Mini 1088: Cookie Thief Mafia (Game Over)

[RobCapone]

I hate you.

I don't trust this andrew kid

[Kublai Khan]

just because you say B is A, doesn't make it A

You've giving this lesson? Hilarious.

a scum in the girl's club would want all the girl's club to remain alive so that they could hide
a scum in the girl's club would want to use the girl's club as a cover for their scum team
a scum in the girl's club would not have outted the girl's club, therefore

that last one I disagree with

WHY do you disagree with the last one? give EVIDENCE that is the case

What better way to remove an investigative ability from the game? Out yourself, get one lynched, then night-kill the other one. You'll probably get lynched next, but the removal of a 2 pro-town half cops was swiftly accomplished.

Especially since your group only learns flavor-name, which is usually useless to scum unless there's some sort of deathnote mechanic in play.

[lewarcher82]

Since I am receiving no answers at all, I will proceed with what I already have, which, actually, is more than enough.
I said I am have missed something. There you go:

I unvoted Poison. This was a bad move. I had missed a blatant slip. I will now explain.

When furco stated to be "blue", I thought that he was using a common offsite-terminology, by whicih a townie is a "blue nilla" (used for instance on epicmafia).

So there was nothing odd in the fact that Poison was unable to understand the statement "I'm blue" by furco.

I was wrong.

I re-read my PM, and I re-read this thread, and I realised that we missed a crucial point.

Town players' PMs contain two words in blue.

Cookie Scout

. I know this because I am a town-aligned player.

Furco knows that too. And the only way he can know it is that he got these two blue words in his message as well.

However, furco is necessarily a neighbour, and neighbours are also pink. The consequence is that they receivd a message stating they are

neighbours

AND

cookie scouts

.

This is 100% demonstrated: if the neighbours only had pink in their role-description, then furco could not have possibly mentioned being blue.

Unfortunately, Poison's reiterated reaction to the being-blue-statement by furco clearly shows that she had no idea there was any blue in the town-players PMs.

Check out her post #134. Check out her post #197. Check ouot her post #228. And again #237. And again #262.

Therefore, she is either scum or a third party.

vote: PoisonIvy

This is a scumslip, Poison. Talk yourself out of this if you can.

[FakeGod]

VoteCount 1.12

drmyshottyizsik (1): andrew94
Darox (1): Llamarble
PoisonIvy (3): Furcolow, Elleran, lewarcher82
Furcolow (1): PoisonIvy,
Stigmata (1): drmyshottyizsik
Zed (1): , gzapsa
andrew94 (3): RobCapone, Darox, Kublai Khan

Not voting: Zed

With 12 people alive, town needs 7 votes to lynch someone.

[RobCapone]

Interesting observation, with her giving up and now this, I want to hear from her

[lewarcher82]

Interesting observation, with her giving up and now this, I want to hear from her

implying that you are not contesting my reconstruction of the colors that should appear in your PM. Which is good, since you are the third neighbour.

which settles it, I think.

[RobCapone]

Nope your assessment is dead on balls accurate

[PoisonIvy]

What the deuce?! WHERE THE HELL IS MY ANSWER?!?!?!? :@



















Tis lucky i always copy before reply.
Right. I has misfits downloading so i have little time for games.

So called ignored lewarcher questions.
Re town reason for claiming inv. immune: well generally the reaction one recieves is typical of here. I dont like Andrew's actions, but his backstory to odd olivia is enough to make me stop and ponder.

Re: names or alignment i made the same mistake and was corrected by da mod. We only recieve role names.

lewarcher. yay! you got it. i wasnt so sure if i could go into detail myself and how would people understand but yes girl scouts are pink. While we/i am essentially a good blue cookie scout, we are not blue. Back a few pages fucr claimed that he was blue town. When i asked him about this he was like "wtf pink?" But that cant be right because my role as a girl scout is i am pink. I will flip pink. Not blue. We will see.

Ivy: GIRL SCOUT MEMBERS ARE NOT BLUE THEY'RE PINK!!!! What do you mean you are blue? "
Fucr: Actually, mine is blue. I doubt yours is pink. It is guaranteed to be red.. book it

He later goes onto backpedal in the giant walls of rabbling text by claiming his is both blue and pink. Which it is. But that to me is beside the point of his inital denial.

Andrew. You have asked robcapone why you are so scummy when i already have a list of the scummy things you have done.
ps. how is disclosing your "no alignment" helpful to town? Preferably i would have prefered if you had left breadcrumbs or something to the like.
Next. Olivia is a girls name and you are not in the girls club?
Re: blank life. You have 3 lives?

welcome gz.

Your strategy of "Hey lynch one of the other guys" is so goddamn stupid and anti-town that you're probably scum for suggesting it.

is something i am on board with .

Elleran. BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAAA. You're following that looney tune with what cause?

fucr. So you are saying you'll lynch me when i flip town and then hypothetically as town you will offer up yourself which

equals two towns down.

my my my. With all this neighbour lynching it would surprize me in the slightest that were you town, Rob would be killed N1 and then that's 3neighbours down but one abiliy scum dont have to worry about! Or, would town hold onto you D2, just cause you're a neighbour with an ability? What a coop for a scum!

a scum in the girl's club would want all the girl's club to remain alive so that they could hide
a scum in the girl's club would want to use the girl's club as a cover for their scum team
a scum in the girl's club would not have outted the girl's club, therefore

WIFOM.

Rob. Fucr is full of shit. He will not quit mafiascum when i flip town. Besides he said "almost" full of sheet. FULL OF SHEET!!

Re: neighbours blue and pink. I've stated it above and if you are not satisfied i await te noose. In a self indulgent way that i hope shuts fucr and his gang of vultures up.
Lewarcher82 is innocent. That's all i can say.

Noose pleaze! Robert Sheehan is on and i just LOVE Robert Sheehan. :3

[RobCapone]

I bet fake god is sitting back laughing at us right now

If I had to pick, I still say furc over ivy but neighbors should go into night 1 as a trio, in case mafia is in there

And despite her overreactions, ivy makes more logical sense.

Also did I miss something, how does furc know mafia is red?

[PoisonIvy]

@Rob. Laughing his darn pants off! hell give me a week or so and i probably will too.

Secondly PM.

And mafia commonly flip red.

[lewarcher82]

PoisonPoison, darling, you never mentioned the fact that neighbours are pink AND BLUE before my last post, unless I missed it.
And if I did not miss it, you are not answering my case.

Rob: I do not understand on what you base your trust in Ivy, since you just confirmed my reconstruction.
What you say about furco mentioning red is pointless. Almost all mafia roles are written in red.

No one here likes furco's play. He is terrible. But still I believe he managed to make poison slip.

It is evident that Poison was completely unaware that there was something blue. If she had blue AND pink in her role description, she wouldn't have reacted the way she did in the posts I listed above.

[RobCapone]

First based on info in QT, furc wanted to work together and got us talking, than threw us under the bus and now denies it, saying fevers away and didn't have a chance to post

Second he switched his stance, first he comes after me and than ivy making it seem like he was suspicious of her this whole time, yet he went for me first which contradicts that in my mind

He is trying to hard to earn town cred

I don't trust ivy either but I'm more cautious of furc who had exposed us as a huge target to mafia, it's careless and reckless and not very pro town. If they kill us all off, we have no info to share.

[lewarcher82]

Still, Rob, I fail to see any other explanation for her reaction to the "I'm blue"-statement. And if my explanation is the right explanation, then she cannot by any means be town, and she should be lynched...

can you offer me a convincing alternative explanation?

[PoisonIvy]

MY ROLES GIRL SCOUT NOT COOKIE SCOUT. HENCE IM PINK!

Essentially im a blue cookie scout but my ranting and raving was directed at fucr who said he was town blue.

Why blue and not pink? We're girl scouts not cookie scouts. Hence pink, not blue. From my point of view he did not acknowledge that we were pink for some time. Thus he is ilk scum. None of his actions make SENSE.

Btw. lewarcher bad play dear chap. You're losing town. But you can deal with the fiasco of an aftermath later on top of furcolow's confusion. GOOD LUCK to deceiphering his rants and raves. He's leading you all BLINDLY and his confusing actions regarding the game, flip flop decision making and the belief town SHOULD follow him will be hilarious to watch from my viewpoint.

Still, not my most hated game. Actually as i agreed earier, give me a week and i will laugh at everyone, bar Darox, Kublai and Rob.

[andrew94]

and the blank cookie is prob a blank alignment, because i believe cops check the cookies that you have. and the cookies are your life.

if you read the first page, a cookie goes missing = someone dies

So you don't actually know if you're investigation immune and you're just assuming it?
And yet you claimed to be investigation immune unprompted?

I hate you.

fcks sakes.
it says that i have 2 blank cookies, if someone is to check me, they get 'no alignment '. i dont know about name cops?
and i have 2 extra lives

[andrew94]

I hate you.

I don't trust this andrew kid

where did i say 'i hate you'

[RobCapone]

Quote tag got messed up, was trying to quote darox who said it

[RobCapone]

Still, Rob, I fail to see any other explanation for her reaction to the "I'm blue"-statement. And if my explanation is the right explanation, then she cannot by any means be town, and she should be lynched...

can you offer me a convincing alternative explanation?

No I just didn't weigh it as heavily as I guess I should be. I too thought of epic mafia when he said blue

[PoisonIvy]

Andrew are you illiterate do you just neglect to read up questions to you?

Why do you think if your name is olivia that you are not a member of the girl scouts?

[lewarcher82]

MY ROLES GIRL SCOUT NOT COOKIE SCOUT. HENCE IM PINK!

@Rob, does this make any sense to you? Is being a neighbour a reason for not being "blue"?

@Poison: look, I will try to make it clearer, so you will perhaps decide to answer without acting outraged:
- I know that blue is the color of scouts.
- If you want to know it, I also have a female name, but I am blue anyway.
- furco knew that scouts are blue, otherwise he would not have referred to it.
- there are no colors in the flavor posts by mod, so furco could not possibly guess that blue was the color of town unless he knew.
- EVEN ROB CONFIRMED ME THAT A TOWN NEIGHBOUR HAS A BLUE ROLE.
- still you keep denying this fact, and you avoid answering my points.

Are you or are you not a cookie scout? And if not, why are the other GC members cookie scouts?

[RobCapone]

My role pm had both tbh

[PoisonIvy]

*breath* Essentially yes neighbours are blue, because i for one am town. But when our role is girl scouts, its only natural to me we are pink. Rather than blue. And when i mentioned it to fucr he seemed abashed by it and didnt seem to know what i was talking about.

[lewarcher82]

You're a blue? FYI girl scouts are pink.

GIRL SCOUT MEMBERS ARE NOT BLUE THEY'RE PINK!!!! What do you mean you are blue?

Furcolow is not pink. He has said we was BLUE. Girl scouts are PINK.

Going back again

town

, girl scouts are pink. fucr has claimed to be blue.

And now you say you are blue?

*breath* Essentially yes neighbours are blue, because i for one am town.

LoL

you should decide if neighbours are blue or not, girl. You really should.

@everyone: comments? anyone cannot see the case I presented?

[andrew94]

Andrew are you illiterate do you just neglect to read up questions to you?

Why do you think if your name is olivia that you are not a member of the girl scouts?

how am i supposed to know

[Kublai Khan]

@everyone: comments? anyone cannot see the case I presented?

Looks absolutely solid. Good job. As loathe as I am to admit it, it looks like Furcolow was right (although for all the wrong reasons).

So should we lynch her today or not?

Pros: RobCapone and Furcolow can outvote her as to their groups investigation/roleblocking target (she is neutralized). Might be able to squeeze an extra night of investigation out of them.
Cons: Why should we keep a scum alive any longer than they need to be? Scum flip will give us knowledge of how scum flavor names look.