Mini 1088: Cookie Thief Mafia (Game Over)

[Furcolow]

i don't care if you all don't want to vote with me
fail town and a really weird setup is not a good mix

[Zed]

Have you ever wondered that perhaps I'm bold because I'm Darox?

Just curious.

I have, but I've never seen you play before, so I wouldn't know if this is normal or not. It comes off as normal, but I still have to wonder why scum would draw so much attention to themself.

@Zed: well, yeah, it is possible... so you think there was only one town aligned player in the GC - the one whose lynch I pushed - and the other two are scum... definitely possibile, why not? Actually, the two attempts by furco at lynching rob never became bw's... I can only say I hope this is not the case...

heh, yeah, I don't usually pay a lot of attention to voting on this site. There is usually so much jumping around it doesn't help all that much. I did notice that no one really voted Rob with Furc, but he seemed like he was trying pretty hard to get a Rob lynch and present him in a bad light. I just know I'm not ruling anything out at this point, but I also wouldn't be surprised if there was no scum in the GC.

@zed. You don't get to be inactive and miss all discussions and than criticize who we used our action on, until you post regularly you have no position in this game. It was mentioned that our target was chosen, shotty was the one mentioned and nobody objected

Now if you fucking read you would see I suggested other names to furc but he chose shotty, I had no choice to go along because if I voted somebody else we stalemate and furc would be in here trying to throw me under the bus

Also Zed we only get name, if you were paying attention you would have known that. This is why I hate lurkers with a passion and if zed is alive at lylo she is costing the game, she has cost town game before

I was not criticizing your choice of investigation, I was criticizing how you made your choice. No one probably objected because, probably, no one thought you would go through with investigating shotty just because no one objected. the whole town doesn't have the power of investigation, GC does. So I don't think the whole town should have any real input on who gets investigated, but then again, if I had it my way the whole town wouldn't know about the GC.

and yes, I do read. I usually read the thread twice before I post to make sure I understand as much as possible. The problem is that yours and Furc's stories don't math. Furc says you suggested three people and made him choose. You said that you thought it was agreed that GC goes off of what the town says. Then you say you were trying to discuss options with Furc. So which is it?

And please be polite when you address me, you came off as very rude.

just read stigmata in iso
unvote;
vote: don johnson

Explanation?

[Zed]

Forgot to say I'm looking at Kublai Khan in ISO right now. If I see something worth mentioning I will, but if not don't expect to hear from me again tonight.

[RobCapone]

I originally said shotty was the only name suggested so I guess we should go with him
I later said if not shotty than darox because he was more suspicious and shotty is playing like shotty
furc says if I am town I should let him choose
I responded with basically I don't trust you
I than berated him for outing girls club because he has narrowed down the potential power roles
I than posted my 3 people and said "we should discuss"
and furc's next post was I sent in shotty and chose you to make the action

he didn't want to discuss he just sent in shotty

[Darox]

Furcolow: What's the flavour justification for you losing your vote?

Still waiting.

[RobCapone]

and by sending in shotty I really had no other choice but to comply.

my only reason was maybe not shotty is
1. do we even know who these people are suggesting him
2. what if shotty was mafia and they thought we were using our action on him, mafia would send somebody else
3. shotty really has played his typical town meta

[andrew94]

so if you eat your cookie, mafia can;t NK?

[Furcolow]

im not going to state the way im losing my vote... how the hell does it help town to lose a town vote
i already stated that it was through someone dying

[Furcolow]

this is also what lead me to believe someone from poisonivy/rob was scum... i felt like the mod gave me a clear to balance it

[Furcolow]

explanation: stigmata's #1 and #2 in iso feel like RVS scumbuddy distancing through voting into an unvote of a partner and talk of shotty and andrew's VIness in #2. Both feel anti-town, and with Elleran's recent forced questioning of me, as of right now I would place the scumteam as Rob, Elleran, and Don Johnson.

I'm being reckless here, sure, but you can't say I'm only attacking people that detract from me, as Don Johnson and I have no beef whatsoever. I am just fairly certain his slot is scum with Elleran due to that interaction, and the interaction he had with the moderator.

[don_johnson]

after the first few pages i can certainly agree that elleran might be scum. if you are convinced that rob is scum, though, you should be pushing that lynch as a robscumflip more or less confirms you, right? did the mod guarantee you that there was scum in the girls club, or are you guys just "neighbors" with a saucy thematic title? it seems people are playing "outguess the mod" here. does anyone have a case on someone else based on something other than set-up speculation? moving on...

[drmyshottyizsik]

so if you eat your cookie, mafia can;t NK?

no if i eat my cookie then i die and day continues, but it simulates a mislynch without a nk after it.

[FakeGod]

Vote Count 2.3

Furcolow (1): Elleran
Darox (1): drmyshottyizsik
drmyshottyizsik (2): Darox, Llamarble
don_johnson (1): Furcolow

Not Voting: andrew94, Zed, don_johnson, RobCapone, lewarcher82

With 10 players, it takes 6 votes to lynch someone.

[RobCapone]

so if you eat your cookie, mafia can;t NK?

no if i eat my cookie then i die and day continues, but it simulates a mislynch without a nk after it.

I want to believe this but I really don't.

[andrew94]

i believe him

[drmyshottyizsik]

I could eat it right now to prove it

[drmyshottyizsik]

not really, but think about it, the mafia is trying to steal cookies, not eat them, if anything this would be a 3rd party role

[RobCapone]

if you are telling the truth how would that be beneficial to town?

p.edit - are you saying you are third party?

I do like that point about stealing not eating

[drmyshottyizsik]

no im not claiming third party, but im saying calling me mafia makes no sense

[Darox]

im not going to state the way im losing my vote... how the hell does it help town to lose a town vote
i already stated that it was through someone dying

You just stated the mechanics.

The flavour doesn't change anything, it just gives us an indication of how much bullshit you are spewing, because flavour is harder to fake.

[lewarcher82]

i don't care if you all don't want to vote with me
fail town and a really weird setup is not a good mix

noise, noise, noise. You told you would quit mafiascum if poison were town. Nevertheless you are still here, asking town to trust you in any case, stating that if town doesn't then town is failtown, and you don't even justify your vote on dj. Consider bowling: easier strategies, less wifom and grammar-skills are not required.

Give it a cut and answer Darox's question.

[Furcolow]

if she flipped town i would almost be willing to quit playing mafia completely

[Furcolow]

you misrepresent the quicktime, gambling, and try to stay middle of the road
who would have reason to do that?
furthermore, if i'm lumping you, darox, and elleran as scum......
and you're telling me to answer darox....
yeah,
thanks for sealing the deal!
rob, you're a noob.

[Furcolow]

this is the last i will talk of this
if a certain player's cookie is eaten, i lose my vote for a day in sadness

[FakeGod]

bump