, it isn't even funny. Especially when all anyone has to do is ISO the slot to figure out that he is the answer to this DP's question.

I've been considering joining this wagon, but I am giving the replacement a few RL days so that I have enough posts to get a good read.

[Dry-fit]

ALSO.
Guys, we are lynching out of
{Midnight's Sorrow, Shrinehime, Timeeater, Nhammen} today. Stop playing Lynch all Lurkers and DO SOMETHING FFS.

Why should we be limited to lynching them? In my experience claiming that a certain group of players are the only lynch choices is a scum tactic.

I do agree with you about pomegranate though. I don't remember one protown post coming from her.

[foilist13]

@nhammen: This was primarily referring to yesterday, where several people commented on you doing exactly what I described. This is not the primary reason you are on my list however. I think you should be lynched because I don't trust your claim, but if it proves true it would strongly discredit socrates.

[LimMePls]

Alright, as much as I want MS to DIAF, this is just too obvious.

Unvote
Vote: Shrinehme

Pack your bags Shrine scum, its time to go.

[SpyreX]

Good lord and dry-fit comes out a swingin' with a big wiffer.

Looks like he's gonna fall on that sad side of things.

[Socrates]

Whoo.

unvote, vote:Shrine

[SpyreX]

I'm holding for hammer but I approve of this.

[foilist13]

They're both on my scum list. If the robotnik wagon isn't going to pick up anymore steam I'll hit up the shrine wagon. I'll say that will happen once shrine's wagon exceedes robotnik's.

[Faraday]

WE SHOULD LYNCH SOCRATES GUYS. WHY WON'T ANYONE LYNCH SOCRATES.

I think Robotnik's slightly better than SHRIN having read back but I'm good with either so let's get this done so I can go to my masonry and LOL DISCUSS stuff.

If we have a vig they best be fucking shootan tonight. There's enough targets ofr 6 vigs so ship up and shoot

[Leafsnail]

MS is making awesome arguments against Shrine, and is definately not relying on the words of a dead townie to make his case. And he's definately not creating a strawman by talking about NK WIFOM repeatedly.